12 ms·
This is a harder problem than just "Free Education". I grew up in the UK (in "deprived" areas, to a single parent with no income other than jobseekers allowanc
by dijit 5y ago
This is a harder problem than just "Free Education".
I grew up in the UK (in "deprived" areas, to a single parent with no income other than jobseekers allowance and some childcare from the state) and I can formerly attest that my "free education" was atrocious.
I am not sure if there was a negative feedback loop involved: School funding was determined by efficacy. How do you measure efficacy of a school? Well, test results... which people from this kind of background will not have good ones.
Another issue that perhaps is not thought much about is that 'Homework' for impoverished people is very difficult, in my case I didn't have a place to actually sit and work (no dining table, we ate on our laps). But Homework is a necessary part of education.
Add to the fact that socio-economic factors do filter into the school; things like gangs and in-groups.
Worried about gangs and gang colours: uniform
Uniforms cost money. Money people don't have.
By the time you get to the age where you're allowed to work (or go to university)- you take what you can get to get out of poverty; which is not going to be further education.
In my experience school is a temporary prison for children so that their parents can go to work, I definitely didn't learn the things I know from school. I learned them from my mum and school regurgitated them at me ad infinitum in a boring classroom in a small building surrounded by prison bars.
I do not miss free school. I strongly resent that it was ever forced on me.
- ben_w 5y agoI'm also from the UK, and I was lucky enough that my parents used a cunning trick to get me into a good school[0], I'd like to add that even when the school is good, the expectations people have for you can make a huge difference. I am terrible at the French language. I could never get the verb conjugations into my head, and trying to do that is one of only three memories I have of the entire learning experience from Year 7 to the start of the exams. Somehow I managed to end up in the top class for everything, including French. I found it really stressful and asked to be moved down to the middle group, and the teachers agreed — but as soon as I did, I found nobody, students certainly and it felt like also the teacher, was even trying in the middle group. While it stopped me being stressed, I ended up with a GCSE grade D in French, my joint-worst with R.E. (guess who wondered into the New Age section of Waterstones and decided Wicca was a lot more interesting than the Bible, while still a student in a Catholic school with mandatory Mass attendance and R.E. lessons). For university I went to Aberystwyth[1]; I never even considered applying to Oxford or Cambridge, because Oxbridge is the best-of-the-best. When I graduated and got a job which happened to be in Cambridge, all my new friends assumed I was a fellow Cam grad, and I rapidly developed a regret I hadn't even tried to get in[2]. I might still have failed if I had tried, but I didn’t even try. I enjoyed learning German at school for the one year I was allowed to (hence moving to Berlin a few years ago), and like your general resentment, I resented having French GCSE forced on me when I sucked so much at it. And the R.E. lessons, too. [0] A Catholic baptism because the best local school was Catholic. [1] Owing to a misunderstanding, a friend said they had a lot of fun there when they were a student, but it turned out they were talking about the town and visiting friends as their university was a completely different one. [2] Thanks to a convoluted series of events, I can technically say I studied in Cambridge university as part of my degree; but this is because my industrial year job sent me on a training course in the William Gates building. This is also how I was in New Hall despite my beard and it being a women-only hall.
- as_i_fall 5y agoI mean what's the alternative? I don't think dumping kids out of school is going to improve anything for anyone.
- dijit 5y agoRemoving children from the offending environment would be the best alternative I can think of. But as others have mentioned that has quite a bit of historical baggage, and of course children and parents would both hate it. It's only hindsight that teaches us valuable lessons about this kind of stuff, sadly. I wasn't offering better options, I was just opining a lost youth and denigrating a terrible education system. But it was "free".
- echelon 5y agoTo help foster growth, kids need a person that encourages them when they fail, keeps them from trouble and bad influences, disciplines them when they make bad decisions, helps with their mental health, and encourages them to learn and grow in whatever interest the kid enjoys. Not all children have access to this kind of role model. And even if they do, it's not a guarantee, just a more favorable probability. School is so strained that it can't be this system by itself. Good teachers help, but they're transitory, and typically not available after hours. And very few care in the same way a parent, grandparent, relative, or adoptive family would as they're not as deeply invested. Other children can be horrible influences that can make a child depressed, angry, lose faith in themselves, and take up bad habits. Kids need to be shielded and told that the pain they experience is temporary, that life holds promise, and that the problems they face can be overcome. It's a very hard and important problem.
- mixedCase 5y agoWhy did this get downvoted? Do people deny the influence that good role models make for children or just extremely resent the fact that we don't have a good universal solution for that problem?
- marcosdumay 5y ago> How do you measure efficacy of a school? Well, test results... which people from this kind of background will not have good ones. If you are going to test a school, your tests must be differential. If you don't test at the beginning and end of the course, you'll only measure noise.
- MrsPeaches 5y ago> But Homework is a necessary part of education. Is it though? Sounds like it was actually exclusionary in your case. I believe that Finland has no homework and yet has some of the highest PISA scores.
- WillPostForFood 5y agoIt is not true, there is homework. It is false information, likely spread from a Michael Moore documentary that made the exaggerated claim. https://finland.fi/life-society/the-truth-about-finnish-schools/ https://finland.fi/life-society/the-truth-about-finnish-scho... https://www.reddit.com/r/Finland/comments/99l5ke/is_that_true_that_there_is_no_homework_in_finland/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Finland/comments/99l5ke/is_that_tru...
- MrsPeaches 5y agoThank you for posting the links. Cunningham’s law in action! https://meta.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law https://meta.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law
- User23 5y ago> How do you measure efficacy of a school? Over the long term? The frequency and size of the checks their alumni write them. It's good signal that the alumnus likes the school well enough wish to do so and was prepared to be successful enough to be able to.
- rbanffy 5y ago> The frequency and size of the checks their alumni write them This only measures economic success, which is only a single dimension of educational success. It also fosters inequality, as schools with better outcomes from other factors (such as rich parents) will receive more resources as the ones that fail for factors the school system can’t control (such as, surprise, poverty).
- User23 5y agoEconomic success is a decent proxy for social success, and has the advantage of being quantifiable. Being successful also correlates with health and happiness. If the purpose of school is to prepare students to have good lives then it’s a good metric. Not to mention donating to the school is charitable, which is another nice trait for people to have. Evidently you believe that the purpose of school is enforcing equality? How exactly does that work in a way that doesn’t result in at best failure and at worst an Harrison Bergeron hellscape?
- rbanffy 5y ago> Economic success is a decent proxy for social success By that logic, Jeff Bezos would be an amazing human being. I believe we can agree he isn't. > Not to mention donating to the school is charitable, which is another nice trait for people to have. Donating to the school in your catchment area will increase the sale value of your property, and improve the school for your kids and your neighbors. That's not charitable. What would be nice is donating the same amount to the least privileged schools in your city/county/state. A donation that benefits your own kids? Seriously? > Evidently you believe that the purpose of school is enforcing equality? Evidently you confuse equality of opportunities (which I do support) with equality of outcomes (which I don't). Overall, the more unequal a society gets, the less democratic it becomes.
- digianarchist 5y agoI don’t agree with the uniforms point. If uniforms are replaced with a student's own clothes they will be bullied relentlessly for not sporting the latest fashion. This happens today because shoes and bags aren’t part of the uniform. Other than the colour requirements. That was a source of bullying for myself and others.
- rbanffy 5y ago> This happens today because shoes and bags aren’t part of the uniform I see that too here in Ireland. Uniforms (and meals) should be included with education. Everyone should have at least all the materials they need. This was one of the ideas behind the OLPC laptop - it was supposed to be a standard tool and end up cheaper than printing and shipping physical books. Didn’t work out, but beget netbooks, chromebooks and other low end laptops, which are kind of great for kids.
- dijit 5y agoI just brought up the uniforms point because: A) It didn't solve the issue, people looked at other signifiers such as jewellery or shoes instead (or if the uniform required "a white polo" then they'd have a name brand polo instead). B) It forced the parent to buy (in some cases) expensive Uniform(s) (because you can't have just 1 and kids grow quickly too). For the second point I was fortunate enough to have really good grades when tested, so I was allowed to go to a more prestigious school that required a tie and blazer. The total cost for everything was more than my Mum received in cash for an entire year. If it wasn't for my granddad stepping in I wouldn't have been able to go to the school on those grounds alone. (EDIT: just so I'm clear, Mum got about 48~ gbp per week but rent was paid directly by the Government)
- kingcharles 5y agoWhat's funny is how niche it got. At my school with uniforms which dictated the type of shoe you had to wear, the "cool" kids would steal these tags off the laces of the shoes in the stores in town. The coolest kids had the most tags hanging off their shoelaces O_O
- 5y ago
- sokoloff 5y ago> I do not miss free school. I strongly resent that it was ever forced on me. What’s the better alternative? No schooling seems like it would be wildly worse for all of students, families, and society.
- danans 5y ago> School funding was determined by efficacy. How do you measure efficacy of a school? Well, test results... which people from this kind of background will not have good ones. That's exactly backwards from how it should be funded but is the sad result of trying to implement "market based" solutions to sociological and historical problems.