5 ms·
This is just telemetry data which doesn’t have much general or scientific interest, i guess they could publish the protocol spec (honestly it probably is aquira
by colechristensen 5y ago
This is just telemetry data which doesn’t have much general or scientific interest, i guess they could publish the protocol spec (honestly it probably is aquirable) but most of the fun for the kinds of people who want this data is going to be doing this reverse engineering themselves.
The real imaging data would require a much more significant dish to even receive (i can’t immediately find what it’s going to use, but I’m guessing something like a 40 meter dish) so there are approximately zero amateurs who could use such open source information.
- dylan604 5y agoAren't they using the Deep Space Network for this?
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, all communications are routed through DSN.
- londons_explore 5y agoBut in a really open project, the design of the whole lot would be on the web, and the data sent back would be sitting on an FTP server somewhere for anyone to download and use. In many ways, an open project is cheaper to do than a behind-closed-doors project where every new contractor needs to get access to only the bits of the project they need access to, and misunderstandings happen because not everyone has enough of the big picture. The only bit that needs to be secret is one private key used to sign the commands sent to the satellite, just so one random Mallory can't 'steal' it.
- semi-extrinsic 5y ago> the data sent back would be sitting on an FTP server somewhere for anyone to download and use I'm sure they could actually do that without too much fuss. But it would require significant amounts of scientist time to document those datasets to enable others to use them for any arbitrary dataset. I'm sure we'll see fully open data sets from JWST appear, but lots of the stuff it collects isn't going to be interesting enough that it's reasonable to spend scientist time documenting it.
- londons_explore 5y agoI think there needs to be a distinction between something that a project "publishes", and something that is "made available". Something published has been checked by a few team members, written with care, and represents the opinion of the authors and project. Something made available has no guarantees of correctness, might not represent the projects opinion, and might just be random matlab scripts made by a JWST scientist in their lunchtime that they thought was fun. In the open source world, what is 'published' is probably the projects homepage, and code. What is 'made available' is random chatter on their discord or IRC channel. I hope that more government projects 'make available' everything done by all the workers - every file saved on every PC, with the understanding that there is no guarantee of correctness. I guess it's the same idea as being able to see into the kitchen from a restaurant. You might see the chef making mistakes or juggling the saucepans, but you'll also see the work being done as it's done, and being able to view doesn't delay the chefs work.
- dividedbyzero 5y agoThat's a pretty bad idea IMO. Putting people in a panopticon has a strong chilling effect, no matter what disclaimer you put on the recordings. Creative, deep work needs space to make blunders in private, scientists are no exception. They'll just use their personal laptops or document every experiment and mistake and script to death, getting done a lot less actual research. Plus, it will be pretty much useless im practice since you'd have to be an expert in that niche yourself to know what's correct (you're not getting any extra docs or context) and probably most of it will be some kind of incorrect, possibly very subtly. The only people who could profit tremendously are the competition who aim to snipe that particular paper. Science is pretty dirty and ruthless often as not, I totally could see this happen.
- jandrese 5y agoIt seems like it should all be automated. Some scientist generates a mission request for the JWST techs. If accepted the mission is added to the timeline with all of the metadata the original scientists had in their proposal. Stuff like the area being imaged, the sensors in use, duration of capture, etc... Once the data is collected and downloaded it is added to the catalog with all of that metadata attached. Then it's a matter of opening up that catalog to the public, although I'm guessing the downloads will be quite sizeable so the bandwidth could be an issue. The trick to making this work is to integrate the publishing into the workflow so it doesn't require any additional effort on the part of anyone.
- coldpie 5y agoYou're assuming it's secret, but the more likely case is it just isn't anyone's job to make it public.
- michaelwilson 5y agoAs I recall, with the Hubble, and presumably the JWST, there were scientific "precedence" rules which limited access to the observational data to the scientist requesting the observation for some period of time. This was to prevent others from also getting the data and publishing before the requesting scientist. Assuming this continues to be true, they probably wouldn't want to handle the data by publishing it to a FTP server immediately on receipt.
- aragilar 5y agoThe data will be at https://archive.stsci.edu/ https://archive.stsci.edu/ (which holds the data from a whole host of space telescopes, and uses standard VO interfaces). STScI is a major contributor to astropy etc. (https://github.com/astropy https://github.com/astropy), and has their own space with more tools/software: https://github.com/spacetelescope https://github.com/spacetelescope. It's unclear what else you'd actually want, unless you want to build a clone of the actual satellite (it wouldn't surprise me that a majority of the software for the satellite is open source, just not put together somewhere publicly for people to download).
- colechristensen 5y ago> It's unclear what else you'd actually want, unless you want to build a clone of the actual satellite (it wouldn't surprise me that a majority of the software for the satellite is open source, just not put together somewhere publicly for people to download). Much satellite technology is classified or at least export controlled (ITAR). The major difference between a space telescope and a spy satellite is which direction you point.
- MAGZine 5y agoA funny quip but the main imaging cameras on the jwst would be useless pointed at earth.
- aunty_helen 5y agoFrom: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20080030196/downloads/20080030196.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20080030196/downloads/20... >To keep up with the high downlink, the recorder data gets sent directly to the Ka-band transmitter Currently aws groundstation doesn't support KA band so no luck there. It's apparently going to do a transmission once a day so you would need to time it right with the ground station.
- Thorentis 5y agoGroundststion as a Service. I had no idea this existed. I am continuously amazed at how many things Amazon churns out "as a service".
- aunty_helen 5y agoIt's pretty amazing. I found out about it a couple months ago from a job posting that wanted a programmer for a cube sat. It seems like this is what they're aiming the service for at the moment. And really, it's the perfect place for aws to enter, add glue, and provide a service to let you do your core business. Feels like the future man.
- hayanno 5y agoNice link, very informative, here's a funny excerpt : "It [JSWT] is currently planned to be launched in 2013 from French Guiana aboard an Ariane 5 launch vehicle".
- aunty_helen 5y agoI couldn't find a publish date in the pdf but going off the url I'm going to guess that it was from 2008. It's a little bit annoying finding information about jwst as info could potentially be old and out of date. Another document that I read mentioned using XML as the database format because XML was an emerging standard :S
- Twisol 5y agoMost of the public specifications are distributed freely by the CCSDS (Consultative Committee for Space Data Systems): https://public.ccsds.org/Publications/BlueBooks.aspx https://public.ccsds.org/Publications/BlueBooks.aspx The mission-specific parameters ("managed parameters") used by any given mission are usually more tightly controlled, as are the payload specifications for each telemetry channel. > This is just telemetry data which doesn’t have much general or scientific interest My understanding is that "telemetry" and "telecommand" stand for the downlink and uplink directions of a space link. I mostly worked upstream of telecommand, but I understood "telemetry" to refer to received data of any kind -- e.g. in CCSDS 130.1-G-3, an informational report on the design of the CCSDS telemetry system. https://public.ccsds.org/Pubs/130x1g3.pdf https://public.ccsds.org/Pubs/130x1g3.pdf By the by, I've been continually impressed with the quality of the CCSDS' documents. The "green books" (informational reports, like the one above) are extremely approachable and well-written.
- astroflask 5y agoGonna chime in here to comment that most NASA missions (and ESA too) provide the scientific data for download free of charge, under Public Domain or CC licenses. If it's for scientific purposes, it's not just good manners, but rather a requirement to cite the proper dataset (that also gives you the bonus of citing a respected source, so it's a win-win). Thing is that many people doesn't even know where to look for! And it doesn't help that some missions manage their own archives differently, and there's a lot of terminology to learn on your own. One of the complete opposites of that, which was a joy, was the New Horizons archive which, at one point, you could download from a torrent! For example, if you wanted to see V3 of the Arrokoth encounter from 2019, you'd go to: https://pdssbn.astro.umd.edu/holdings/nh-a-lorri-3-kem1-v3.0/dataset.shtml https://pdssbn.astro.umd.edu/holdings/nh-a-lorri-3-kem1-v3.0... Again, New Horizons is a bit of a rare case in which they went for super accessible data for everyone. PDS itself is a great system, but many missions will just upload a bit of data to PDS and then manage the rest some other way (Cassini for example has only a couple of instruments on PDS, and you have to go to some other URL if you want uncalibrated but automatically processed images on JPEG format[0], but yet another place (to which I've lost the link to and I can't find on mobile) for the full, science-grade dataset). A great resource is OPUS[1] too, however I find it's UI a bit difficult, and in the end I prefer to download full datasets and just explore them on my own rather than going with those online browsers. For example, if you wanted to check the Voyager images of Neptune, you'd go to this massive URL[2]. Quick tip: once you've configured the filter you want to apply, the Search button is on the top left -- this is the kind of usability thing I mentioned, buttons and links aren't quite where you'd expect them. Oh and there's a limit to how many things you can select for download at once. And it's all dynamically loaded, and on and on and on. Which is why, as I said before, I generally prefer to just download the full GB sized dataset and explore it on my own. [0] https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/raw-images/raw-image-viewer/?order=earth_date+desc&per_page=50&page=0 https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/raw-images/raw-image-viewer/?or... [1] https://opus.pds-rings.seti.org/opus/ https://opus.pds-rings.seti.org/opus/ [2] https://opus.pds-rings.seti.org/opus/#/instrument=Voyager+ISS&observationtype=Image&target=Larissa,Neptune,Neptune+Rings,Nereid,Proteus,Triton&cols=opusid,instrument,planet,target,time1,observationduration&widgets=instrument,observationtype,target&order=time1,opusid&view=browse&browse=gallery&cart_browse=gallery&startobs=1&cart_startobs=1&detail= https://opus.pds-rings.seti.org/opus/#/instrument=Voyager+IS...