8 ms·
Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app
- smoldesu 5y agoMan, Apple's review process is getting to pretty incomprehensible heights. Certain people will have their apps rejected carte-blanche, while other developers get to... collaborate with the reviewers to blacklist objectionable content in their app? I really don't follow how a dialogue like this even starts in the first place, much less how nobody has stepped forwards and just acknowledged that this is a double-standard yet. The App Store desperately needs transparency if it wants to avoid regulatory ire. Stories like this are just getting ridiculous.
- judge2020 5y agoI doubt regulators will care about the adult content moderation policy of all things, outside of enforcing stricter age checks.
- kingcharles 5y agoNext, Apple refuses new Angry Birds update. Requests that birds be only "Mildly Annoyed".
- dvt 5y agoIf you look at it from a cynical standpoint, what's happening is completely obvious. Apple is applying the full force of their developer policy -- and the pressure is mounting -- because Tumblr has absolutely zero social capital. It's a dead platform, and other than a few zealots, just about everyone's moved on. Contrast this with Epic v. Apple: Epic has the arguable upper hand there (and Apple's flinched a few times already) because Fortnite is a massively popular game with a huge fanbase.
- whateveracct 5y agocasting tumblr users of 2021 as zealots is hilariously out of touch it's a plenty vibrant platform - all of the other social media websites are way worse, content-wise. Create a tumblr account & follow tags/accounts related to your interests. You'll get a lot of quality content! For example, there's a reason the witcher season 2's media campaign included an AMA on tumblr with one of the stars. That's where the fandom thrives. it just isn't an especially monetizable bunch of communities. Fandom in general is hard to monetize (look at the donation-driven AO3 for another community-hub more vibrant than the ones twitter and facebook can manage.)
- lmm 5y agoThis is a bit of an "Are Y'all with the Cult?" moment. Tumblr is a niche community at this point and the people who are still there are largely unusually dedicated fans.
- malwarebytess 5y agoCan you quantify that Tumblr is dead? Metrics I've seen still have it receiving a huge amount of traffic.
- StellarTabi 5y agoTwitter and Reddit constantly get progressively worse every update. You guys pretend like tumblr is dead all you want. The numbers show tumblr growing.
- jjj123 5y agoCan you share those numbers?
- 1123581321 5y agoI'm not the same user but I checked SimilarWeb (better sources may exist.) It looks like Tumblr has a lot of traffic, but isn't growing and is far behind reddit and twitter. None appear to be growing in the last several months; I don't know what that means. https://www.similarweb.com/website/tumblr.com/?competitors=reddit.com https://www.similarweb.com/website/tumblr.com/?competitors=r... https://www.similarweb.com/website/tumblr.com/?competitors=twitter.com https://www.similarweb.com/website/tumblr.com/?competitors=t... Tumblr is about equal to wordpress.com hosted blog traffic, interestingly. Wordpress.com is a collection of hosted blogs with very light in-network social features. https://www.similarweb.com/website/tumblr.com/?competitors=wordpress.com https://www.similarweb.com/website/tumblr.com/?competitors=w...
- whateveracct 5y ago
- LordDragonfang 5y agoI mean tumblr is a dead platform because of Apple applying the full force of its developer policies. It lost Three quarters of its active users in the span of a few months after the 2018 porn ban fiasco (which majorly affected sfw artists as well because the rollout was so botched) which the OP explains Apple's hand in.
- lsiebert 5y agoYeah, my understanding was that apple cracking down was merely the excuse Verizon, which owned tumblr at the time, used to justify banning porn, but it was about ad revenue. Twitter certainly has plenty of porn.
- markx2 5y agoIt is nothing to do with Apple. That is a distraction. It is all about advertising.
- DantesKite 5y agoI don't think this is true, because the Reddit iOS app would've been shut down ages ago if it was.
- jackson1442 5y ago> Apple is applying the full force of their developer policy source? not sure why tumblr is the only app doing this then since reddit and twitter have a plethora of porn and other "unsavory" content available on their official iOS clients.
- saagarjha 5y agoThey get squeezed about it regularly as well.
- judge2020 5y agoIf “submission” is added automatically, why would it be used for BDSM content when so much of the content in search results would be off-topic?
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoI figure a lot of people tagging do the shotgun blast of tags: just add a bunch of relevant tags to increase visibility. They probably don't consider people actually searching this phrase in particular.
- markx2 5y agoI very much doubt this is due to Apple. Automattic bought tumblr to make money. They can't make the money they want unless they make tumblr more advertising friendly, and that means slowly but surely eliminating - basically non-Google friendly - content. Eliminate tags, sites using those tags their traffic goes down, they move elsewhere. tumblr looks pure and wholesome. That's the plan.
- noahtallen 5y agoOne thing I’ve never been sure of is how Reddit has been so successful with NSFW content. It’s certainly not banned from the platform, so how is it able to get away with it compared to the other services? It’s also mostly an ad business, right? Whereas other as businesses like YouTube have historically been very prudish (swearing can demonetize a video and nsfw content isn’t allowed)
- markx2 5y agoI have no knowledge of how Reddit handles NSFW content. I have some knowledge of how Automattic does. From what I have seen as an active reddit user of 10yrs+, the ads I see on - for example - /r/culinaryskills, /r/gamedeals, /r/dogs - are quite different. They are targeted in some way. All WordPress.com sites - and I assume tumblr sites - could have ads shown. One way to stop ads being shown on those sites is to apply a tag. Call that tag "mature" A site tagged as "mature" will - not appear to other sites - will therefore experience a drop-off in traffic - but will still appear in Google but because of the lack of linking will be much much lower in results. Reddit cannot add those tags as fast and (maybe) as accurately as a blogging service can so it gets away with it. That said, they do have the ability to quarantine sites and I have no idea at all if they hide NSFW content from crawlers.
- riantogo 5y agoSo you are saying there appears to be a way (likely nontrivial) that Tumblr could adopt (maybe same as reddit) to keep both advertisers and community happy?
- Animats 5y agoThe list of bad words: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1YG7E84Dvs2PyoKMgSgZFgEX0Kh0RtJqsazZsyVGY8dk/preview https://docs.google.com/document/d/1YG7E84Dvs2PyoKMgSgZFgEX0... This is the trouble with online censorship. It gets totally out of control very fast.
- pmlnr 5y ago[...] "me", "corset", "sad" [...] Wtf tumblr?
- tyingq 5y ago"CNC" is even bolded. And that's probably one of the more lucrative topics for ads...that is things like CNC routers. I have no idea what the naughty version of CNC is. Edit: Ahh. "Consensual Non-Consent", I guess people that like to play act rape.
- smoldesu 5y agoRemember kids: be careful writing sad things online, or else your iPhone-owning friends may not get to see it.
- wruza 5y agoIt’s just pointless, because people find a way. If you ban e.g. “sh#t” aggressively, the auditory will eventually invent series of local euphemisms and one morning you find yourself banning “skittles” and “slip” somehow. Sad thing is, these guys never learn the history of internet forums and put the same snakeoil compresses again and again. It gets totally out of control very fast There is a way to censor internet correctly in a controlled way, it is human-oriented moderation. HN is a good example of it (in a good sense). We have near zero “bad” content or discussion here, but you’d never encounter the famous “sorry, your post contains a word from our stop-list”. Because words aren’t a cause, they are an effect. Appeal directly to the cause: human personal sense of the appreciated culture and the reasons to have it. Those who get it will try to moderate themselves out of respect, those who do not will find themselves in a vacuum or quickly flagged. When site owners believe in automated moderation by a whip, they are doomed and rightly so.
- kingcharles 5y agoI wonder if this is the reason my gf's (reasonably popular) account was terminated out of the blue. It certainly contains a number of the banned tags.
- cipheredStones 5y agoOne of Tumblr's former iOS devs thinks that this astonishingly clumsy move is the result of Tumblr (and all other iOS apps) needing to appease Apple's randomly-selected reviewers - each with their own interpretation of the content guidelines - rather than needing to meet the guidelines per se. https://sreegs.tumblr.com/post/671649355334336512/alright-lets-talk-about-apple-and-tumblrs https://sreegs.tumblr.com/post/671649355334336512/alright-le...
- diebeforei485 5y agoI find the censorship of iOS apps to be dystopian, because Apple doesn't allow them to say that some other results exist but are unavailable in the app.
- forgotmypw17 5y agohttps://nitter.kavin.rocks/Foone/status/1474985481737625606 https://nitter.kavin.rocks/Foone/status/1474985481737625606
- propogandist 5y agoI didn't realize Tumblr was sold to Automattic for $3 million. Yahoo bought it for $1.1 Billion just a few years prior (which made zero sense at the time). Yahoo was truly a poorly run business with an incompetent executive team.
- astrea 5y agoWas? Don't they still exist?
- propogandist 5y agoYahoo was sold to Verizon for $4.8 billion in 2016 [1]. VZ then merged it with their AOL acquisition under the brand Oath, which was then rebranded to Verizon Media Group. The whole thing was apparently unloaded to a private equity group for $5 Billion recently [2] and has been renamed back to Yahoo... so yes, they still exist and now "Yahoo!" includes AOL too. [1] https://mashable.com/article/yahoo-verizon-acquired-bought https://mashable.com/article/yahoo-verizon-acquired-bought [2] https://techcrunch.com/2021/09/01/apollo-completes-its-5b-acquisition-of-verizon-media-now-known-as-yahoo/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/09/01/apollo-completes-its-5b-ac...
- 5y ago
- trollian 5y agoI think it's great that users have a choice of mobile platforms. Many people would rather not have any adult content on their phones and they choose iOS. Who are we to force it upon them? If they wanted a an uncensored experience they would have bought a different phone.
- smoldesu 5y agoNo one here is forcing it upon anyone; the easy solution here is to have the app filter NSFW content by default and then force the user to manually enable it if they do want to engage with the content, which appeases both users. Trying to argue that having your hands tied isn't so bad because your feet are still free is a very slippery slope though, and it's not an argument that ends with anyone's platforms being better. It's especially not an argument when the platform owners have practically infinite resources and bigger fish to fry than "how hard is it to access porn on my iPhone". What we really need to do is take a long, hard look at the devices we have, and decide whether we are the ones who should control them, or third parties. Pretty much every other argument is a strawman.
- Griffinsauce 5y agoYou could even make it a system-wide setting that you can control through parental controls, giving you an extra selling point for the "think of the children" crowd.
- slaymaker1907 5y agoPlease show me where exactly Apple advertises itself as porn-free in regards to iOS.
- Lazare 5y agoPlease. iPhones have a browser; you can open google image search, type "sex" and get some adult content. Apple is not attempting to create an adult content free device (not that it'd be a good idea if they were; it's just that is clearly not a thing they are attempting to do).
- 5y ago
- meibo 5y agoDiscord hides all NSFW servers on iOS now by default. They're just gone - you need to open it on a PC and enable a setting to get them to show up. At least they give you the choice.
- MrDresden 5y agoWhat actually is Tumblr business model? I never seem to see any ads on the few occasions I end up on a Tumblr page.
- evanelias 5y agoIt's a social network. Logged-in users see ads on their dashboard (activity feed), which makes up most of Tumblr's traffic. If you're only ever viewing Tumblr "pages" from the public blog network and without an account, you have never really interacted with the majority of the product. It would be like if your only experience with Facebook was viewing businesses' public Pages without an account, and then wondering what their business model is because there's no ads on FB Pages. Your point of confusion is a common one though, which really speaks to Tumblr's biggest marketing failure. Sadly, it also indicates that those login walls/nags on Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, Pinterest, Reddit, etc are actually somehow necessary for people to grok a social product that has a public-facing component.