8 ms·
I also don’t think it’s even necessary to prevent copyright infringement to achieve a goal of effectively steering people towards paid sources. I often hear ar
by kube-system 5y ago
I also don’t think it’s even necessary to prevent copyright infringement to achieve a goal of effectively steering people towards paid sources.
I often hear arguments that its “easier to pirate movies than use DRM’d software”. But I don’t think this is actually the case for the average non-tech-savvy person. If you can operate a torrent client or even know what one is, you are much savvier than the average Netflix/Roku/etc user.
DRM means that there isn’t a point-and-click app for my mom to send her sister a movie. This is the average person who buys movies. Not some geek on a tech forum.
- jayd16 5y agoIf pirate sites were allowed to flourish, they'd surely end up feeling as good as Netflix or better.
- consp 5y agoPopcorn time was/is pretty much the pinnacle of it so I'd say they got pretty close to being better than the streaming services.
- zo1 5y agoI never actually used Popcorn Time. What made it so great?
- juliendorra 5y agoIt was as easy to use as an official streaming service is, with integrated subtitles downloads in the background (from open subtitles), links to trailers and critics sites (it also pulled a lot of metadata from different sources). Popular movies were always on top of the list because the default sorting was by seeders and these movies would load instantly At the time it was the best streaming experience existing, paid or free combined. [edit] oh and install was just dropping an all-in-one app somewhere on your computer and launch it.
- BlueTemplar 5y agoWhy "was" ?
- aspenmayer 5y agoMostly the GUI, which is reminiscent of Netflix, and also the torrent client config. You hit play button on a video poster image, client sequentially downloads blocks of videos until the buffer outruns the download rate (this is the main difference from other clients which can’t/don’t download blocks sequentially), then it autoplays, pausing for more buffering if needed, with one click.
- dartharva 5y agoThere also exist a lot of centralized pirate streaming sites with huge catalogues that give you HD content right from your browser, and many of them feature players that give users more control in playback speed, video quality, subtitles etc. in an arguably better manner than any legitimate streaming service.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoPopcord time created resillient dustributed video service, with no hosting costs. It is technologically superior to anything all those billion dollar companoes have ever created.
- warkdarrior 5y agoNot that resilient in the end, since it is mostly shut down.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoI think when Netflix says they are 'resillient', they mean server failures, not armed SWAT and carpet bombing.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoI don't know. You have to put up with popups from streaming sites, sure - adblocker only stops most of them - but in general, playback is just fine and I can find most movies and shows. The allure of Netflix is simply legality, but for selection it is a step backwards from a decent streaming site.
- jtbayly 5y agoYes. It’s a major step back in terms of selection. And more to the point, it’s continuous major steps back every year, even compared to itself from a few years ago. Part of what people don’t seem to remember is that one of the benefits of iTunes was its huge selection. Netflix is becoming more and more like BandCamp, not iTunes, in terms of selection. I don’t go there to find something to watch anymore. I only go there if I want to watch one of the few things worth watching on it. There is currently no legal video platform for watching all the things. (And that’s ignoring the DRM crap.)
- dilyevsky 5y agoHow is drm responsible for the absence of such apps? If anything it’s the dmca systems and an army of lawyers
- kube-system 5y agoTechnical friction is also a factor. It’s much like speed bumps on a road. They don’t prevent people from going 50 in a 25. But they make it more of a PITA, even when a cop also might pull you over.
- dilyevsky 5y agoConsidering the fact many popular releases hit the torrents often times before official version is even available anywhere I dont think your speedbump metaphor is really working here =)
- oriolid 5y agoNot really. The speed bumps affect everyone, but it's enough that one person or group cracks the DRM and makes the result available for everyone.
- kube-system 5y agoIt doesn’t have to be much friction to have an impact. People take the path of least resistance.
- DarylZero 5y agoBut it does, because of the effect just mentioned. 99.999% of people can take the path of least resistance while the 1 in 100,000 exception bears all of the friction for all of them. Perhaps though the real friction is not exactly technical but that the piracy sites don't have the same attention-capturing "feed" or recommendation mechanisms set up. Just the friction of having to make choices.
- 5y ago
- devwastaken 5y agoI thought this was true until I visited an old friend in a trailer park, of which their family would borrow DVDs written with pirated movies. There were many reasons why. No internet, too expensive, no blu-ray player, etc. It was amazing how they could just put in a DVD, and instantly movie for their children. These kids had rarely ever seen an ad on TV in their life. The people who made the disks got paid, too. Market incentives are a universal concept. Digital content by it's nature is infinitely copiable. So who has the better market offer? Guy in trailer park for $1 for a movie or $50/month Hulu live subscription + 70/month internet? This is how it goes in other countries, too, where you cannot even legitimately get disks or downloads, much less be able to afford them. It is true it's simpler to just stream content for those that have the money and tech, but if you've seen how the media giants have split the market it's not affordable to most people to have Hulu live tv, Netflix, Disney+, Spotify, etc - all to watch a few specific movies. Piracy is a natural result. Don't underestimate the amount of tech knowledge people have nowadays, especially if it will save money. They themselves may not know, but they know someone that does. The internet has become a beautiful resource to learn absolutely anything. VPN's are advertised everywhere on YouTube. Necessity is the mother of invention after all.
- 5e92cb50239222b 5y ago> This is how it goes in other countries, too, where you cannot even legitimately get disks or downloads, much less be able to afford them. Oh yes, thank you for remembering that. It's truly an exception around here. Pretty much all streaming services refuse to accept my money or provide access to 0.1-1% of their catalog (compared to what is available in the US, literally a few to a few dozen shows/movies) for exactly the same price per month, so who would even bother? Of course, you can always try to find a working VPN, if they weren't getting blocked all the time. I believe Spotify is the only service that gives access to the same selection as in every other country. So everyone "pirates" everything, especially if you want content in its untranslated original form. Edit: except for games. Most games are available from Steam and other major platforms, and those are very popular.
- watermelon0 5y ago
- mkotowski 5y ago> If you can operate a torrent client or even know what one is, you are much savvier than the average Netflix/Roku/etc user. Probably depends from where you are. In Poland some 15 years ealier, it was quite a common skill, even for people who rarely used anything else on the internet. Many people had crappy and unstable connections and torrenting was the only viable option for them to watch anything from the Internet.
- 14 5y agoMy dad is elderly and has figured out how to watch online movies for free. He goes to [1] and it is just like netflix point and click no skill needed. 1 https://flixtor.to/home https://flixtor.to/home
- kube-system 5y agoI have no doubt that one, or even thousand of seniors are pirating the latest movies. I’m not saying that people don’t pirate stuff. But Netflix has 213 million users. If pirating was really so much easier and DRM made legal options unusable, they wouldn’t. DRM sucks, but Netflix isn’t going out of business any time soon
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago> But Netflix has 213 million users Nitpicking, but Netflix has 213 millions subscribers, not users. We don't know how many of them are active or how many people are using them. We simply know they paid one time.
- kube-system 5y agoI’ll phrase it another way: in 2020, some number of people collectively decided it was easier to send Netflix 25 billion dollars instead of pirating movies.
- peoplefromibiza 5y agoLet's look at it from another perspective: in 2020 people collectively decided it was easier to send Netflix $25 billion instead of other forms of entertainment (cinemas, theaters, concert halls, stadium, etc were closed) Pirating skyrocketed as well during 2020 The two things are not adversaries as much as one might think Theatrical releases on streaming services have helped piracy, now you can download a movie mere days after it came out and the quality is gonna be perfect. > More people are pirating movies during the coronavirus lockdown During the last seven days of March, there was a 43% spike in Americans visiting sites that pirate movies compared with the last seven days of February. Italy, which went under lockdown orders on March 9, saw visits to piracy sites spike 66%
- petepete 5y agoPopcorn Time being shut down by the MPAA is the reason there's no simple app for your mum and aunt. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Popcorn_Time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Popcorn_Time Unfortunately now there are so many streaming platforms piracy will gain in popularity again. Lots of people don't mind paying for one or two, but probably not five or six. Especially when some just have one or two good programmes.
- oarsinsync 5y agoWikipedia link shows that it's very much still alive, just on a different domain. MPAA managed to shutdown various domains, and get Github to stop hosting their source, but it appears that they're still very much alive and kicking.
- fabioborellini 5y agoOne of my favourite anecdotes is about an employee of a not-so-successful video streaming startup not knowing Popcorn Time being illegal, promoting its use at the water cooler and apparently using their company laptop for using it.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Lots of people don't mind paying for one or two, but probably not five or six. Especially when some just have one or two good programmes. 'Subscription rotation' may become a thing: you pay for a service for a few months, catch up on any shows that were released on it that you haven't seen, and then cancel and move onto the next one. A year later you come back to the first one and do a new catch-up. There may be one or two that you stick with (e.g., Disney if you have kids).
- peoplefromibiza 5y agopopcorn-time used to work ten times better than any paid streaming service of today. also, no ads. there is nothing inherently difficult in watching unlicensed content. and downloading has been a thing since I can remember. Everyone in my age range or younger than me (mid 40s) should know exactly how to do it. the main two reasons people watch paid services nowadays are: 1 - they have kids and don't want to do parenting, because it's hard, so they buy Disney+ and leave the kids in front of it 2 - they are young and have been educated to them by their parents (AKA they don't pay for it) 3 - go back to one
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoWhen you're young being excluded from the principle cultural medium film/television cause social exclusion to done extent. When you can't afford to pay I think this provides a genuine moral reason for copyright infringement. With morally defensible copyright terms it might not. As you age (30s-40s), generally your can afford more and so access some of these most popular cultural artefacts without copyright infringement; so you should pay. Also, it may become less important to establishing and maintaining friendships and status (like if you find your niche in society). I don't think those following such a social progression need be aware of it.
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago> As you age (30s-40s), generally your can afford more and so access some of these most popular cultural artefacts At my age I have no FOMO, truth is I never had it before either, it might be me or the fact that I am naturally immune to most mimetic tactics, I simply get no reward from social acceptance. Anyway: at my age I have developed my own moral compass,I pay to go to the movies, I pay for concerts, I pay for records, I pay for books, I pay to watch and listen online content that I think it's worth it (I buy a lot of music from Bandcamp) I have no ethical problem boycotting VC funded services that want to build a monopoly (growth, they call it) and have fragmented the market in ways that "excluded [people] from the principle cultural medium film/television" of their times. sorry, not sorry.
- nescioquid 5y ago
- Broken_Hippo 5y ago"I often hear arguments that its “easier to pirate movies than use DRM’d software”. But I don’t think this is actually the case for the average non-tech-savvy person. If you can operate a torrent client or even know what one is, you are much savvier than the average Netflix/Roku/etc user." I don't know many folks that actually torrent things now. If you want to be able to see it offline, sure, or if you want the physical file. It isn't necessary, though. Even if it was, the last torrenting software I used was pretty easy and you didn't need to be that tech savvy to use it. It doesn't matter because this isn't necessary. Streaming sites exist, and they are definitely easy to use. So long as you have a decent internet connection, there is no real reason to download anything.
- grishka 5y agoReasons piracy still exists and will exist approximately forever: - Something not being available in your country - The version that is available is a "helpfully" translated one when you would rather watch the original with subs - Your device isn't worthy of receiving a high-quality stream despite you paying for one and your hardware being capable of decoding it - The player is just shitty and you can't use your own - There are ads despite you paying a subscription - You "bought" a movie, then it was taken away from you because the seller lost the license. In other words, your continued access to something you allegedly own is still contingent on the seller and its whims. It's surprising how much people are willing to tolerate, but in general, around me torrenting something is still the default. Some people do have Netflix or other subscriptions, but they are a minority. Just no one is having this whole "you get the same exact movie but you pay AND you get a worse UX" thing. And DVDs? I don't think I've ever seen an actually licensed and encrypted DVD. Many players ignore all those "no fast forwarding" flags as well.
- toraway1234 5y ago> DRM means that there isn’t a point-and-click app for my mom to send her sister a movie. "magistv"