6 ms·
No we're not. Division is being fostered by social media ("rage = engagement") and the news media through articles such as this. People lean center and are tir
by echelon 5y ago
No we're not.
Division is being fostered by social media ("rage = engagement") and the news media through articles such as this. People lean center and are tired of the fringes.
If both parties got rid of the extreme elements, everything would be boring again.
- 01acheru 5y ago> If both parties got rid of the extreme elements, everything would be boring again. I don’t agree neither disagree with the article, but that’s a big “if”.
- liuliu 5y ago> If both parties got rid of the extreme elements, everything would be boring again. This is the key isn't it? Do we observe anything happening on this end recently? What we observed in the last decades, is the opposite.
- kadoban 5y agoIt's not even the key, the premise is flawed. The Democrats are pretty much just trucking along like usual, while the Republicans are embracing the end of democracy itself.
- happytoexplain 5y agoWhile fundamentally true, I think this is an oversimplification. I don't think you need the majority of people to be "extreme elements" to have a low-grade civil war.
- sofixa 5y agoOne of those extremes literally tried to stage a coup d'état, and is in the process of doing its best to stack the deck for the next elections. Social media or not, their intentions, and the support they get, is pretty clear, and the two-party model makes opposition hard. It's entirely plausible that next time they get farther in their attempts, which triggers an agressive response from people against that.
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> literally tried to stage a coup They did indeed! However, the results were mostly just pathetic. The unfortunate thing is that the President himself tried to play along with it, and best chance for significant escalation would be if the President manages to be re-elected in three years' time — which is not the most likely outcome but is still actually distressingly credible — and does more to lay the groundwork during his term in office.
- kadoban 5y ago> However, the results were mostly just pathetic. It was closer to working than you'd think. It looks pathetic until it works. > The unfortunate thing is that the President himself tried to play along with it That's generous wording.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoI have doubts it was close to working! It was close to placing Congresspeople at risk of life and limb, and it was a little bit further from being a hostage situation. A standoff with the National Guard, or the military itself, following such a hostage-taking, would have been very unfortunate. But disrupting the continuity of government would take a good deal more than that. A real, non-sad coup attempt would have sent the military in there to support the crazies, or at the very least, a quasi-organized group of armed men who could set up some defensible position. Instead we saw mostly maniacs looting the speaker's podium. > That's generous wording. If you're assessing his intentions, yes, but while his act of "oh look I'm doing plausible deniability, I'm not organzing any coup" was weak, so was any organization he actually did. The risk is that next time people might learn from these mistakes. (The other risk is a counter-coup crackdown like Turkey, which cracks down on the opposition and purges them from both the public and private sphere, as enemies of the state. Our due-process is still a little too strong for that to work right now, fortunately, and any attempts to that end that may exist are pretty marginal.)
- kadoban 5y ago
- kadoban 5y agoOne party attempted a coup and no organizers have yet even been charged with any crimes. If you allow the basic system of government to be attacked without repercussion, that's not going to have a peaceful end. Social media and "the news media" may be part of our issues, but they're not the whole of them.
- all2 5y agoIf by "attempted a coup" you mean "walked calmly into an otherwise empty building after police let them in", then yes. The whole thing is a joke once you dig into it, all propaganda to try and make people scared of each other. We even had elected leadership lying about being on premises when it happened (Cortez). "United we stand, divided we fall", and the goal of most media rhetoric is to divide. Don't trust the "it was a coup" rhetoric. Dig in, take a look at the footage of what happened at the capitol. Don't take the media's word for it.
- ryan93 5y agoSome people in Jan 6 assaulted capital guard and chased people into private areas of Congress. But I don’t think they had any chance of overturning the election.
- kadoban 5y agoAll they needed to do, and what the plan was, was to disrupt the proceedings and get more time.
- ryan93 5y agoMore time for what? They left quickly and peacefully when asked. Wasn’t much of a plan. definitely not evidence of a strong desire to do what it takes.
- kadoban 5y agoTheir goal was to prevent the certification of the vote, and to pressure Pence to assist with that. They wanted to throw it back to the states, have them do more "review" or give different electors. If nobody can convincingly be said to have the required number of electoral votes, the US House decides, with each state getting one vote. > They left quickly and peacefully when asked Oh? Then what is anyone being charged with and convicted for exactly? They finally left vaguely once Trump asked, because he was forced into it, it hadn't worked, and public pressure had risen.
- klipklop 5y agoAgreed, most people are far more reasonable in person than social media would like us to believe/click on. I figure even 80% of the more "radical" people would be a lot more to center if they talked to real people instead of stuck in outrage loops designed to have them view as many ads as possible.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe fact that people perceive polarization and extremism will cause rise to polarization and extremism.
- chris11 5y agoDisagree, I think we are in an extremely dangerous situation. One party tried to stage a coup, and is still claiming the election was stolen. Just because the coupe failed doesn't mean we're safe. Polls show widespread distrust about American elections, and a significant portion of the Republican party believes Trump should be president. The coup was pathetic, but what would have happened if the riot had delayed the presidential election being certified? John Brown's raid on Harpers Ferry helped cause the American civil war two years later. He and most of his raiders were quickly caught and executed. But the trial turned Brown into a martyr in the north and motivated the South to form the Confederacy. I think Brown's raid was a moral action, and the Jan 6th coup was an attack on American democracy. I'm not very confident that the justice system will hold the planners accountable, or that it just did short term damage to our democracy. https://www.forbes.com/sites/andrewsolender/2021/09/15/poll-finds-most-americans-think-an-election-will-be-overturned-over-partisan-sour-grapes/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/andrewsolender/2021/09/15/poll-... https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/may/24/republicans-2020-election-poll-trump-biden https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/may/24/republicans-... https://www.axios.com/axios-ipsos-poll-republicans-lose-trust-elections-52410b23-9513-453b-8a37-d140cae2d455.html https://www.axios.com/axios-ipsos-poll-republicans-lose-trus...
- kenjackson 5y agoExtremes are more pervasive now than ever. It would be great if we could just avoid the war part and just split. As a progressive I feel like I have no need to ever go to a conservative state and I’m sure conservatives feel the same way. Let them define the laws they want.
- snarf21 5y agoI agree we aren't close to civil war but it isn't as simple as saying 'get rid of extreme elements'. All "media" is specifically designed to foster faux outrage to sell more ads. When is the last time a headline wasn't worded as click-bait. As long as outrage is extremely profitable for Hatebook, Fox News, CNN and Twitter, these "fringes" aren't going anywhere.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoThe belief that we're on the brink of civil war only makes things worse... "Once that idea takes hold, it has a force of its own. The demagogues warn that the other side is mobilizing. They are coming for us. Not only do we have to defend ourselves, but we have to deny them the advantage of making the first move. The logic of the preemptive strike sets in: Do it to them before they do it to you." [1] (in the context of the N Ireland troubles. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/01/america-civil-war-prophecies/620850/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/01/america...