5 ms·
If you think you can describe the physical world without any irrational numbers, when one of the most basic (the ratio of the area of a circle to its diameter)
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
If you think you can describe the physical world without any irrational numbers, when one of the most basic (the ratio of the area of a circle to its diameter) is irrational, I think you're probably mistaken.
- Koshkin 5y agoUnless we live in a computer simulation, of course, in which case we have to content ourselves with the IEEE floats.
- analog31 5y agoGod made the IEEE floats, and all the rest is the work of man -- Apologies to Kronecker
- btilly 5y agoYou can describe it to within measurement error without any irrational numbers. And with fewer decimal places than you'd probably imagine. See https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/edu/news/2016/3/16/how-many-decimals-of-pi-do-we-really-need/ https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/edu/news/2016/3/16/how-many-decimal... for more.
- midjji 5y agoThat often works, but not always, some systems generate sequences of operations which can be symbolically simplified, or equivalently could be exactly computed using reals, but which if computed using any finite precision will fail. A simple example would be solving for the position of a planet in orbit under simple Newtonian gravity, a sufficient number of revolutions latter. For any finite precision the number of orbits can always be increased until failure occurs. Its a cool how few bits of pi are required to compute the circumference of the earth to within an atoms width accuracy. But equally cool how bad it gets if you try the same to compute the position of earth 2^64 years later.
- btilly 5y agoThat logic is disingenuous at best. Planetary orbits are chaotic. Long before your imprecision in pi is going to significantly mislead you, shifts in mass due to, for example, earthquakes and weather patterns are going to cause orbits to be impossible to predict. There are theoretical systems where the exact value of pi matters. But no physical system is going to match that, and measurement error is going to quickly exceed calculation errors from pi.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoPi is only incidentally a number. Pi is an abstraction that represents a certain relationship. (Actually more of a set of relationships.) If you define pi as a specific constant with limited precision - because "that's all physical systems need" - you lose insights into the web of relationships around it. This is a bad thing and makes many kinds of math harder. It's the conceptual equivalent of lossy data compression. You don't want to do it unless you really, really need to. And if you do it, you need to be aware that you're now using approximations instead of abstractions, and those are not the same thing.
- wruza 5y agoBut when you remove or take these fluctuations into account, you’re still left with an error. This rational model has no chance to ever be correct computationally, unless you cheat and add more detailed ratio every time you see a loop. Also, how exactly will you define rational pi? Let’s start with 3/1, why go any further. If it doesn’t represent reality (draw a circle and measure it with a string), well, strings have vague length anyway. See where this is going? The bigger problem is analyzis will not work, probably. Can you do analyzis with rationals? E.g. f(x)=x^2 isn’t continuous at f(x)=2/1. I’d theorize that there is a way to do finite calc without giving up on “reals”, by using enough FT coefficients (and packing this complexity into sine waves), but it’s the same sort of cheating probably, unless pi is the “origin” number of all “physical” reals. (I’m not a physicist nor math guy, so one can reframe my ideas as questions instead.)
- midjji 5y ago
- MauranKilom 5y ago...but Planck length!
- EGreg 5y agoPerhaps that’s where quantum uncertainty reaches a threshold where you can’t make time based distinctions anymore.
- roywiggins 5y agoPi is the ratio of a mathematical circle to its diameter, but there are no physical circles which have that ratio as exactly Pi, and even if one existed, you'd never be able to distinguish it from one that was merely equal to Pi to the accuracy you are capable of measuring, because you'd need to measure with infinite precision, which you can't.
- kadoban 5y agoOrbits over long stretches of time seem likely to need arbitrarily high amounts of accuracy in pi. Sure you can just pick a rational number close enough for the accuracy you need, but why should the definition of pi need to change based on what you're measuring?
- roywiggins 5y agoEvery simulation picks some rational approximation to Pi, because they have to. Either they will run out of time or space or collapse into a black hole before needing more than a finite number of decimal places, so for all plausible purposes we can make do with the first googleplex digits (or whatever) of Pi. I guess my argument is, since you can always just pick a rational approximation to Pi, you cannot prove empirically that we live in a universe where more than a finite number of digits of Pi matter. That is, the mathematical irrationality doesn't really matter, physically speaking, since no experiment could ever prove that every digit in Pi actually contributes to the result. If the universe does have ways to do this, to mix an entire irrational number into a physical outcome, that means hypercomputation is probably possible, since Turing machines definitely can't. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_computation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_computation
- zozbot234 5y ago> Every simulation picks some rational approximation to Pi, because they have to. Your simulation might need to ask for an increasingly tighter bound on the real value of Pi. You can totally do this with no more than the usual rational numbers, but it's not equivalent to "just picking some rational approximation" and running with it, because what accuracy/precision you pick is outcome-dependent and it's always possible to request more.
- p2t2p 5y agoThat is replacing actual reality with math all over again. In the actual reality this ratio is concrete, limited value. I would say that our numbers and approaches are limited that they are unable to precisely define it. It just we are so used to it that no one even thinks about challenging it. And even if they do - good luck finding funding. Now we do have tools that overcome those limitations somewhat - like limits and stuff but doesn’t remove the need for better tools. So I somewhat disagree with both of you - we need new, better numbers that are further from math abstraction and closer to actual reality. Otherwise it is like this story with Poynting vector from Veritasium video - only confuses instead of explaining.
- drdec 5y agoExactly. The square root of 2 had no more basis in reality than the so-called imaginary number i. Don't confuse the "real" in real numbers with reality, at this point it is just a name.
- int_19h 5y agoIf the physical world is entirely quantized, including spacetime itself - which, as I understand, is still considered a valid hypothesis - then wouldn't it be possible to describe it using integers, pretty much by definition?