4 ms·
> I recently learned this is no longer true! AMD EPYC processors (and maybe other recent AMDs?) divide cores into groups called "core complexes" (CCX), each of
by masklinn 5y ago
> I recently learned this is no longer true! AMD EPYC processors (and maybe other recent AMDs?) divide cores into groups called "core complexes" (CCX), each of which has a separate L3 cache.
It's still kinda true, just that "a CPU" in that context is a CCX. Cross CCX communications has shown up a fair bit in reviews and benches, and really in all chips at that scale (e.g. Ampere's Altras and Intel's Xeons): https://www.anandtech.com/show/16529/amd-epyc-milan-review/4 https://www.anandtech.com/show/16529/amd-epyc-milan-review/4 and one of the "improvements" in Zen 3 is the CCX are much larger (there's one CCX per CCD, rather than 2) so there's less crosstalk.
And it could already be untrue previously e.g. the Pentium D were rushed out by sticking two P4 dies on the same PCB, I think they even had to go through the northbridge to communicate, so they were dual socket in all but physical conformation (hence being absolute turds). I don't think they had L3 at all though, so that wasn't really a factor, but still...
- IronWolve 5y agoYup, and why overclocking on AMD tests each of your ccx/cores, marks gold cores that can reach 5ghz+, and slower cores that dont overclock. Also why AMD tests each ccx, and moves worse ones to lower end products, and higher ones to the 5950x. Then you can OC tweak each core and try to milk out performance, PBO tends to be pretty good on detecting which cores with slight performance boost. With a few bios options, all that adds up without effort. And then finally get a better (advanced) scheduler in windows/linux that can move workloads around per core depending on workload. Windows released multiple fixes for the scheduler on AMD starting with win10 1903. I find scheduler mods and modest bios tweaks to increase performance without much effort, very detectable performance. Linux I use xanmod (and pf-kernel before that) Windows I use project lasso and AMD PBO. Slow/fast cores and scheduler tweaks is how win11/arm mac/android, makes things appear faster too. Amusing, scheduler/core tweaks been around for linux for a decade+, making the desktop super smooth, but its now mainstream in win11/arm osx.
- tentacleuno 5y ago> And it could already be untrue previously e.g. the Pentium D were rushed out by sticking two P4 dies on the same PCB, I think they even had to go through the northbridge to communicate Part of me hopes you're wrong here. That is absolutely absurd.
- masklinn 5y agoYeah you'd hope so wouldn't you? But Intel got caught completely unaware by the switch to multi-core, just as it had by the 64b switch. The eventual Core 2 was not ready yet (Intel even had to bridge to it with the intermediate Core, which really had more to do with the Pentium M than with the Core 2 though it did feature a proper dual-core design... so much so that the Core solo was actually a binned Duo with one core disabled). So anyway Intel was caught with its pants around its ankle for the second time and they couldn't let that happen. And they actually beat AMD to market, having turned out a working dual-core design in the time between AMD's announcement of the dual-core opteron (and strong hints of x2) and the actual release, about 8 months. To manage that Intel could not rearchitecture their chip (and probably didn't want to as it'd become clear Netburst was a dead-end), so they stapled two Prescott cores together, FSB included, and connected both to the northbridge. It probably took more time to validate that solution for the server market, which is why where AMD released the dual core Opterons in April and Athlons in May, it took until October for the first dual-core Xeon to be available.
- danudey 5y agoHere's the wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentium_D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentium_D "The Pentium D brand refers to two series of desktop dual-core 64-bit x86-64 microprocessors with the NetBurst microarchitecture, which is the dual-core variant of Pentium 4 "Prescott" manufactured by Intel. Each CPU comprised two dies, each containing a single core, residing next to each other on a multi-chip module package."
- Dylan16807 5y agoThey didn't have to go through the northbridge itself, but they had to go over the frontside bus that connects the CPU to the northbridge (and would normally be point to point).
- sroussey 5y agoThere are core complexes in Apple’s M1 variations as well. And it’s not just L3 that can shared by various chips. Each complex also has its own memory bandwidth, so running on two core in two complexes will get around twice the memory bandwidth of two cores in the same complex.
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoI have that Pentium D -3.4GHz CPU somewhere, It thought me important lessons like CPU clocks mean nothing if the architecture is botched up, to be weary about purchasing first generation compute hardware and more importantly not to trust big-name brands blindly. Not only did I put a hole in my father's monthly budget by paying a premium for this but continued to do so for years with the power bills for this inefficient crap. I remember reading that some politics between intel India-Israel teams led to rushed up design blunder, Couldn't find that article now.