6 ms·
> You can defraud people at scale and completely get away with it Ever heard of fiat currency inflation?
by ekianjo 5y ago
> You can defraud people at scale and completely get away with it
Ever heard of fiat currency inflation?
- mrosett 5y agoYou're not wrong, but the USD has had ~6% inflation over the last year while Bitcoin has experienced ~15% inflation since the end of last motnh.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoKind of cherry picking when over the same year as the 6%, Bitcoin has experienced ~45% deflation, isn't it?
- vorpalhex 5y agoStability is a feature. 6% is pretty rough, ~45% is atrocious world ending stuff.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe deflationary aspect of Bitcoin was a design flaw, but it's not inherent to cryptocurrencies generally. Nothing says there has to be a finite supply of coins as opposed to the supply scaling in proportion to how much the value of the currency exceeds the cost of hardware or electricity. And even with Bitcoin itself, think about what Wall Street and governments would do with securities derivatives and Bitcoin-denominated debt instruments. The supply of Bitcoin isn't actually limited by the supply of Bitcoin.
- ekianjo 5y ago> Stability is a feature so the USD going to the ground at 6% per year is a feature? Aren't currencies supposed to be store of value over the long term, you know, over dozens of years since you need hard cash to retire?
- vorpalhex 5y agoInflation has historically been targeted around 2%, though we've seen period of higher inflation and sometimes very rarely a little bit of deflation (though not recently). Some inflation is normal and fine. 6% is rough but tolerable, but getting it back to 2% is obviously desirable.
- ekianjo 5y ago> Inflation has historically been targeted around 2%, thats' been much higher than that because the basket they use to measure inflation is not at all representative and does not account for the cost of energy, anywhere. Believing the propaganda from governments does not help much.
- vorpalhex 5y agoRight we don't include fuel or groceries in that normalized figure because across the US it will pull the average in very funny places. The figure with those included is available on the same page, but it's not the standard inflation figure. It's far too boring to be some conspiracy or propaganda.
- ekianjo 5y ago> It's far too boring to be some conspiracy or propaganda. You don't even need to bring lizard men in the mix to understand that the government has a clear conflict of interest when it comes to reporting inflation.
- seoaeu 5y agoYou’re just providing additional evidence that Bitcoin is widely more volatile than USD. A +45% swing this year could easily mean a -45% swing next year…
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoGoalposts wherever you like. > A +45% swing this year could easily mean a -45% swing next year... Volatility is a function of speculation. When most of the currency supply is held by speculators, high volatility. Less of that the more people actually use it as a currency.
- ekianjo 5y ago> You're not wrong, but the USD has had ~6% inflation over the last year while Bitcoin has experienced ~15% inflation since the end of last motnh. I was merely making a point that if you think defrauding currencies is limited to crypto, you are missing the big picture that every currency out there has been smashed by inflation over the past 50 years. Look at how the dollar went downhill since it went off the gold standard. And that's within one's lifetime.
- woodruffw 5y agoBarring specific examples of governments inflating their currencies to escape sovereign (not individual!) debts, can you explain how inflation "defrauds" anyone? You might as well say that deflation does too, since it amplifies illiquid market behaviors and is a net detriment to the economy[1]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Effects
- karaterobot 5y ago> Barring specific examples of governments inflating their currencies to escape sovereign (not individual!) debts, can you explain how inflation "defrauds" anyone? Why this would be barred?
- woodruffw 5y agoBecause it's a form of sovereign financial structuring, not the state attempting to defraud individual citizens. It's another one to file under "words mean specific things, and abusing the language does a disservice to an otherwise reasonable point."
- bufferoverflow 5y agoI will take deflation over inflation any day of the week. Inflation punishes good behavior of people who save money and create cushions for the pissible bad days. It robs people of their savings. I've been storing my life savings in crypto, and so far it's been phenomenal compared to my USD ones. Deflation actually forces you to think of how to spend money more rationally, not to buy junk that will pollute the planet. (yes, I know BTC mining isn't great for the emissions, and I wouldn't recommend BTC anyway)
- woodruffw 5y ago> I will take deflation over inflation any day of the week. Inflation punishes good behavior of people who save money and create cushions for the pissible[sic] bad days. It robs people of their savings. As an individual, deflation benefits me too. But that's because you and I are individual actors, not a government in charge of maintaining a diverse economy of actors. To cut the entire thing short: the general undesirability of deflation is considered a settled matter in economics. Just about any resource will help explain why that is, and why we (agents in the economy) benefit from small amounts of inflation.
- imtringued 5y agoInflation isn't controlled by any single person, not even the fed can control inflation, they can only "mitigate" it by making it harder to borrow new money. For example. If the government were to ban car imports, then if inflation were a tax, it would be levied by the car companies, not by the government. When workers demand higher wages, then they would be the ones taxing the owners of money. The only universal statement that you can make about inflation is that it hurts creditors and benefits debtors and it often does so in a way that prevents debt slavery which is why I personally am fine with some degree of monetary inflation. My point is that creditors and debtors can be completely different people at different time periods. After world war 2 consumers had very little debt but the government had a lot of it because of the war. Nowadays young students have a lot of debt. Homeowners have extremely expensive mortgages. Companies borrow to pay out dividends or do stock buybacks. Wealthy people may go into debt for tax reasons. Blanket statements about who is benefiting aren't really possible so being angry by default about inflation helps no one.