5 ms·
If they put a few GB of RAM in the router, they could run a proxy in it to play video out of a cache of traffic broadcast to all terminals in range of a satelli
by ncmncm 5y ago
If they put a few GB of RAM in the router, they could run a proxy in it to play video out of a cache of traffic broadcast to all terminals in range of a satellite and held by terminals that actually want it, obviating need to upload and download multiple logically-identical copies of content being watched (at possibly different points in the playback sequence) from multiple terminals in the area. This would reduce loading on the channels, enabling more effective bandwidth from the very limited available spectrum.
It would need adaptation at the application layer, but the data management needed is minimal. It would also need some attention at the central terminus / edge node serving the area, to identify duplicate requested streams and shift a corresponding stream to the broadcast channel. In turn, this would typically depend on cooperation from the original source of a stream, typically mediated by their contract with an edge cache service.
The extremum of usefulness for this facility would be when hundreds or thousands of terminals in an area are used to watch the same World Cup football match. In this case, the cache storage footprint would be minimal, as almost all viewers would be watching at the same point in the broadcast.
More commonly, a few blockbuster movies and local news might dominate broadcast traffic. But no advance planning or personal attention would be needed; any stream found being fed to more than one downlink could be shifted to broadcast according to the amount of bandwidth that would thereby be saved.
As laser inter-satellite links are added to the constellation, a single uplink stream could serve simultaneous broadcast from multiple satellites in a chain.
- fuzzy2 5y agoNo need for any caching, just do proper multicast like "real" IPTV networks do. Other than that, I don't think that enough people would watch the same shows within a reasonable timeframe to justify the costs.
- ncmncm 5y agoMulticast would save exactly zero Hz of spectrum bandwidth, which a moment's thought would reveal to you. Allow me encourage a habit of that. Multicast routing uses, exclusively, point-to-point links. So, a packet could go up to the satellite once, but would need to be copied down to every terminal individually. But internet video is in any case not distributed by multicast UDP. Even if it were, you still would need caching for viewers not watching identically the same frames at the same time, because a multicast router does not do time-shifting: all copies of each packet are queued to send immediately.
- fuzzy2 5y agoIs that right. Do enlighten me then! Of course the transport link would have to cooperate and open a group-encrypted channel for every multicast group a client is subscribed to. Basically how regular satellite TV works, but with dynamically allocated bandwidth.
- spmurrayzzz 5y agoYou were right to point out multicast. Its a great way to do cache discovery if nothing else. Saying that its de facto not effective at saving spectrum bandwidth handwaves pretty much every last mile detail thats relevant in networks like these.
- ncmncm 5y agoNo, fuzz is 100% wrong. Multicast makes more-effective use of fiber, where each new fiber link branching off provides its own, private pool of bandwidth, added on to all the others. Once you get to radio spectrum transmission, each pair of endpoints competes with every other pair in range, in a strictly limited pool of bandwidth. Adding another terminal takes away capacity from all the others. A multicast stream going to your satellite and then distributed to 100 terminals by multicast burns 100x the fixed available bandwidth as each terminal gets. The only way to get any benefit from batching delivery over radio spectrum is via broadcast. For a packet network, you have the extra chore of making those broadcast packets actually useful to as many terminals as possible. In practice that requires caching of broadcast content in the terminal, so that when it is actually asked for it is already there.
- spmurrayzzz 5y ago>Once you get to radio spectrum transmission, each pair of endpoints competes with every other pair in range, in a strictly limited pool of bandwidth. Adding another terminal takes away capacity from all the others. A multicast stream going to your satellite and then distributed to 100 terminals by multicast burns 100x the fixed available bandwidth as each terminal gets. Multicast is indeed problematic for wireless networks, even beyond what you describe (e.g. FEC, ACK storming, retransmits, etc). But if the phy layer is using OFDMA or similar, its entirely plausible to dedicate a subcarrier for multicast traffic. This doesn't solve the O(N) terminal problem you describe, but it mitigates the impact for concurrent transmission of unrelated unicast traffic while the multicast delivery is happening. There's a fairly large academic body of work on this specific topic re: OFDMA multicast. And though I think your note on caching is a necessary component of this (a la Open Connect), I still think there is a role that multicast can play here.
- Scoundreller 5y agoYou may want to look into Othernet, which does satellite broadcast data distribution to rasp pi based terminals. But they only have 2kbps to work with, so it’s largely the day’s news and some broadcast messages. But it’s free and it works! I understand some Canadian arctic cities want to do what you say because they depend on x$/gb satellite links, but not big enough for a Netflix or whatever appliance. But every time there’s an iPhone or windows update, everyone is downloading it independently. It would also make sense to load a box of SD cards with their supply flights and put them on-net. Dunno if a formal system exists for that.
- reaperducer 5y agoThanks for the Othernet mention. I just looked into the Wikipedia article and the company's web site, and it's exactly the sort of tech I enjoy. Unfortunately, even though its receiver was supposed to enter production in November, it's still not available. Ordinarily I'd blame 'rona/supply chain/whatever, but according to Wikipedia, it failed to deliver a previous kickstarter. When it's available, I'll buy one. But I won't be the first, in case this turns into vaporware.
- Scoundreller 5y agoKeep an eye on the forums. It seems to be a real thing, but exactly how anyone got setup without the kickstarter delivering, iunno. Be suspicious. https://forums.othernet.is/ https://forums.othernet.is/
- tyingq 5y agoThe satellite based WiFi used on commercial aircraft do this, with some on-demand content cached on the aircraft. I think they also "tape-delay" some of the live stuff to deal with short fade-outs. Google around for DVB-S2 and DVB-S2X.