6 ms·
I remember someone here putting it this way: treat user data like uranium, not oil. Both are valuable, but you don’t want to just collect and store an unlimited
by ryandrake 5y ago
I remember someone here putting it this way: treat user data like uranium, not oil. Both are valuable, but you don’t want to just collect and store an unlimited amount of uranium. Collect the bare minimum user data you need to operate your business and then dispose of it when it’s no longer needed.
- ftyers 5y agoI read it on Idlewords: https://idlewords.com/talks/haunted_by_data.htm https://idlewords.com/talks/haunted_by_data.htm. Pretty much all the talks there are fantastic!
- jacquesm 5y agoThat's a very good analogy, I like it.
- cik2e 5y agoBut, to use your analogy, why would companies treat user data like uranium when risk/reward is like that of oil? Grinder surely made much more from data sales than the 6.something million Erous it was find. The paltry fines under GDPR do nothing to dissuade this behavio. That's been a recurring theme in previous HN discussions on this topic. Right now, I would posit that these low penalties are for show. Governments don't want to lose the economic benefit of having these companies operate in the EU and the general public can be satisfied that their governments are on top of the issue.
- MauranKilom 5y ago> Grinder surely made much more from data sales than the 6.something million Erous it was find. ...sure, but they also had business expenses. Fining them for all the revenue would more or less instantly kill the company, which is hardly the goal.
- cik2e 5y agoI've got an estimate here that says Grindr is doing 31 million dollars net on over 100 mil revenue per year. I am by no means in favor of running these companies into the ground. The fines are definitely a balancing act. But it seems at the present moment the expected value of breaking the rules is substantily higher than 0. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-ppp-grindr-idUSKBN247308 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-ppp-gr...
- jacquesm 5y agoWait until they try this again. It may not be the Norwegian DPA that acts the next time around, it could be the UK DPO, the Dutch AP or any one of a whole raft of others, and they'll all take into account that they were already fined once before. This fine is level '2', apparently you ignored the first warning so now you get a major but not crippling fine. The next one will not be at that level, there is a pretty clear progression for repeat fines. One case, a hospital first got a warning, then a small fine and then a mid six figure fine for a case involving a single patient. You can rely on them having learned their lesson and that there will not be a third fine.
- dfxm12 5y agoWhat does it mean for data to be no longer needed when one of your income streams is to sell user data?
- SCHiM 5y agoIt means that democratic societies have decided that that type of business practice is undesirable, and should go away.
- jacquesm 5y agoIf you keep it around to sell then you are likely violating the 'legal basis for processing' part of the GDPR. Data can only be used for the purpose for which it was originally collected, selling the data to others to use without that exact same goal can not be such a purpose, and even then you will have to be quite careful that you maintain control. Various EU data brokers (Schober, for instance) have found ways to do this in a controlled manner usually by anonymizing the data or by selling it only in aggregate form. But selling it raw with the personal identifying information of the data subject is almost always a complete no-go.
- adrianN 5y agoGDPR only requires informed consent to allow selling of data as far as I know. Am I wrong about that?
- yulaow 5y agoGDPR requires informed consent for ANY type of storing or managing any kind of personal data or data which can be linked to personal data (eg email which can contain name and surname of the person behind an account), and you must be explicit on what you do and you cannot give the data to another entity without re-requiring consent for that specific purpose and declaring who will be exactly the new controller of that data.
- ifjimelse 5y agoI’m not sure where you got that idea from. Consent is just one of the six available lawful bases under the GDPR. https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protection/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/lawful-basis-for-processing/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio...
- kryogen1c 5y agoneat, this analogy travels pretty far - user data is radioactive. theres a background amount of radiation. its everywhere, even in higher amounts than youd expect like bananas and airplanes. no amount is safe, but the risks are neglibly small when exposure is minimized. concentrated amounts can be safe when exposure is controlled and managed with oversight programs in place. disasters can be managed with disaster programs, but its still possible that unforseen problems can cause big issues. unregulated handling can poison local populations. corporate influence on government can be a problrm. what a comparison! there should be an award for this.
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoAh, the linear no threshold theory of radiation. If background radiation is everywhere, how can there be no safe dose. It’s a fun analogy, but reinforces an incorrect assumption.
- rileymat2 5y agoCan’t it be like playing Russian roulette with a gun that has billions of chambers? The gun is always unsafe, but you will probably be fine? The higher the level, the more full chambers?
- aidenn0 5y agoThat's also the linear no threshold model. The risk of dying increases linearly with the number of bullets you load. A different model suggests that very low levels are either benign or even helpful.
- emn13 5y agoI can't find any solid supporting sources that provide any evidence that there exists a positively safe dosage, but even the linear-no-threshold models suggest the effects of low dosages are small enough to be hard to measure; i.e. which model is correct is practically irrelevant for low enough (e.g. 1-10 mSv?) dosages.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoYou can collect as much data as you like, its what you do with it that counts.
- phoe-krk 5y agoI don't think your statement holds true in practice. Collecting data that you then don't do anything with, in theory or even in practice, is also something that GDPR penalizes, since there's no need for you to collect it if you claim you don't do anything with it.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoNot doing something with the data is also a function, just like Nulls are a value, so yes you are right that collecting the data and not doing anything with it could be viewed negatively when up before data commissioners. Its interesting watching how the IT industry views GDPR and the advice given out by various law firms. You see unlike maths which is pure, language is vague and open to interpretation, the trick is convincing the decision maker ie data commissioner or judge that your interpretation is the correct one and not just an incorrect herd mentality sweeping the IT industry, which you see in the comments posted here and elsewhere.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mrweasel 5y agoRight It’s the storing and sharing part that’s a liability.
- leodriesch 5y agoI think the less data you collect the less impact a leak or rogue employee can have. Imagine if Hacker News would leak its user database. I assume there is not much in there, so the impact would pretty much be non existent.
- jacquesm 5y ago
- spaetzleesser 5y agoAs usual this fine is not enough as deterrent.
- zitterbewegung 5y agoGreat minds think alike . I’ve thought of this way in a broader sense. If you have any data from user data to internal data from various LOB it should be : Data is the new uranium.
- datavirtue 5y agoThe data is power and can equate to money quite easily. This means that people are not going to handle data responsibly unless forced to do so. Most companies have zero data controls and it ends up getting passed around everywhere and saved off by employees for their own personal use. It's like waving money in front of people when you have no way to determine if it gets stolen or by whom. I was raised in a family bookeeping business that handled all of the vital business data for hundreds of clients. Data protection and privacy (respect for clients) were always job #1. This came to be my philosophy for all user data in any context. A philosophy that very few people share--and the rise of the web seems to have reversed any possibility of such a philosophy taking hold as user data became a form of currency.