4 ms·
And yet we still see fools in the US who actually believe that Myers-Briggs personality types like "INTJ" are somehow meaningful. It's hilarious.
by nradov 5y ago
And yet we still see fools in the US who actually believe that Myers-Briggs personality types like "INTJ" are somehow meaningful. It's hilarious.
- andybak 5y agoI think there's something interesting in Myers-Briggs. It's crude, flawed and inaccurate in many ways but your sniggering rubbed me up the wrong way.
- arbitrage 5y agoTypical INTJ behaviour.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoIt's not Meyer Briggs: > Despite the use of colours, it turned out that the “Surrounded by …” books were not based on Myers-Brigg. Instead, they built on another personality theory, the so-called DiSC model.
- coliveira 5y agoBut it is a similar kind of BS. No scientific basis as well.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoSo i suppose there is "science" against it? I don't know the science surrounding it. But i took a test through work once and most seems to be correct. I don't think it would be "popular" in businesses if nothing would be correct. That's exactly what suprised me the first time, so I'm hesitant to call it bs. If there is another correlation it could be that the test was pretty positive for me. Perhaps it was the contrary for you? ( I'm just guessing and trying to find differences in experience here)
- coliveira 5y agoPerhaps you should consider the main idea in the article: pseudo-psychology operates stating the obvious with different words, to make it sound important. The tests that you took are tautologically true, because they ask questions about you and then give one or more names to that set of responses (blue, sanguineous, etc). Moreover, you rarely get a clear answer, and the creators of these test know that is very difficult, so they disclose that as a known "feature". It gets even worse when they start to pontificate about the meaning of these tests, because there is no scientific or social basis for what they propose.
- NicoJuicy 5y ago> Moreover, you rarely get a clear answer Weirdly enough, i actually got more than I bargained for. So whatever the pseudoscience is. It was applicable and useful to me.
- dmingod666 5y agoThey should read it's history. I think its audience is that of people who'd otherwise love astrology if it weren't so out of fashion.
- zzbzq 5y agoastrology is very fashionable though
- dmingod666 5y agoDepends, at your Sunday brunch, sure. While making small talk with a potential investor, I don't think so..
- delecti 5y agoIMO the biggest issue with MBTI types is the lack of "unaligned" letters. Someone at 51% of the way between "P" and "J" probably doesn't meaningfully express their "J", but would still get "INTJ" the same as if they had scored 100% of the way to "J". Adding an "X" to the middle of each scale would probably help differentiate between people genuinely expressing one end or the other of the scale, and the middle who don't really. Of course then the test probably would have never gotten popular, because most people would have a few Xs in their score and it's a lot less catchy of an idea then.
- nradov 5y agoIMO the biggest issue with MBTI types is reducing personality traits to exactly 4 dimensions. Why not 3 or 5? It's completely arbitrary.
- delecti 5y agoThat actually doesn't bother me at all. Any test attempting to group people into a finite number of categories will necessarily look need to limit the analysis to a finite number of dimensions. The more dimensions you look at the more groupings you'll end up with. Add those together and a consequence is you want to have fewer dimensions if possible, but not so few that the groupings are overly broad. Maybe 3 or 5 would have been better, but it's clear that thought went into the decision, and that it was obviously not an arbitrary decision.