3 ms·
Communism would be great if people would actually be good. It's hard to not feel enticed by a future where everyone has equal rights, where the plentiful resour
by jeroenhd 5y ago
Communism would be great if people would actually be good. It's hard to not feel enticed by a future where everyone has equal rights, where the plentiful resources of the world are shared among everyone else and where there is no need for class warfare.
Sadly, time and again humanity has proven unable to do good at the scale of a country. The laudable ideals of any political system will need to resist man's evil nature or they're doomed to fail, and the communist regimes have all proven to be to easy to corrupt.
Communism isn't evil, it's foolish. The same way the idea that unrestricted capitalism is foolish if you strive to make everyone's lives better.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 5y agoThis is interesting because it's based on a view of socialism/communism that Marx mocked and ridiculed socialists for holding. Marx argued that those who wanted to create socialism or communism through altruism were fools - his argument was that socialism was only possible once a society was well developed enough that it was in the self interest of the working class to force distribution of wealth. He repeatedly criticised attempts to argue for equality for the sake of it rather than redistribution that would benefit those demanding it.
- lelanthran 5y ago> Communism would be great if people would actually be good. That's a tautology: Anything would be great if people were actually good[1]. That you need to rely on some external force of good for Communism to look good says more about Communism than any propaganda machine ever could. [1] Other -isms would work even better than Communism if people were good.
- PixyMisa 5y ago> Communism would be great if people would actually be good. Communism replaces a multitude of small, localised optimisation problems with a single, centralised, completely intractable optimisation problem, and at the same time destroys the very information required to tackle that problem at all. Communism cannot work on any but the smallest scale, and is utterly doomed when applied to any modern nation state. J. B. S. Haldane - himself a socialist - pointed this out as far back as 1928.* Whether communism is inherently evil or not, we know for a fact that it cannot ever work. > The laudable ideals of any political system will need to resist man's evil nature The solution to that is not to permit the government the ability to cause great harm to its citizens in the first place. * See "On Being the Right Size", an essay mostly on scaling in biology, but also touching on related subjects.
- DarylZero 5y agoThat's assuming we want to tackle this "optimization problem"... people under capitalism may be more interested in escaping from the over-optimization of everything.
- shrimpx 5y agoI agree with your comment but I would add that whatever the Russians and Chinese have done is not "communism" in any meaningful sense.
- anovikov 5y agoEverything would be great if people would actually be good; but in any case, lack of possibility to improve your and your posterity's life outcomes vs others, by saving/investing/building capital, which is the case in both socialism and communism, is a depressing thing to think of and i don't think it's "great" in any sense of it.