5 ms·
That's what mining is too, basically. It's just that a mining rig can "buy a lot more tickets".
by HPsquared 5y ago
That's what mining is too, basically. It's just that a mining rig can "buy a lot more tickets".
- theden 5y agoSolo mining yeah definitely, but with pool mining one can at least generate some fraction of a BTC.
- kosinus 5y agoMake me wonder, at what point does brute forcing private keys become more lucrative than mining?
- IronIvan 5y agohttps://odysee.com/@3Blue1Brown:b/how-secure-is-256-bit-security:f https://odysee.com/@3Blue1Brown:b/how-secure-is-256-bit-secu... or more briefly: never
- echelon 5y agoYou're assuming the crypto is flawless and forever hard, even with new computational paradigms. We've shown time and time again that our undefeatable algorithms aren't. Would you be comfortable if the Blockchain was frozen in time for a hundred years, after which you could withdrawal your balance? Would it be impervious over that time frame?
- temp0826 5y agoI mean...btc will eventually hit the supply limit. Sort of hilarious if all mining hardware was repurposed at that point to work on brute forcing instead
- tromp 5y agoTransaction fees will dominate the block subsidy long before that. Probably within the next 2 decades (in which the subsidy drops 32x).
- MereInterest 5y agoThe supply limit is irrelevant in this case. In order to remain secure, the cost to attack Bitcoin must be proportional to the value represented by Bitcoin. Currently, when proof of work is performed, it is funded in large part by increasing a ledger value without a corresponding decrease elsewhere (aka "minting"). In the future, when proof of work is performed, transaction fees will need to increase in order to provide a similar incentive. If the sum of the block reward and the transaction fees decreases, then that would result in fewer groups willing to perform proof of work calculations, and would be followed by a decrease in the proof of work difficulty in order to maintain ~1 block every ten minutes. That lowered difficulty then results in a lower cost to attack Bitcoin. So, there must always, always be profit in running proof of work calculations. Not only that, but to maintain the security of the ledger, any increase in Bitcoin valuation must result in a proportional increase in proof of work expenditure across the entire network. It's an absolute disaster of a system.
- Pennycade 5y agoWhat effect would this have on transaction fees, has this been modelled somewhere?
- patrickthebold 5y agoYes but, mining is set up to be easier/winnable because adding blocks is necessary. The opposite is true of finding private keys.
- aqme28 5y agoWell that's a different lottery system with much better odds than this. Technically miners could start mining by trying to guess private keys, but there's no reason to because the expected value is so so much worse.
- bhouston 5y agoHas someone done the expected cost to find a usable BTC address as well as the expected value of a BTC address? What is the ratio?
- garmaine 5y agoAstronomical. You could convert every computer into existence into hunting for used private keys, and run them for the lifetime of the universe, and you’d be unlikely to find even one used key.
- bhouston 5y agoWhat is the expected speed up if using quantum techniques? Can quantum techniques allow one to more effectively search for a specific private key to a BTC account?
- robbiep 5y agoWell, theoretically, instantly. But that’s kind of like asking what if I had this potion that instantly cured every disease known to man and then some, what would happen. What sort of quantum computer are you talking about? How many qubits?
- shawabawa3 5y agonot exactly true BTC addresses that have never sent BTC are not vulnerable to quantum computers as the public key is only sent when a transaction is made. The address you send to is a hash of the public key and irreversible even with quantum computers
- MarkPNeyer 5y agoThis isn’t true at all. Mining involves guessing a salt which, when added to data for a single block’s with of transactions, makes the hash have a certain sum of zeros. They are only the same in that they are using randomness to search for some number satisfying a given criteria. But, for example, you couldn’t use mining hardware to search for wallets with open balances. The mining hardware is specially optimized for one thing only.
- shawabawa3 5y agoIt's not at all what mining is Miners aren't brute forcing keys to existing wallets and stealing the bitcoin, as that's effectively impossible even for the biggest mining rig (like, a mining rig the size of the sun couldn't do it in a trillion years)
- nyadesu 5y agoI would say "it can solve very big sudokus way too fast"