3 ms·
> Inflation punishes good behavior of people who save money and create cushions for the pissible bad days If everyone did that, then there wouldn't be enough c
by imtringued 5y ago
> Inflation punishes good behavior of people who save money and create cushions for the pissible bad days
If everyone did that, then there wouldn't be enough currency in circulation to actually do work. This is known as the paradox of thrift. There is a nice version of it with baby sitting coupons:
http://www.pkarchive.org/theory/baby.html http://www.pkarchive.org/theory/baby.html
TL;DR people can panic buy money the same way they can panic buy toilet paper, except money is absolutely essential for commercial employment and thereby cripples the economy through a depression.
>It robs people of their savings.
Well, you cannot save in money as money has no inherent value. The best you can do is let people promise value in the future which is exactly how our money system works. Think about it this way, you have money, the other person has 40 hours of free time this week. You save your money and the week is over, the other person was unemployed and couldn't do anything since you didn't spend your money. Ultimately that debt shouldn't exist and therefore the savings shouldn't exist either. The problem is that humans age but money does not. Thus, money allows you to isolate yourself from the "storage costs" of e.g. human labor and in a general sense it allows you to isolate yourself from losses in the economy.
Isn't that strange? Insisting that those losses should never reach you is quite selfish and would give you a lot of power over those who don't own money. I hope you see where this is going. People save, not because it is virtuous or good behavior, it's simply profitable to not be the one in debt and therefore being able to shove the problem onto someone else. E.g. see Germany shifting debt to Greece and pretending to be the good guy.
Now, imagine if we solved the inflation problem. 0% inflation every single year. The storage costs problem wouldn't be gone. The system would have to actively pass on storage costs and losses in the real economy to those holding money e.g. through negative interest rates. When people actively realize that their short term deposits are not profitable, they will either work less as they already have enough and let someone else work, or they save their money as long term deposits which have higher yields or finally they directly invest their money.
All three options are better than pretending that there is something where there is nothing.
The problem with deflation is that holding onto money becomes more profitable, which actively sabotages the medium of exchange function of money and directly competes with commercial employment. People can't trade and actually working by e.g. building cars doesn't bring in as much money. One could argue that deflation is the epitome of an anti work culture.
- bufferoverflow 5y ago> If everyone did that, then there wouldn't be enough currency in circulation to actually do work. That's just not true. Money on its own is useless to people. People want to buy stuff and services. Deflationary currency just makes them think - do I really need this stuff? Inflationary currency makes you think - I better buy at least some useless junk than lose my hard earned money.
- ekianjo 5y ago> The problem with deflation is that holding onto money becomes more profitable Nope, it is only profitable if there are no better investments out there. You are forgetting a little thing called the stock market. Nothing happens in a vacuum.