13 ms·
Ubisoft's unprecedented “exodus” of developers
- martinpw 5y agoI think a significant amount may also be pull from FAANG companies which are now getting a lot more into 3d content creation. I don't have so much visibility on the games side, but at least in film and VFX I am seeing a lot of former colleagues at studios moving to those companies for much higher salaries and job stability.
- jscipione 5y agoThis explains why the year late Prince of Persia Sands of Time remake is probably not going to come out any time soon. :/
- cheeseomlit 5y agoI wonder if the Splinter Cell remake will fare any better...
- willis936 5y agoSC has a lot of goodwill from good memories and not having the blood wrung from it yet, so my bet is that it will sell well regardless of the quality. Also, we now have HDR OLEDs so when a guard shines a flashlight at the player we can experience this: https://youtu.be/Zp2EjsIYIhQ https://youtu.be/Zp2EjsIYIhQ
- pdimitar 5y ago> Ubisoft brass argues that, for all its tumult, the company's standing is comparable to its peers. Pointing out that everybody else has bad ethics too is not a compelling argument. That’s like saying “hey, we are as bad as the others”. Yeah well, okay, but try and improve?
- beamatronic 5y ago"Our TPS reports are the same length as everyone else's!"
- pm90 5y agoWhenever a company’s leadership tries to gaslight employees by trying to fudge numbers like this, it’s loudly saying that they’re not interested in finding out why employees are really leaving. To be clear, they aren’t necessarily lying, just presenting facts in a way that doesn’t address the problem. While attrition overall might be similar to other companies, if their most senior developers leave, they’re fucked. But they won’t talk about those numbers. Anyone still at Ubisoft: better start looking around. Statistically it’s just gonna get worse.
- sbarre 5y agoTo be fair, most large enterprises use 'industry-standard' metrics like these because it's all they have. "Pulse check" survey companies aggregate data across whole industries or verticals and then provide their customers with comparison numbers so they can get a sense, across their industry, on how they are doing, without revealing specific numbers for a given company. There are many factors - shit working conditions and bad pay being only some of them - that affect churn, and if you think the people in charge of this stuff, HR and people management, are smart enough to really parse those factors - let alone come up with their own useful metrics - you are giving them too much credit. It's not that they're not interested, it's that they have no idea how to figure it out. They would love to know, but have no idea where to even start. So they say "we're doing comparable to the rest of the industry" because that's all they know. They're not fudging anything, they literally have no other insights to give. This is of course not ok, but this is a very textbook case of "don't attribute to malice what can be attributed to incompetence".
- pdimitar 5y ago> It's not that they're not interested, it's that they have no idea how to figure it out. They would love to know, but have no idea where to even start. Maybe. I would think the human factor is also involved here, namely that it's hard to admit you're doing terrible (in this case: losing a lot of good talent) so people kind of get into an echo chamber where they and their club pat themselves on the back for how well they're doing "despite adversity". It's quite pathetic really but that's Homo Sapiens for ya. I've been guilty of the same in the past. To finally understand how wrong did you get various factors is honestly like traveling to another dimension. Most people can't and will not ever do it. > This is of course not ok, but this is a very textbook case of "don't attribute to malice what can be attributed to incompetence". 90% of the time I am inclined to agree but not sure about this case. There's a lot of money at stake in the gaming industry and I'd be inclined to think the higher-ups at least are quite aware of what they're doing. They simply surround themselves with deluded people that will allow them to coast on deflecting blame for as long as possible. And finally, I could just be paranoid and I am not claiming anything for a fact, it's just how I am viewing it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- AlexandrB 5y ago> Ubisoft brass argues that, for all its tumult, the company's standing is comparable to its peers. I think he's referring to Activision Blizzard.
- alpaca128 5y agoAnd being comparable to any of those big names isn't something I would brag about. It's more an insult than a sign of quality.
- izacus 5y agoThe numbers quoted look in line with the rest of the "Great Exodus" in the IT industry... Is there any special proof that there's something more going on than the post covid resignation spike (following record high retention 2020) we're seeing across the rest of the industry?
- siva7 5y agoIt’s a great exodus to greener pastures because developers are a pretty scarce resource in those wild times we’re living
- lampe3 5y agoSorry but what exodus in the it industry? Here in Germany if you can code "hello world". You will get a job. Also all of my peers and friends around Europe are still working in the industry. So I'm just wondering. Can you point to any source? Is this maybe something that happens in the US?
- yawaworht1978 5y agoI can do quite a bit beyond hello world, speak German and have right of residency. What are the salaries for such programmers? Do get in touch if it's really that simple, I am ready to roll. The job requirements on the job pages are all a bit ridiculous with the requirements, am genuinely curious, if you reply with an email I can contact you I would love to have a chat. Danke vorab.
- grumple 5y agoIt's also about about techies jumping jobs for more money, not just leaving the industry entirely. It is US-centric and not limited to tech. https://www.recruiter.com/i/no-post-pandemic-the-great-job-exodus-of-2021/ https://www.recruiter.com/i/no-post-pandemic-the-great-job-e... But I'd also say the common wisdom in US tech is to jump jobs every couple of years for a raise anyway, so losing 1/4 of engineers per year seems in line with expectations.
- lampe3 5y ago
- kiawe_fire 5y agoThe gaming sector has already been struggling with a (relative) lack of AAA content and incomplete releases with quality issues. I can’t help but wonder if we’re in for a rough couple of years in the market with all of the additional tumult. Granted much of the tumult is a direct result of the conditions that caused quality issues in the first place. I’ve often argued that AAA games are just too big, and gamer expectations too unreasonable to be sustainable. (Not that I mean to excuse poor management as a leading factor). Perhaps we’ll see an eventual changing of the guard and a reset to a more sustainable market, closer to what we had in the 90s?
- crate_barre 5y agoAs a gamer, I can say we are a fickle bunch. We’re no different that pop-song listeners at this point. We love it when it’s a hit, and we’ll play it out until we can’t stand it anymore and never look back. If you make an indie game or a big budget one, you are vulnerable to this fickle crowd. You are better off hyping the living hell out of a game and cashing in the initial few months than you are to build a modest game with a community that will stick around. It was never really like this, I’m not sure what happened. I really don’t know where it all went wrong. It’s a hits driven industry at this point.
- oneepic 5y agoI'm going to go ahead and guess platforms like social media/twitch/etc encourage us to keep looking at the next thing instead of looking at what we have. Meaning the previews look great but they dont translate into lasting experiences.
- gjhh244 5y agoYeah, I don't really get why some people buy all this hype and even preorder stuff. Maybe I'm getting old, but I just don't care anymore for most of the new stuff, no matter how fancy the looks. I downgraded my PC and only play indie / decade old AAA nowadays, with only few exceptions which are mostly niche strategy games.
- 5y ago
- munk-a 5y ago> One programmer told Axios they were able to triple their take-home pay by leaving. Tripling is pretty impressive - but as a developer who used to work in the game industry you'll definitely see a significant bump leaving - I personally saw a 50% bump and I'm still not in a particularly high earning tech sector.
- Bayart 5y agoI was about to say, some of it is due to the high demand for devs, but a lot of it is just down to the video games industry being incredibly exploitative.
- cecida 5y agoIt certainly showed in the hot buggy mess that was AC Valhalla.
- fileoffset 5y agoUbisoft are no better than Activision or EA. Absolute scum. They ruin every game they touch with their greed.
- tester756 5y agoI don't think it's unique to them "Here" (Eastern EU) almost all software people I know did change / are changing / strongly consider changing jobs various experience level, various industries, various salary expectations.
- darth_avocado 5y agoIt is embarrassing that developers [also designers and other creatives in gaming] are the core of any tech company, but very few companies actually value them accordingly. This is especially true in the gaming industry. Most companies start with great talent, but then more and more middle management comes in. Managers hire more managers so they can become senior managers. Non functional bloat starts coming in the form of sales, marketing, “strategy and ops” etc. Not saying they don’t add value, but they get hired and rewarded way more than the value they add and ultimately drown the company.
- rileymat2 5y agoHow are you measuring value added? A great product with no sales adds very little value.
- ecf 5y agoA great product sells itself.
- friedman23 5y agoThis is just not true.
- ethbr0 5y agoGiven extremes of "a great product sells itself" vs "well-marketed vaporware is successful," the former is more true.
- reificator 5y ago> > A great product sells itself. > This is just not true. Minecraft is the best selling game of all time[0] and while it's been marketed more since Microsoft purchased it, the first million sales happened within 7 months of charging for the game. Just over a year after commercial release it hit 10 million sales. This was not a period of Minecraft marketing. Most sales were due to people simply seeing others (friends, YouTubers) playing the game and wanting to try it themselves. [0]: Wikipedia claims 238 million sales, vs GTA V in second place with 155 million. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_video_games https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_video_gam...
- mdoms 5y agoThe triple-A gaming industry in general seems to be in a bit of a crisis. Quality of releases for the past couple of years has been abysmal, and creative direction seems to be now entirely in the hands of overpaid, unengaged executives who are totally disconnected from the gaming world. Games are routinely being released in a half-baked state. How could a developer with a real love for the medium be happy working at organisations like this? Ubisoft is one of the worst offenders (especially in terms of creative direction) so it's no surprise that they are the most affected.
- LegitShady 5y ago>The triple-A gaming industry in general seems to be in a bit of a crisis Aren't they making more money than ever before? Why is that a crisis? Imagine you're the most profitable you've ever been even with the quality issues - why is that a crisis at all? The purpose of the companies is to make money and they are. The games are just the widget they're selling. If people keep buying widgets, whether they're subscription widgets or microtransaction widgets, the business is working.
- mdoms 5y ago> Why is that a crisis? For the exact reasons I stated in the rest of my post? I didn't say "AAA companies aren't making money".
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoNeither management nor shareholders are in trouble, so people in charge don't care, so its not a crisis and nothing will be done.
- mdoms 5y agoThat's like saying there's no housing crisis because landlords and property developers are making tons of money.
- hylaride 5y agoThe video game industry as a whole has been a notoriously bad place to work for techs for a long time. It is extremely deadline driven, technical decisions are often made by product managers (or worse, other business people), and on top of that the pay is often mediocre compared to other industries. In the past, they've gotten away with it by enticing young people in (often because they loved video games growing up and want to make them) and burning them out. That seems to be a strategy that no longer works now that recruiters for all sorts of companies/industries have become so aggressive that you'll very quickly learn you're being taken advantage of if your linkedin profile is even moderately up to date and checked. These labour shortages (in all sorts of industries) are really going to be fascinating to watch. It's been 40 years since workers have had this kind of power/positioning and it'll be interesting to see if and how companies will adapt and change.
- jatone 5y agoagreed, I'm excited to see what happens. its taken those 40 years for globalization and women in the work force to be integrated and absorbed. we're just now seeing the labor markets plateau.
- hylaride 5y agoI think on top of all that, the two largest demographic groups, millennials and boomers, are no longer working together as the latter start to retire en mass (that's already been accelerated as many took early retirement during the pandemic). It will indeed be exciting to see what happens now...
- HideousKojima 5y ago>That seems to be a strategy that now longer works now that recruiters for all sorts of companies/industries have become so aggressive Companies are also becoming more and more willing to post salary ranges along with job postings these days as well, which makes jumping ship from game dev even easier. "I could make 30-50% more and only work 40 hours a week instead of 60-80, at the low cost of giving up games to write boring tax software instead? Sign me up"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lemoncookiechip 5y agoBetween the sexual misconduct scandal, the more recent NFT Quartz PR nightmare from both the outside and inside, as well as a general shake in the AAA industry due to similar sexual misconducts, allegations of racism and discrimination of minorities, physical abuse, toxic working environments, crunch culture above and beyond what is standard for other industries, mass layoffs after record profit years every year... It is no wonder that people are tired, or that we see more and more big names devs leave and form their own studio alongside with friends every other month. (An example being Activision-Blizzard who keeps bleeding big names and new studios keep forming). There's no apparent effort from the leadership of the industry to change all the above, as well as a continuous push by publisher for more monetization methods on top of pre-existing ones at the cost of the studio's PR (NFTs being the most recent). Combine this with a general lack of care for the quality of releases at launch or guaranteed long term support for the titles, which leads to animosity and lack of trust from consumers. There's also the fact, that all of this leads to developers and staff, being harassed on social media by people who don't and don't want to understand and simply want someone to blame. Also worth mentioning that there's a on-going pandemic for the past 2 years, that has left people both mentally and physically exhausted. So... that probably doesn't help at all when paired with the above. EDIT: Also worth adding, is the fact that CEOs are earning multi-million dollar bonuses on top of very large salaries (especially when compared to CEOs from other industries) when people are getting paid so poorly that they can't afford to eat (https://www.gamerzunite.com/activision-blizzard-underpays-employees-to-the-point-where-they-cant-afford-food https://www.gamerzunite.com/activision-blizzard-underpays-em...) or get layoff during a record profit year.
- mottosso 5y ago> An example being Activision-Blizzard who keeps bleeding big names and new studios keep forming If there's anything good coming out of all of this, it's this. We need less consolidation overall, and new studios emerging with this level of experience can only be a net-positive for the world.
- tyingq 5y agoSeems like it will probably have snowball effect. With this many leaving, the remainder have more work to do than before. And assuming the rumors about game dev are mostly true, the company will react by forcing long work hours and other unpleasant new policies, etc. Which will make more want to leave. Rinse, repeat.
- jabl 5y agoI haven't played anything by Ubisoft in a really really long time (nothing against Ubisoft per se), but I have to say based on reviews/walkthroughs [1] of Far Cry 6 on youtube that it must be a masterpiece. Not because it's any good, but because it unintentionally is so hilariously shitty. [1] see e.g. the ongoing walkthrough by Mighty Jingles
- exar0815 5y agoNever, in about a million years, I would have expected The Mighty Jingles referenced on Hacker News. My internet career now absolutely went full circle.
- jabl 5y agoHappy to oblige. ;)
- FooHentai 5y agoUbisoft have been on my personal veto list for years for a host of reasons. Dreadful launcher, bland padded-out content, lack of after-launch updates, key activation problems. The juice was consistently not worth the squeeze, so I just don't touch anything they're putting out nowadays.
- Shorel 5y agoReading all comments criticizing some modern AAA games: If you are into simracing, we are entering a new golden age. Particularly with Automobilista 2, the latest update is amazing, and the developers, called Reiza, are more of an indie studio instead of a big player. But the end result is nothing short of AAA quality. Other titles we enjoy are Automobilista 1, rFactor2, iRacing, and Asetto Corsa Competizione.
- aspaceman 5y agoIMHO, the results possible with modern open source tools are really amazing. I think a lot of the "cost" of AAA are inefficiencies in the pipeline, and issues of scope. A racing title seems especially easy to limit scope in. Compare your titles with the F1 games. There's no fancy campaign with voice acting and 3D modeled faces. But it plays really nice and the used assets are pristine. Indie no longer has to imply "2D pixel art". Speaking from experience, it's not that hard to teach some artist friends how to use blender. Then it's just a matter of compensating them fairly and you're off to the races. Plus it's fun. If you haven't tried 3D art, it's surprisingly intuitive. Like a sculpting with magic hands and clay that isn't annoying.
- TOMDM 5y ago> Ubisoft brass argues that, for all its tumult, the company's standing is comparable to its peers. The brass has realized they don't need to be good, just competitive.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoGood, I hope they learn a lesson. Anecdote: i know a fintech that fired their last per developer, while about 30% of their payment processing systems were written in perl. They tries to press a friend of mine into fizing it when it broke 'again', and he quit on the spot with 'someone has to take reaponsebility for the braindead decisions around here'.
- beebmam 5y agoWhen companies pay "market rates" for their developers, there should be no surprise that there's high turnover. They'll easily get a better deal going somewhere else simply due to the variance in those market rates. Here's one easy solution: pay the people at your company more so they don't want to leave for an offer that will certainly be less good than what they have with you. Good software engineers are hard to find. You should be paying them their weight in gold.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dschuetz 5y agoIt is really saying a lot when asked about workers complaining the top management starts shoveling numbers instead of facing the issues. This is how far removed management is from reality; it's all numbers and analytics to them, acting like robots.
- mabbo 5y agoIt's a great market for senior developers in Canada right now. A lot of companies are moving to full remote for a large portion of their developers. Especially important is that this includes some Bay Area big names. These companies are willing to pay well for talent and don't care where you live. Toronto, Vancouver, and Montreal have historically paid senior developers poorly compared to what the Bay offered. But we devs chose to be here instead because we like Canada, want to raise our families here. Sometimes because of US Visa issues, but not as common as you'd think. But now we are being offered the best of both worlds. Better pay than anyone previously offered; you can stay in Canada; you can even work from home every day and avoid commuting. And it's not like every developer leaving Ubisoft is going to Instacart (though I'll bet a few are). The market on senior developer labor is just suddenly more competitive. Every dev with more than 5 years experience is reevaluating their current total comp and listening to recruiters offering more. But don't worry, says Ubisoft, we replaced those very senior ICs with a bunch of new people. As long as developers-in is greater than developers-out, I'm sure it will all be fine.
- Thaxll 5y agoWorking for US compagny with not HQ in Canada can be a lot of problems. You have to pay for everything, insurance etc ... it's a lot of complications.
- kache_ 5y agoConsidering the fact that I made half a million dollars this year, I'm sure it was worth not having dental insurance
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SuoDuanDao 5y agoAs we never tire of pointing out, health insurance is less of an issue in Canada.
- nikon 5y ago
- hintymad 5y agoOh no! I really enjoy Assassin's Creed, and I wish the quality of the game will not deteriorate. Assassin's Creed is especially good for a layback gamer like me, who does not like time pressure and would like to take their own pace to finish the game. The fabulous view and handy tutorials and guides along the way helps too.
- Jerry2 5y agoOne of my best friends from college days ended up at Ubsioft Montreal and he spent around 8 years up there. He left last month due to changes in management. About 3 months ago they hired some new manager and this person had no clue about programming, or software development in general, yet she was in charge of the whole team. After a whole lot of infighting, my friend decided to leave after they refused him a change of a team. He ended up leaving for another AAA game publisher. At least 4 other members of his previous team also ended up leaving after him. I'm often reminded of the old adage: people don't leave companies, they leave managers.
- onion2k 5y agoThe optics of leaving half way through the development of a big project looks much worse than leaving after it's completed. Hiring managers question why people leave. I would be surprised if there wasn't a large number of people moving on in their career after working on and launching a big title like AC:Valhalla or FC6. That seems like the ideal time to find a new role at a higher level, using your latest credit to leverage a better package somewhere new, especially if you're a "top 25" person on the team.
- shp0ngle 5y agoBlizzard seems even worse. Poor Blizzard. Even a few years ago, with the Overwatch release, it still looked strong. With some stains but strong. Alas.
- biophysboy 5y agoI've seen bad press about game developers for quite a while, and I've increasingly seen that the explanation is corporate greed. But if its greed, why are game developers able to get significantly higher pay and quality of life by working elsewhere? Why are video game execs more greedy than any other software company? Is the tech/entertainment industry more scummy than the tech/business industry, at least among its leadership? I know nothing about this industry, but it seems like the margins for a game are extremely low. People balk at the $60+DLC prices, but you can get high quality games for $20 or less if you just pretend to live a year or so in the past. Is this not a confounding explanation for the shady stuff the game industry does, like lottery-style mechanics, repetitive franchises, and poor work-culture? Having said all this, developers should absolutely get more bargaining power at their studios. If this increases the price I ultimately see, so be it.
- jayd16 5y agoEmployers will pay what the market will support. People will accept lower pay (and even allow themselves to fall into a lot of bad working conditions) for making games because its actually pretty enjoyable a lot of the time. Not to mention the starry eyed kids that will accept just about anything to work in games.
- beeboop 5y agoI really want to break into the gaming industry doing game development even though it's a step down in pay and working conditions - I just applied because of this. Hopefully they're desperate enough to hire a mediocre developer like me :)
- throwawayubi 5y agoI was recently fired from Ubisoft, mainly because the human resources people were not familiar with the type of visa I had. This type of visa allowed me to work outside the country - it was not the regular working visa, but rather something very close to a permanent residentship. I had to use this option when a member of my family died and I had to return to my home country to take care of things and the rest of my family. This was agreed to and approved by my manager and I asked him to take care of personnel issues - he said sure and I left the country. At the same time, he got approval for my transfer to another studio in another country. A few weeks ago, I received a threatening message from a human resources person claiming that by leaving the country, I had put the studio in danger and so on. Turns out they had lost my visa information and decided to shift the responsibility to me. I tried to fix it, sent them everything they needed, but it didn't work. They decided to fire me because that was the easiest way they thought it would be. So they fired me. They gave four reasons for firing me in the termination letter. None of those reasons were stated in the policy or in my contract. As a cherry on top, the HR officer blamed me for what happened, ignoring the facts, ignoring previous email threads, ignoring my manager who told him that everything was actually handed over and everyone had been informed and coordinated. The HR person lied to upper management (both HR and IT) and presented me as if I had left the country without informing anyone. As a result, I lost the opportunity to be transferred to another studio. Remarkably, no one in IT or HR management (except for my direct manager) spoke to me during the process to hear my side of the story. They ignored my manager as well. Another fun fact - when I came to the company, it took them 1.5 months to make sure I could actually work on this visa - it took me 10 minutes to call the ministry and get verbal confirmation, and another 2 minutes to find the relevant information on the government website. It was definitely a red flag, but I unfortunately ignored it. F*k them. It was one of the worst experiences in my carreer. The way it was communicated, the fact that noone even tried to listen to me, it was just so humiliating. Had they communicated it properly, I would have quit myself and waited for the transfer. Instead, they presented me as an enemy and kicked me out of the company.