7 ms·
Can somebody explain what 5G is actually good for? With 4G you get fast enough coverage at long distances for basically everything. Maps for sure, but even str
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
Can somebody explain what 5G is actually good for?
With 4G you get fast enough coverage at long distances for basically everything. Maps for sure, but even streaming video as long as not everyone on the tower is trying to do it at once.
With 5G you get more bandwidth, but you're not going to get it in the middle of the woods because it also requires more towers closer together. So it's for high population density areas. But those areas are the places where it's extremely cost effective to install fiber, and cellular will never ever be as fast as fiber, and installing a million towers everywhere is just about as expensive.
If 4G is about all you're going to get in the middle of the woods and fiber (with the last hundred meters over Wi-Fi for mobiles) is the thing you actually want in the city, why is anybody even wasting money installing 5G towers anywhere?
- mhh__ 5y ago5G covers what 4G does as well IIRC. The really high frequency stuff is only what makes the news. Also the advantage of 5G as far as I'm concerned is being able to connect things (possibly in a mesh?) At very high throughput without cables. If you have an oscilloscope and a signal generator, you should be able to synthesize a (say) network analyzer out of the two of them by linking them via 5G.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> 5G covers what 4G does as well IIRC. The really high frequency stuff is only what makes the news. Right, right, the really high frequency stuff is what we're talking about. It's confusing that they stick so many things under the same label. The parts of "5G" that are just 4G with better radios and algorithms are useful but also not so contentious. But for that you wouldn't need more towers at closer intervals. > Also the advantage of 5G as far as I'm concerned is being able to connect things (possibly in a mesh?) And now we're talking about a third thing. It could actually be quite useful to open up more unlicensed spectrum for things like this -- if nothing else so we could get better Wi-Fi to hook up to the fiber. But that's a different thing than having Verizon install a cellular tower on the end of every street corner for high frequency cellular 5G and then not having them come the rest of the way with the fiber into your house, which still seems like some kind of a bad joke.
- lettergram 5y agoI think they aren’t wasting money installing towers. You’ll pay for those increased speeds as they build many towers. Although I agree, what we will end up with is going to be broad area WiFi effectively. Seems like the goal is to replace fiber and then you can move around the city always connected at high speeds. Comcast is already doing this, their routers will let other Comcast users connect over WiFi. Personally, I believe that is the end objective. I personally am just getting satellite via starlink and probably will get fiber if it’s available.
- mycall 5y ago5G is under 3GPP release 17 now [1] which includes many new features than 4G as release 8 [2]. 5G is much more than just changes in speed. [1] https://www.3gpp.org/release-17 https://www.3gpp.org/release-17 [2] https://www.3gpp.org/technologies/keywords-acronyms/98-lte https://www.3gpp.org/technologies/keywords-acronyms/98-lte
- llimos 5y agoNot to mention vastly higher power consumption. In an age of increased awareness around climate change, it's fairly mind-boggling that 5G is being pushed so hard, given the questionable value of the benefits it brings.
- pas 5y agoHow does it increase power consumption?
- llimos 5y agoSource: https://www.ericsson.com/495d5c/assets/local/about-ericsson/sustainability-and-corporate-responsibility/documents/2020/breaking-the-energy-curve-report.pdf https://www.ericsson.com/495d5c/assets/local/about-ericsson/... This is a brochure for Ericsson's lower power innovations, but look at the baseline without their system. Graph on page 2.
- gruez 5y ago>In an age of increased awareness around climate change, it's fairly mind-boggling that 5G is being pushed so hard, given the questionable value of the benefits it brings. How much % of global carbon emissions is due to cell equipment? Is it a big enough portion to worry about?
- toast0 5y ago5G is kind of three things. 5G on existing frequencies can do more data with the same spectrum. Something something MIMO. This is broadly useful, if you have an 5G capable device and your network updated their base station equipment. 5G and 4G are supposed to be better at sharing spectrum on demand vs 4G and 2/3G. 5G on new, nearby frequency, in the US, there was a second round of taking historically TV spectrum and reallocating it for communications. These bands will most likely need new antennas on towers as well as on handsets. These tend to be lower frequencies, which could be useful for distance and structure penetration, but may not always be built out. Then there's the millimeter wave stuff. Very high frequency, very fast, great for density, like maybe transit stations and arenas. This is the stuff that needs a tower on every light pole or whatever. I don't think this is going to get a lot of deployment, but it gets a lot of press. I think this is the part the FAA is objecting to for now.
- jdiez17 5y ago> Then there's the millimeter wave stuff. [...] I think this is the part the FAA is objecting to for now. mmWave 5G signals are in the 24-54 GHz range (f = c / 0.001 m ≈ 30 GHz)
- therein 5y agoThis makes me nervous. The O2 peak at 60GHz. What are your opinions on it? If we get that peak of attenuation at 60GHz, what's happening to that energy? The common wisdom would say it heats up but that's not guaranteed. https://i.imgur.com/KUR4XmX.png https://i.imgur.com/KUR4XmX.png https://i.imgur.com/iUD2v4D.png https://i.imgur.com/iUD2v4D.png https://www.5gamericas.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/InDesign-Understanding-mmWave-for-5G-Networks.pdf https://www.5gamericas.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/InDesi...
- lumost 5y agoWhat else would happen to the energy? It’ll turn into heat + some re-emissions.
- speed_spread 5y agoSemi conspiracy alert: 5G is mainly motivated by surveillance through IoT. 4G is still mostly ok as a regular "cellphone" network but isn't cheap enough to be embedded in every device. Many consumer goods now have a wifi option (like my new dishwasher) but it still need to be configured after installation, which many people won't care to do. 5G will make it cheap enough for manufacturers to bundle always-on cellular modems in every device. The cost of networking plan will be assumed by the manufacturer and be offset by the value of telemetry data collected and subscription services made possible by the always-on network. Special dishwasher cycles for an extra 3$ and other shenanigans. Obsolence no longer has to be preprogrammed but can be declared unilaterally at the time most convenient by and for marketing departments.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoI'm not seeing it. I mean yes, corporations are definitely going to attempt that and they can all die in a fire, but telemetry like that requires minimal bandwidth. It doesn't need "5G" for anything.
- therein 5y agoAnd beamforming is going to be useful for having precise location as a part of the protocol itself.
- alphabettsy 5y agoDoesn’t the number of antennas make location more precise without beamforming? Doesn’t seem like it has anything to do with location precision.
- drevil-v2 5y ago> 5G will make it cheap enough for manufacturers to bundle always-on cellular modems in every device How do you figure that? Is there something special about the 5G electronics and chipset manufacturing that make would make it much cheaper than 4G electronics? I don't think this is true.
- 5y ago
- sandoze 5y agoLots of stuff covered. Here’s a few more. In theory you should be able to take your private network anywhere there’s 5G. Industrial Ethernet. Latency, jitter, and guaranteed delivery are required in many factories. Meaning they’re still relying on cable, wiring, and proprietary PLC hardware close to the sensors. Private network slices.
- madspindel 5y ago> but even streaming video as long as not everyone on the tower is trying to do it at once 5G Broadcast solves that. Radio, live TV, popular Netflix TV shows etc. could be broadcast and save a lot of bandwidth.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoHow is that supposed to work when everything is on demand and Netflix alone has thousands of shows?
- kjellsbells 5y ago5G means so many things to people it gets muddy. If you are Verizon or ATT, you have lots of mmwave spectrum, so your interest is in dense urban environments and multi-dwelling units where your speed let's you compete against wifi and cable providers. You spent a bazillion on spectrum and you need to give your customers reasons to pay extra for their service. If you are t-mobile, you have a ton of mid range spectrum. After all, that was the only reason you bought sprint. You will want to go after consumers with a coverage play, since that is better than mmwave from T and VZ. You might also dip your toe in business services like IoT for farmers and factories. If you are a hyperscaler, you need CBRS (3.5GHz) to take off. You'll be pitching IoT and edge compute like crazy because the radio coverage is better than wifi, the speeds are good and best of all the spectrum is available at essentially nominal cost. What you won't get just yet, but will hear about a lot, are the toys like vr robots. The ugly truth is that no one really knows what the killer app for 5g is yet, but every operator is terrified that just like 4G theyll miss the value chain and leave apple or whoever to ride their network and slurp up the profit.
- ec109685 5y agoYet, those legacy operators haven’t invested a bit in an engineering and software organization capable of competing with the apple’s that ride their network.
- kjellsbells 5y agoId argue that the telco industry tried, and failed, as opposed to not trying at all. ATT for example sent a boatload of people on training from Georgia tech, invested massively in automation... and couldn't pull it off. I also blame the industry for missing the point on the whole pivot to virtualization. For those of you not in telco, telcos got together in 2012 and said, "how can we be more nimble like the cool kids?" and concluded that virtualizing everything, was the way to go, as if all it took was a vm and a k8s pod. Really it was about culture and supply chain, but that's a whole other story.
- ec109685 5y ago
- Lammy 5y ago> Can somebody explain what 5G is actually good for? Surveilling your irl location 24/7 with centimeter-precision https://www.fastcompany.com/90314058/5g-means-youll-have-to-say-goodbye-to-your-location-privacy https://www.fastcompany.com/90314058/5g-means-youll-have-to-... https://venturebeat.com/2019/04/29/sk-telecom-will-use-5g-to-build-centimeter-level-accurate-city-maps/ https://venturebeat.com/2019/04/29/sk-telecom-will-use-5g-to... https://www.ericsson.com/en/blog/2020/12/5g-positioning--what-you-need-to-know https://www.ericsson.com/en/blog/2020/12/5g-positioning--wha...
- diebeforei485 5y ago> but you're not going to get it in the middle of the woods because it also requires more towers closer together This is a misconception. You're only thinking about high-band (aka mmWave) 5G. The media has largely focused on this because of the higher speeds and its low range which makes it easy to dunk on with clickbaity articles. But this isn't particularly common outside of sports stadiums or music venues, large train stations, airports (but note that the interference in the article is not in the mmWave spectrum), university campuses, etc. 5G has much better range than 4G at the low-band, and at the mid-band they're much faster at a similar distance. If you're in the US, the only carrier that's been rolling out low-band 5G at scale thus far is T-Mobile.
- PostThisTooFast 5y ago