7 ms·
> There is nothing special or magical about this technology... I hope this is not the same thing as the 'use rsync' response when Dropbox was introduced. [0]
by rvz 5y ago
> There is nothing special or magical about this technology...
I hope this is not the same thing as the 'use rsync' response when Dropbox was introduced. [0]
> I hope the whole crypto delusion crumbles as quickly as possible before it takes down the whole world economy with it. Or maybe that is exactly what must happen so that the world wakes up to reality. Maybe that is the whole point of it.
Right. Let us make a start rather than continuously talking about it since it is very difficult for everyone here to ignore it and we will see yet another HN post about cryptocurrencies, Web 3, etc.
How do we get rid of crypto entirely then? Stop everyone using it, shut it down and ban all of it?
EDIT: Good luck attempting to ban cryptocurrencies entirely. Either way, the undeniable trend in all of this is going towards regulations for cryptocurrencies.
It is not going away and we will still continue to keep talking about it and for many on this thread, it will be excruciatingly difficult to ignore it.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863
- agumonkey 5y agoI think 10-15% of the web3 bag is potentially a good idea to do what Dropbox did to many parts of society. Constant, transparent, ubiquitous tracking of shit. A task no one wants to do but causes a lot of friction.
- Traster 5y agoMy big problem with crypto at the moment is that 99% of normal investors are just using exchanges. It’s like we’ve claimed to invent a new technology to replace rsync and it really does exist but it’s worse than rsync, and everyone who thinks they’ve bought in to the new technology are actually buying things from companies that claim to use the new technology and do genuinely have the ability to use the new technology but actually are using rsync 99.99% of the time. Or to put it another way - almost all the transactions are actually off-chain.
- Tenoke 5y agoEyeballing the numbers on Coingecko DEXs seem to have a lot more than 1% of the volume (and this has been steadily growing). Further, most of web3 isn't about payments and where people invest and trade in them has little to do with whether those projects have potential.
- roenxi 5y agoThat doesn't necessarily change how exciting the tech is. The exchanges are working in an asset with known, predictable and locked-in inflation. 3rd parties (cough the US cough) cannot weaponize that asset against the traders. Inter-exchange transfers of wealth are relatively quick and trustworthy, even across borders without trusting any other exchange. That is a pretty substantial change from any existing asset. It isn't all sunshine and roses, but there are a combination of properties here that never existed before.
- gghhzzgghhzz 5y agothere's no regulation, auditing or government backed guarantees / insurance on the exchanges. so what happens when there is a run on an exchange, and it turns out that it does not hold the assets that it has on its books?
- roenxi 5y agoPeople losing all their money (in an entirely foreseeable way) is a tragedy. But it isn't new, that has been a show on repeat for millennia. This time, at least the losses will be in something new. Much like how the first dot com bubble doesn't change the transformative nature of the internet, a massive crash in crypto isn't going to be the end of this story. We might outlive Bitcoin, but no-one alive today will outlive cryptocurrencies. The only real question is how much change they will cause.
- octopoc 5y agoIt's better for society than our current banking system, because the government considers our current system "too big to fail," so banks know that the government will bail them out if things get too bad, and the banks engage in risky behavior accordingly.
- yazaddaruvala 5y agoThat will always be true. Even with a 100% crypto world governments can use taxes/reserves/bonds/tariffs to prop up / bail out failing companies. They just wouldn’t be able to use quantitative easing (easily - i.e. without global consensus) to do it.
- gghhzzgghhzz 5y agoindeed. the promised advantages include de-centralisation, on-chain, and no big financial institutions taking a cut or manipulating rates. yet to practically trade in it you are back to centralisation, off-chain, and the exchanges taking a cut and manipulating rates. and if it made any sense to use it as an actual currency, e.g. to buy coffee, then you are back to centralisation, off-chain, and wallet providers taking a cut.
- Karellen 5y agoAnother interesting comparison is git and GitHub. We invented a new technology to replace CVS/Subversion/SourceSafe/$CENTRALISED_VCS, and it really does exist, and it's better than all of those old systems partly because it really is decentralised, and it's also based on crypto(graphic) primitives, but 99% of the people who think they've bought into it are actually just using another centralised service all over again. Or to put it another way - when GitHub goes down a disturbingly high proportion of a) git users are unable to get any work done at all, and b) build systems just break. (Ok, git didn't invent the DVCS. But it was better enough on a number of important axes than those that came before it - including "being used by a high-profile project" - that you can say that it made DVCSs happen.)
- namdnay 5y agousing git with github is still a DVCS. You can branch, commit, merge, whatever without access to the central repository. None of that was possible with the classic VCS - if the central server went down, you were stuck with your current working copy, or copying a colleague's state on removable media
- mathnmusic 5y ago> How do we get rid of crypto entirely then? Stop everyone using it, shut it down and ban all of it? Govts around the world could start treating tokens and NFTs as just another kind of security. Bitcoin and Ethereum would also qualify. Free speech never allowed anybody to issue ownership in projects for future gains without satisfying the regulations. https://www.seclaw.com/what-is-a-security/ https://www.seclaw.com/what-is-a-security/
- dmitriid 5y ago> I hope this is not the same thing as the 'use rsync' response when Dropbox was introduced. Because, invariably, everything crypto is "the next big thing". And not, you know, Theranos. Or Google Nexus Q. Or AT&T's ISIS mobile wallet. Or...
- pjc50 5y agoI think it's feasible to define "proof of waste" in a way that makes it possible to ban it, in the same way and the same rationale as you can't sell inefficient vehicle engines or lightbulbs. Anonymous/pseudonymous money, unregulated securities, gambling, etc. are already on a collision course with regulators who are largely unable to keep up. On the other hand, I don't think the problem is big enough to trigger massive action yet, it would have to be on the scale of 1MDB.
- bluecalm 5y ago"Just use rsync" have the same problem as "don't use Discord". The alternatives are way less convenient, not as polished, not as pleasant. Thankfully there is nothing convenient, polished or pleasant about using crypto other than going around regulation.
- bena 5y agoThe difference was that "use rsync" was several steps specific to Linux that required some knowledge about how it all worked. Vs. Signing up for Dropbox. Using any crypto is more akin to the "use rsync" side of things as there are several steps you have to perform before actually getting to the asset. Vs. Paying cash. I think crypto in general has run into the same problem Uber/DoorDash/Airbnb and other similar "disruptor apps" have, but much sooner: Every seemingly stupid rule has a reason. The cab industry operated as it did because it already ran into the problems Uber faced. DoorDash is finding out exactly why these restaurants did not offer delivery in the first place. Airbnb is learning a lot about why the hotel industry works as it does. Crypto/DeFi enthusiasts are learning that maybe a little less De would make the Fi more plausible.
- CrazyStat 5y agoDropbox did the same thing rsync did but made it so simple that my grandma who barely understands the difference between single and double click could use it. There's a clear value proposition there. web3 so far mostly makes things more complicated. My grandma (still going strong) is not going to figure it out.