4 ms·
Note that you are literally shedding identifiable DNA from your body at all times and a truly motivated adversary would have no problem obtaining enough sample
by dekhn 5y ago
Note that you are literally shedding identifiable DNA from your body at all times and a truly motivated adversary would have no problem obtaining enough sample material to do high quality sequencing.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoOne of the key differences is that in the case of the DNA sequencing services, you're agreeing to ToS that allow them to abuse your data (and thus indirectly the data of any of your blood-relatives), and you directly tie the data to a name and address.
- shukantpal 5y agoAt scale?
- dekhn 5y agoSure. I've worked with and know people who could carry this out at scale, although obviously individual sample collection isn't highly scalable. Edit: I used to help Google fund researchers like Joe Derisi and others who develop technology to do this, and some of the people I worked with in my academic career are quite good at identifying serial killers from 30 year old DNA. If you're downvoting because you think I'm making this up, you're wrong. If you're downvoting because you don't think large-scale individual detection using genetic sampling of the environment is possible, you're wrong. If you're downvoting because you think you couldn't do a whole genome sequence of an individual using a sample collected in the wild, you're wrong. If you're downvoting because you think this is a terrible idea (morally, ethically), that's fine but I didn't say anything about my own moral or ethical beliefs about this. It's simply factually correct to say that large-scale individual sample collection (at order tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands of individuals in a country the size of the US) is possible. All the technology is there to do this.
- jcims 5y agoIt seems very unlikely to me that there isnt at least *some* genetic information that would be of direct value in advertising. Like if Google took five years of personalized ad performance info and filtered that through the associated individual’s known DNA to develop a predictive model.
- hourislate 5y agoI'm curious whether a Covid PCR test could be used to sequence your DNA. Is there enough of a specimen in the process.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoAbsolutely.
- l-albertovich 5y agoWell crap, there you go, giving the lunatics reasons not to get tested and make the whole thing worse than it already is... I'm joking, I don't think you did anything wrong but I'd hate it if a ridiculous argument such as this example gained any traction : Example : The government / aliens / whoever released the virus so we willingly gave them our DNA to sequence and match with our assigned ID so they can do XYZ in case the implant in the vaccine doesn't work or if we are smart enough not to get vaccinated. Scary stuff.
- makeitdouble 5y agoGiven the past incidents, it would probably be more in line with a gov. agency getting direct access to everything that goes through a few selected labs for years/decades, so that a significant number of people geting blood/cells sampled for that period would have a high chance of passing their data though these labs at some point. At the base of it, if the gov. of the country one lives in is the enemy, it can’t be a matter of refusing vaccines here and there, that’s not the scale they should be thinking about.
- monopoledance 5y agoYes, of course there is. Just like any other medical sample you have ever given. Blood, stool, urine, swaps... But also all the unintentional donations: Every pubic hair you lost on the toilet seat, every tampon you disposed, every bandage you ripped off and threw away, every mattress you slept on, chewing gum you've spit out, every ejaculation, every ... you get the idea. That's why you need laws to regulate this.
- 5y ago
- nomercy400 5y agoIt's not the motivated adversary I am worried about, who actually has to show up where I have physically been. It is the company on the other side of the world in a country with lax legislation, profiling me based on the data I 'shed' online, like a cloud-based DNA sequencing service.
- KeepFlying 5y agoThis is my threat model for most things in life. If someone is physically targeting me, I'm fucked. I'm more worried about limiting the casual long-distance attacker since I have more ability to stop them. If someone steals my DNA I can't stop them. But I can at least avoid being swept up in large scale DNA scanning and tracking efforts.
- russdill 5y agoIn the near future (or arguably now depending on your purpose) you don't even need that. Assuming enough of your relative's sequences are available, the probability of you having certain genes/mutations can be narrowed down so much that having your individual genome doesn't add much.
- petters 5y agoThis does not seem true? Even if the complete genome of my mother and father is known, there is still a lot of uncertainty left.
- sllabres 5y agoIsn't that quite similar to help solving cold cases as example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_James_DeAngelo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_James_DeAngelo On April 24, 2018, authorities charged 72-year-old DeAngelo with eight counts of first-degree murder, based upon DNA evidence; investigators had identified members of DeAngelo's family through forensic genetic genealogy.
- petters 5y agoYou don't have to reconstruct the genome in order to prove relationships or find a person.
- russdill 5y agoLets say there's some rare genetic disorder, only a few hundreds of a percent of the population has it. If someone knows that your mother or father has it, you now don't have a few hundreds of a percent chance of having it. Depending on the disorder you having it might just be a cointoss.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThe data monopolies and abuse originate from people giving these companies data for free. If they had to buy it, or pay goons to collect it, they wouldn't be profitable.
- Teever 5y agoI assume this line of reasoning is also why you don't lock your doors at night?
- diplodocusaur 5y agoI imagine one's DNA can't be too different from the cousin that agrees to share that kind of data?