3 ms·
A court order can't legally force someone to share incriminating information. Thus if prosecutors want a piece of information for other purposes (like to prosec
by nradov 5y ago
A court order can't legally force someone to share incriminating information. Thus if prosecutors want a piece of information for other purposes (like to prosecute a bigger criminal) they will often grant criminal immunity on that point. Then the person being questioned has no 5th Amendment right to remain silent.
- akerl_ 5y agoI’m not sure where you’re sourcing this, but courts can totally force you to share incriminating information. They cannot compel you to testify against yourself. As a more mundane example, a court can grant a search warrant compelling you to turn over your computer so that police can look for proof of suspected criminal activity. Likewise, they can get a court order compelling the IRS to hand over your tax returns.
- nradov 5y agoWithin the current interpretation of the 5th Amendment, ordering someone to turn over physical property like a computer or safe key isn't legally considered as compelling someone "to be a witness against himself". If you want the source then there are many Supreme Court opinions on this issue. https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/obtainopinions.aspx https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/obtainopinions.aspx
- akerl_ 5y agoI feel like we’ve looped. You wrote “A court order can't legally force someone to share incriminating information”. I gave an example where the court could force you to share incriminating information. Did you perhaps mean that a court order can’t force someone to answer questions that may incriminate them?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> A court order can't legally force someone to share incriminating information. It can't force someone to give potentially self-incriminating testimony (not all “information” is “testimony”, and not all incrimination is self-incrimination.)
- nradov 5y agoIf we're being pedantic, the specific legal phrase is "witness against himself". The courts have interpreted that more broadly than just testimony.