4 ms·
Ok I’m no Tesla fan. Wow. I don’t know how anything without night vision wouldn’t have hit that. It’s practically invisible. I think it was a huge mistake for
by MBCook 5y ago
Ok I’m no Tesla fan.
Wow. I don’t know how anything without night vision wouldn’t have hit that. It’s practically invisible.
I think it was a huge mistake for Tesla to remove radar from their vehicles but radar isn’t very good on stationary objects so not much help here.
This must have been terrifying to be there for.
- ironmagma 5y agoKeep in mind the human eye is very good at detecting low level lighting, better than a camera. Some studies say it can even detect a single photon. It was likely easier to see in person. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms12172 https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms12172
- hunterb123 5y agoSingle photon detecting eyes or not, most of us drive and know how hard that scenario would be to prevent. I doubt I would have seen it or reacted in time. There was a human in the Tesla that apparently didn't see it either. - edit - Sure... maybe a human could have "lessened the blow", maybe some humans, but now we're hindsight backseat driving and pulling things out of our ass. As a human there's a lot that goes into it, it depends on how long you were driving, your vision at the time, whether you were talking, your driving skills, your reaction time, your handling of accidents, knowing where you can swerve to. Some humans with full attention may have prevented it or weakened the crash, but that's a maybe, and assuming full attention. Many people in this thread who think they would have noticed the subtle lighting effects on a pitch black pickup in the middle of the road. I've nearly hit blacked out cars on the road, you don't see them. You could go back and probably see it in a dashcam, but you know it's there then. The uncompressed version you're still expecting a truck, it seems like it's much slower than what rounding a corner going 75mph on a freeway is, I don't think any of us could judge without being in the seat at the time. All in all, this is the most speculative thread I've ever seen on HN. Very reaching, but anti-Tesla is hot news here so... The big takeaway for me is how that Tesla just took that head-on collision at 75mph without compromising the cabin.
- KaiserPro 5y agoyou would have seen the light reflecting off the wreck when the truck drove past it. Because the light would be moving and in a place you wouldn't expect it, you would have been alerted. You might not have been able recognise it was a pickup, but you would have at least braked earlier.
- runarberg 5y agoDon’t be so sure. The lines on the road have a obvious break where the truck is. You might have noticed that and slowed down as a result, even slowed down enough to be able to notice the truck in time.
- ncallaway 5y agoYou may not have reacted in time to prevent a collision, but you very likely certainly would have stomped on the breaks before the impact. Changing a 75mph collision into a 35mph collision is a world of difference in terms of the total energy. I think it's important not to view "collision" as a binary event. With human drivers, it's pretty rare not to heal the squeal of breaks just before an impact. I suspect with automated driving (at least for a while) these kinds of "full speed" impacts will be more common than with human drivers.
- ironmagma 5y agoIt would have been difficult, but contrast is a lot different in real life. This video is pretty LDR, and the truck would have been visible at approximately 0:05, giving about 3 seconds warning, which is a lot when you are driving on a highway.
- vb6sp6 5y agoyou should view the uncompressed video. very easy to see
- w1nk 5y agoYou're misunderstanding what people are saying. You've watched a highly compressed video from a camera sensor that is known to have relatively poor dynamic range (ie: it doesn't see well in the dark when lights are around). The point OP was making (that you completely dismissed) was that our eyes are actually quite good at sensing this scenario. Here's a better version: https://twitter.com/haenschengross/status/1473326136755118085 https://twitter.com/haenschengross/status/147332613675511808... When you watch the uncompressed version, there are tons of visual cues to a human that there is an object in the way. This is no where near as subtle as the janky video makes it out. You can say you might have missed this at night but either you don't pay enough attention when you're driving, or you're giving tesla a pass here they don't deserve.
- runarberg 5y agoI think it is kind of unfair to apply your own intuition without any tests. Perhaps the average human will see there is something weird in front without being conscious of it (e.g. the lack of the white lines etc.) that is you would see it without seeing it. Or at least enough to slow down a little and be more cautious going forward. It is pretty hard to know this without doing tests.
- MBCook 5y agoYou’re right, that’s possible. But from that video this looks like the kind of thing an attentive driver could easily miss until it was too late. Maybe they’d start breaking but would they have stopped anywhere near in time? I doubt it.
- runarberg 5y agoWe don’t know unless we test it. But an attentive drive might at least increase their alertness when the stop seeing the headlights of the oncoming traffic, step off their gas pedal when the lane lines starts to disappear, and apply a significant amount of breaking when they finally notice the car, making the accident at least not as bad.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 5y ago> Wow. I don’t know how anything without night vision wouldn’t have hit that. It’s practically invisible. Radar and Lidar work in the dark. But yes, this is a problem with optical-only, especially since the camera-systems Tesla uses are pretty badly spec'd (1.2MP, not even 1080p) Tesla _used_ to have a RADAR system installed. But stopped installing them and rewrote the software to get rid of it earlier this year.
- jeffreygoesto 5y agoThat is actually a benefit for low light conditions. Less resolution = bigger pixels = better efficiency.
- dragontamer 5y agohttps://www.eetasia.com/teslas-hardware-retrofits-for-model-3/ https://www.eetasia.com/teslas-hardware-retrofits-for-model-... > ON Semi AR0136A with 3.75 um Pixel size at 1280×960 1.2Mp resolution This is a pretty crap camera / sensor. The ON Semi documentation suggests its a 1/3" sensor size: https://www.onsemi.com/products/sensors/image-sensors/ar0136at https://www.onsemi.com/products/sensors/image-sensors/ar0136... Your iPhone 13 has a 1/1.9" wide sensor, significantly larger... and multiples of them working as a team. Even if we go back to 2018: the Google Pixel 2 has a 1/2.6" sensor, still much larger (and with better resolution) than what this Tesla is using to see the road. ---------- If you want better night vision, then use a bigger sensor. Its just basic physics. A sensor with 2x the area will capture 2x the photons. Complaining that this car can't see the road at night... well.... yeah. Its got an tiny camera sensor. What did you expect? Its got bad night vision.
- jeffreygoesto 5y agoADAS must use qualified chips and that one was a pretty standard one some years ago. I like others better, but you must see them in system context and be able to continuously process that stream. Given the power budget and other constraints this was what a number of manufacturers ended up with. After all these guys are not dumb, they just need to desing in many more aspects than mobile phones.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y ago> It’s practically invisible. Have you ever tried to take a picture on your phone at night? Or even dusk? Things that are clearly visible render as 'practically invisible.' It's a safe bet that this video isn't a good representation of how visible the thing is, and it's guaranteed that the truck was more visible than it appears. The question of how much more visible probably isn't easy to answer other than "much more."