6 ms·
While the M1 is definitely impressive, Apple has been known for their lacking cooling designs and weird performance curves back in the Intel days. This compari
by jeroenhd 5y ago
While the M1 is definitely impressive, Apple has been known for their lacking cooling designs and weird performance curves back in the Intel days.
This comparison maybe Apples to Apples, but it's not really apples to apples. Modern Intel and even older Intel can bring a lot more to the table than the Mac Pro from a few years back could deliver because of Apple's design decisions. You could make the argument that you're just benchmarking Apple Macbooks to choose a platform to run macOS on, but then the datacenter CPU doesn't really add anything.
If you're going to throw a datacenter GPU into the comparison, at least grab a modern Intel chip for your benchmarks. The 9980HK is from two years ago, back when Intel was already losing ground to AMD. The 10th, 11th and 12th gen processors made significant performance improvements since then (12900HK performing twice as well in some benchmarks compared to the 9980HK), at the cost of thermals and power usage.
The M1 will probably still beat a modern Intel chip, but by a significantly smaller margin in terms of performance (battery usage, though, is a whole different story).
- jb1991 5y ago> If you're going to throw a datacenter GPU Do you mean CPU?
- starfallg 5y agoThe funny thing is that the Threadripper isn't even a DC/Server CPU, it's a workstation CPU. The whole comparison is undermined by the design choices.
- KarlKemp 5y agoIt’s undermined by comparing a laptop to a $50,000 workstation? In that it is unfair to the workstation?
- ilogik 5y agoaccording to rumours, the upcoming Mac Pro chips will have 2x to 4x the core count of the M1 Pro/Max
- zeusk 5y agoIn a way, yes. They use a 3995WX with 128 threads but the benchmark is single threaded? Also, 3995WX is definitely NUMA so their benchmark is skewing the results.
- ashvardanian 5y agoThis benchmark isn’t single threaded, it utilizes all the physical cores found in the machine, 64 on Threadripper and 10 on Mac. See the source for details: https://github.com/unum-cloud/HashTableBenchmark/blob/00f94c30352cb5c4f6e66bd6204a1985402d1c2b/src/wrappers.hpp#L28 https://github.com/unum-cloud/HashTableBenchmark/blob/00f94c...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- starfallg 5y agoWhether it is fair (or not) is a value judgement. All I said was that the comparison was done poorly. Those choices together with single-threaded memory-intensive benchmarks (esp. those sensitive to memory latency) is problematic because the whole point of using a workstation CPU like the Threadripper Pro is for multi-threaded performance with a wide memory bus (sometimes NUMA). And they make a big deal out of it, emphasising the $50k price tag to paint the M1 Pro/Max as some sort of "Dragon Slayer". If they did a more rounded comparison including stuff like kernel compile times, etc. then maybe they are justified, but as it stands it's just unprofessional.
- klelatti 5y agoIt would be utterly astonishing if the the MacBook outperformed the workstation on all benchmarks. The post doesn’t claim that it does. The fact that the MacBook outperforms the workstation on some benchmarks is an interesting and, for some users, relevant datapoint. To point this out with full and detailed disclosure of the tests performed isn’t unprofessional at all.
- ashvardanian 5y agoThanks a lot for support! It feels like some people forgot to read not just the title of the article, but also the subtitle…
- klelatti 5y agoI genuinely thought it was one of the most interesting articles on the M1 we’ve seen. Thanks for your work in putting it together - any follow ups would be much appreciated.
- jeroenhd 5y agoThe 3995WX is a 6 grand chip. Not cheap, but you don't need to pay 50k for a workstation if you're going to compare it to a Macbook. That 1TB of RAM will be a much more significant part of the cost of the machine, but you could never get that in an M1 Mac so the cost is a useless metric. I can't tell if these tests make use of multiple threads or not. I don't think they are, because the 128 threads should absolutely crush the 16 threads of the 9980HK. If it's not, Apple's flagship chips are sorely losing to a chip that's been optimised to bring multicore performance by sacrificing single core performance. It'd be like bringing an F1 car to a dirt track and measuring performance against a rally car, and still losing to the F1. That wouldn't bode well for an M1 Mac Pro at all, unless there's some serious GPU power hidden in there that an AMD GPU wouldn't be able to provide at a similar price.
- danachow 5y ago> It'd be like bringing an F1 car to a dirt track and measuring performance against a rally car, and still losing to the F1. Huh?
- ashvardanian 5y agoSure, you can configure a cheaper server with just the hardware needed for this benchmark, this is just the fastest machine we have in our cluster RAM-wise, that has one NUMA node. That's why we added it as an extra point of reference. The core comparison is of course between two generations of MacBooks, as the title suggests. Plus, $3000 on Macbooks isnt going to exclusively to CPU and RAM either. You buy the whole system. I am not even sure if we can find out the price of the M1 alone. I guess it will be around $500 for the M1 SoC vs $6000 for the Threadripper, still a 12x difference, even if we keep their power consumption out of the equation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throw8932894 5y agoOn some intel CPUs charger included with Macbook does not not satisfy CPUs power consumption. So if you ran CPU on 100%, it will use battery to get extra power, and macbook will eventually die, after battery reaches 0%. This is not how you design "workstation". Macbooks are just toys.
- plantain 5y ago[citation needed] I've only ever seen this happen if you use the lower wattage charger from a 12" Macbook Air with a higher spec'd Macbook Pro.
- aemreunal 5y agoWhile I don't agree with parent's declaration of all MacBooks being toys, that battery drain issue while being plugged in definitely did happen. Couldn't find a source for it just now, though. It used to happen on my 15" 2013 MacBook Pro when it was plugged in and I was playing games (BioShock Infinite was one such game).
- gerardvivancos 5y agoIt is easy to make my 2019 16" MBP consume more than the 96W that the included charger provides. Loading the CPU alone gets you close to that. Just add some discrete GPU work and there you go. In fact, since connecting an external display enables the dGPU, the consumption can increase enough to get you over 96W with the CPU alone
- can16358p 5y agoNope. The charger provided with 16" MBP (2019) can't delived the maximum required wattage to the MBP if everything (CPU, GPU, screen brightness) is at max usage. It's no issue for "everyday use" of most users, for sure, but for a pro machine... Stupid, but true.
- celsoazevedo 5y agoThis happened with my 2019 16" MBP (i9 8-core 2.3GHz). No charger, including Apple's own 96W, was enough when doing something heavy like CPU video encoding. Last year I had to convert some blu-ray movies so I could stream them to my TV and it was common to go to bed with 100% and wake up at 20% or so. Throttling kicks in when the battery is too low, so I don't think it would shut down, but yeah, this was one of its flaws. It also overheats and throttles very quickly (~1 minute) even with a more aggressive fan curve or even fans manually set to run at 100%. This can be managed by disabling Intel's Turbo Boost or by using Monterey's power saving mode, but that's not something one expects to do on a "Pro" machine.
- klelatti 5y ago> At the cost of thermals and power usage Isn’t this the whole point? Sure if you give Intel a bigger thermal envelope it will do better than the M1 but that really is Apples to oranges.
- Redoubts 5y agoDepends if you feel the thermal constraints are inherent to the form factor, or simply sloppy engineering.
- i_am_proteus 5y agoHorse is a lot faster than a motorcycle if all you've got for fuel is oats, hay, and water. Adding in some gasoline would be apples-to-oranges.
- gonehome 5y agoMore like a Tesla vs a gas guzzling rocket car. Rocket car may be technically faster under optimal conditions - but everything else about it sucks.
- i_am_proteus 5y agoIt's not clear to this reader which of Intel or Apple you mean for each of your examples. "Everything else about it sucks" certainly seems like it doesn't apply to either.
- sschueller 5y agoI found the i9 in macbook pro so severally throttled most likely because of heat that it underperforms compared to a 10 year old high end i7. The i9 in that from factor is pointless IMO.
- afr0ck 5y agoI have an Intel I9 workstation machine, I use it mainly for developement. Let me tell you something: it's the most horrible machine I've ever had in terms of performance (based on compiling a very large C code base).
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>Apple has been known for their lacking cooling designs and weird performance curves back in the Intel days. Isn't that at least partly because Intel over promissed and under delivered.
- qeternity 5y agoMy desktop rig went from a recent overclocked i5 32gb ram hackintosh to an 8gb ram m1 mini when they first came out, and the performance was mind blowing. I also grabbed an m1 mbp at the same time, which demolished my previous intel mbp but the hackintosh comparison is the one that sealed the debate for me. I had a massive cooler installed and yet the m1 mini was easily twice as fast. I couldn't get my hands on the 16gb versions at launch, and for the first year they were still so much faster even when swapping 6-10gb but I am feeling the ram crunch a bit these days. I recently upgraded the rest of my team to the new 14 inch pros with 32gb ram and I'll be grabbing one for myself when I have the time next year to do a time machine transfer.