13 ms·
LG’s new 16:18 monitor
- elevanation 5y agoI'm still a fan of the 16:10 format (1920x1200, 2560x1600, 3840x2400). Has anyone seen any new desktop monitors in this format? (I know it's unlikely, but one can always hope...)
- renw0rp 5y agoThis would be my preferred choice as well, but I haven't seen anything new coming to market, especially bigger diagonal/higher resolution. It's not exactly what I was looking for, but I'm tempted to try Huawei 28.2 2:3 monitor if I get a chance
- raihansaputra 5y agoI used to prefer 16:10 too, but increasing ppi/size makes using 16:9 displays a non-problem for me (24" 1200 -> 27" 4k). 16:10 / 2:3 still matters a lot at laptop sizes though.
- jbverschoor 5y agoDell usually sell those..
- justin66 5y agoDell's newest is the P2421 (near the low end in terms of cost, at least - I believe they've got a 30" for roughly a thousand dollars). I have three U2415 monitors that I've been very happy with, and the P2421 seems to be the recent evolution of that model.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- metaphor 5y agoThe P2421 suffers from same dilemma as legacy 16:10 displays: they're still just single-link WUXGA. Furthermore, it's not a UltraSharp series display, which suggests (at a minimum) no proper color calibration out of the box...perhaps not just a personal nit given desktop productivity users tend to use them in multi-display setups almost exclusively. A decade-ish ago when the U2412M was in production, shit color calibration was a particularly egregious trend that Dell eventually corrected with their U2415 offering. Now the best they have to offer is U2421E, which eliminates the bottom bezel (nice for portrait mode users) and throws a USB-C hub on, but still no progress on the native resolution front and panel quality is reported to be inferior to its U2415 predecessor. So I'm also stuck with U2415 for now, but I'd really like to see if coding on higher resolution displays truly squares with all the hype. Might have switched to 16:9 a while ago, but the substantial loss of vertical coupled with excessive horizontal when working in CAD has been a showstopper for me.
- justin66 5y ago> panel quality is reported to be inferior to its U2415 predecessor Ah, that's disappointing. Those monitors fill a nice niche. I remember buying monitors 20 years ago, and I remember what stuff cost back then, so I don't complain too much (we've got a lot of bargains) and I accept that "you get what you pay for." The disappointing thing is the nonsensical nature of monitor pricing. It tends to be a pretty bimodal distribution and it often takes some research to figure out why something is cheap or expensive.
- Loic 5y agoLenovo ThinkVision. I have two 24", each in 1920x1200 as setup, I am satisfied with the quality but I must confess that I am just coding and doing little graphical work.
- metaphor 5y agoWhat model? I just browsed through Lenovo's display offerings and didn't see a single 16:10 aspect ratio display listed anywhere.
- Loic 5y agoThis one: https://www.lenovo.com/de/de/accessories-and-monitors/monitors/office/T24d-10A16240WT0-24inch-MonitorHDMI/p/61B4MAT1EU https://www.lenovo.com/de/de/accessories-and-monitors/monito...
- metaphor 5y agoI see, thanks for clarifying. In the US market[1], it appears to be a discontinued model. [1] https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/p/accessories-and-software/monitors/office/61b4mar1us https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/p/accessories-and-software/moni...
- layer8 5y ago16:10 has had a resurgence for 21-24" monitors (for generic office use), but unfortunately not for larger sizes. I’m still hanging on to a 27" 16:10 Dell monitor from 2008.
- rektide 5y agoreduced major first / minor first ratios, for reference: 16:18: 1.125 / 0.888 4:5: 1.2 / 0.8 16:10: 1.6 / 0.625 16:9: 1.778 / 0.563 2.38: 2.38 / 0.42
- ralferoo 5y agoThis new format sounds interesting. I personally have been using a fairly cheap 48" 4K TV as my primary desktop monitor for a number of years, as that combination is effectively like a 2x2 arrangement of normal sized 1080p monitors. It works well, except that it was basically impossible at the time to find a graphics card that could drive it reliably at 60Hz (I tried both a Radeon R9 270X and an nVidia 1060, both of which were newly released at the time). The 1060 is better in that it actually manages 60Hz, but only in YUV422 mode (which is mostly fine as I primarily do black-and-white code editing) and if I want to avoid YUV fringing, I need to run at 30Hz. The Radeon required me to use an external DP-to-HDMI adapter, which worked, but then I hit driver redraw issues, so I stopped using it within about a week. But in any case, the biggest problem with a set-up like this is that it's so hard to go back to using a small monitor afterwards. Even dual-screen feels cramped afterwards!
- ciupicri 5y agoAren't TVs too glossy to be used as monitors?
- vladvasiliu 5y agoI've wanted to do a similar thing, but I wonder: don't you end up sitting too far from the screen, so that the perceived text size is smaller than on the regular 24" screens? I have a 32" screen and if I sit as close to it as a 24", the sides don't look so great any more because of the angle. So I have to push it back, but then I have to increase the text. While with two screens, you can set the second one at an angle, which alleviates this problem. I expect the curved screens to do the same, though I've never tried one.
- wombatmobile 5y agoI use a 42" monitor and it's never worked as well as I wanted it to. I wanted to have 16 windows open at once so I could see all the spreadsheets, text files, folders, pictures relevant to the legal matters I was working on. The 3840 x 2160 pixels lets me do it, but there are drawbacks and limitations: 1. Only the windows in the center of the screen are easy to perceive. I have to turn my neck or my eyes to bring the other windows into my attention, or sit further away from the whole screen, as if I had a smaller monitor. 2. The Mac menu is all the way up the top left. That makes using any app in any window that isn't top left difficult because I have to keep sending the mouse away long distance. A friend got something instead which is better: Two very wide and not very tall monitors, which he arranges vertically stacked. What makes this so successful is that each monitor has its own menu. I wish I could accomplish the same thing by telling OSX to split the screen horizontally across the middle so I had two menu's too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eckmLJE 5y agoIs it just me or from the pictures does it not look like a 16:18 ratio? Maybe it's the perspective of the photos but it looks much less square than that.
- tirpen 5y agoI just wish there was anyone making good 4:3 monitors with modern panels that do not cost an arm and a leg. 4:3 is still my preferred screen ratio without a doubt for everything except watching movies, all current wide screen rations feel to vertically squashed for me, I always end up with half the screen unused and wishing I had a decimeter height more. So I'm probably buying one of these if the price is not too outrageous, it seems like it's close enough to 4:3 to capture the same feeling.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MisterTea 5y agoI still use a Samsung 21 1600x1200 LCD as a secondary display. Wish I had more. Unfortunately 16:9 is here to stay thanks to TV's being the lowest common denominator. Though I'd happily look in to these 16:18 displays as long s they're affordable. More vertical pixels is what I miss most about 4:3.
- formerly_proven 5y agoI also use a 21" 1600x1200 with a Samsung PVA panel as a second display, the vertical height lines up nicely with a 27" widescreen. It's kinda fascinating to see how the PVA panel, which is like 20 year old tech, has no issues keeping up with a modern IPS display, and even has lower viewing angle shift, no backlight bleed, far better contrast and hence deeper blacks. The only teeny tiny problem is that it's visibly slow, even for a 60 Hz TFT.
- NathanielK 5y ago> The only teeny tiny problem is that it's visibly slow, even for a 60 Hz TFT. If it really bugs you, basically all scalers (brainbox for the LCD display signal) can handle 75-85Hz, since that was part of the VESA crt spec back then. Many of them will accept a higher frequency signal if you toodle around in your GPU settings a bit. Can't fix the slow response times, but it still helps a fair bit with making general work feel smoother and snappier.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wombatmobile 5y agoWhat is "vertical split view function that lets users see more in one glance."?
- iso1631 5y agoPoor bloke, having to work on January 1st. Is it 2018 or 2024 though?
- jmiserez 5y agoI wonder why they couldn't go just a bit wider to make it 2880x2880 (1:1 and the same number of pixels as 4K), instead of 2560x2880.
- firstcommentyo 5y agoActually I wonderd similar. However I guess the resolution comes straight from the marketing department since 16:18 is 16:9+9 which is, as already kinda mentioned in the article, 2x 16:9 screens stacked on top of each other.
- nicoburns 5y agoI imagine it comes straight from the technical department. I suspect this is literally two 16:9 panels stacked on top of each other.
- TremendousJudge 5y agoI figured the same
- Terretta 5y agoAnd worse, it’s 2 x 1440p panels, instead of 2 x 4K panels. This is a poke in the eye for “retina” users.
- RONROC 5y agoNo mention of refresh rates, per usual. I’d like to have a stern word with whatever marketing suit deemed refresh rates in excess of 60 to be a premium feature that only the gaming segment cares about. Even if this monitor is strictly for editing professionals, there are GoPros and Iphones that shoot @ 120 fps. So I still fail to see why this is not a more important selling point? A daily driver with a high refresh rate (120+) is like cocaine or calamari: once you’ve had the good stuff, reverting back to the “floor” starts to seem downright offensive.
- coldtea 5y ago>Even if this monitor is strictly for editing professionals, there are GoPros and Iphones that shoot @ 120 fps. So I still fail to see why this is not a more important selling point? Probably because people use these 120fps to deliver slow motion in regular 24fps/30fps/etc timelines, so they have no need to watch/edit them as 120fps...
- RONROC 5y agoWhy wouldn’t an editor want to view the final deliverable in 120fps, if that was an option? I understand there’s no need for it, but have you seen the size of the latest F-150? To quote Jack Nicholson playing Frank Costello in the Departed: “I haven't needed the money since I took Archie's milk money in the third grade. Tell you the truth, I don't need pussy any more either...but I like it.”
- formerly_proven 5y agoBecause increasing the display's frame rate makes zero difference on a S&H display for movie playback unless one of the combinations has jank: If you go from viewing 24 fps content on a 60 fps display it's janky, going to a 120 fps or 144 fps display fixes that jank because frames divide evenly. If you watch 30 fps content, it looks almost exactly the same on a 60 fps and a 120 fps display (but going to 144 fps would introduce jank).
- 5y ago
- svennek 5y agoNow, they just need to make really, really advanced research and in the future release the most advanced ratio: 20:15 And people would love it... For realz, I long after a taller monitor... It might just because I grew up with a 4:3 but I think that aspect ratio really hits the spot for work - for movies and stuff 16:9 is frankly better.. And I prefer 16:9 on laptops too due to the shallower base it allows..
- stevencorona 5y agoAll I want is a non-thunderbolt HiDPI display (5K @ 27" is the perfect display, IMO). Why has HiDPI has stagnated outside of the apple ecosystem?
- formerly_proven 5y ago5K @ 27" used to be a thing around five years ago but those monitors have largely died off.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoHow would you connect such a beast to your graphics card? If I understand, thunderbolt is the only connect standard with enough bandwidth, or maybe USB-C would work? Dell has a new 32” 8K monitor that connects via two display ports.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoHDMI 2.1? I've yet to see a computer which supports it though. Even the latest macbooks don't support it - which is one of their biggest downsides. Why include port that's outdated in the moment when you put it?
- thebean11 5y agoBecause vast majority of people using the port won’t be using a 5k screen, and those that do can afford a USBC to DP cable.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoUSB C is generally DP Alt mode. What doesn't generally work, is HDMI 2.1 to DP - see "Maximum Supported Resolution on Any MacBook via This Adapter is 4K@60Hz" https://www.amazon.com/Cable-Matters-48Gbps-Adapter-Supporting/dp/B08MSWMXT4 https://www.amazon.com/Cable-Matters-48Gbps-Adapter-Supporti...
- stevencorona 5y ago
- ciupicri 5y agoI'm still waiting for a matte OLED monitor.
- reacharavindh 5y ago138 PPI :-( I’d love this format if it was a hidpi display.
- smichel17 5y agoWhat counts as hidpi? I have 20/20 vision, and normally sit with my eyes approximately 3 feet away from my monitor (based on a rough measurement just now). My 27" 4K monitor has ~160 PPI, and I cannot discern individual pixels until my nose is around 1.25 feet away from the screen. My old 24" 1080p monitor has 92.5 PPI, and I remember being able to see individual pixels at the normal sitting distance. Subjectively, my 4k monitor is a big upgrade; you won't hear me arguing that PPI doesn't matter. Based on my ballpark measurements, though, 138 PPI seems like plenty, as long as your monitor isn't right up in your face.
- reacharavindh 5y agoI’m not sure of the scientific background. But, HiDPI displays on Macs have spoiled me with text rendering that is so sharp that I cannot bear to work with low(er) resolution displays anymore. I always attributed this “sharpness of text” trait to the high DPI that Apple displays tend to have. Hence my disappointment with the new LG monitor.
- smegsicle 5y agonote that macos eschews the subpixel rendering strategies other major vendors use to increase sharpness and legibility at reasonable DPI
- reacharavindh 5y agoThat is sad news. I have a Linux Desktop that emits not so sharp text on my 1440p monitor. I always attributed to that bad text rendering to the low DPI monitor. I was hoping that one day I could buy a hidpi monitor that would make my Linux desktop as friendly to my eyes as my MacBook Pro. Looks like not anytime soon :-(
- timbit42 5y agoI prefer 3:2 ratio. Apparently it's the closest to human field of view.
- petree 5y ago3:2 is very close to a 16:10.
- layer8 5y agoThe monitor has a PPI of about 140, FYI.
- cylinder714 5y agoIf you're desperate for a more-square monitor, Eizo has made a true square (1920x1920, equal to 2560x1440) monitor for some years now, the EV2730Q (https://www.eizo.com/products/flexscan/ev2730q/ https://www.eizo.com/products/flexscan/ev2730q/) I think its pixel density is around 140 pixels/inch, so the retina folks won't like it, but if you value real estate over sharpness, you can use all of the available pixels without scaling. (It'll even do 2048x2048, but the scaling makes everything a bit blurry.) Emacs is amazing. The EV2730Q runs $1429 in December 2021; if this new LG monitor can be had for that or less, it could be a big success. EDIT: Scratch that, square monitors will never be more than a niche, enthusiast product, so "big success" is wrong. But maybe, having LG behind it, it'll make more people aware of the choice. Now, for the counterpoint: Dell makes a 43-inch 4K monitor, the U4320Q (https://www.dell.com/en-us/work/shop/dell-ultrasharp-43-4k-usb-c-monitor-u4320q/apd/210-avke/monitors-monitor-accessories https://www.dell.com/en-us/work/shop/dell-ultrasharp-43-4k-u...). The prices vary over time, but for $959 as I write this, you get essentially two EV2730Q monitors mounted side-by-side. A better deal, but it's a huge monitor, way too big for my tiny setup. And I keep hearing complaints that a monitor that large requires more head movement to see everything. Edit: I have to say, I'm surprised that LG would venture into monitors like this. I had despaired that Eizo would be the only one willing to make a niche product like a square monitor, but I'm glad to see LG doing so, and making a higher-resolution one to boot.
- oxplot 5y agoGlad to brag that I am as productive on my 12” Thinkpad screen as I was on multi 27” monitors. I’ve 3D printed a foldable stand for my laptop to keep it at optimal height (got bad back) and distance from my eyes.
- jhanschoo 5y ago300 nits no thank you