12 ms·
There’s no such thing as a tree (phylogenetically)
- worik 5y agoA fern is not a tree. Hmm... What about a Tree Fern?
- worik 5y ago> “woody plants”, like lianas (thick woody vines) There are plants that start out as parasitic vines (parasitic? Epithetic? I am not sure what words to use...) that grow, as a vine, up a tree. Kill the tree, then stand as a tree from then on. https://live.staticflickr.com/5066/5645437671_f04c556157_b.jpg https://live.staticflickr.com/5066/5645437671_f04c556157_b.j...
- thaumasiotes 5y agoStrangler figs are like that, except I believe they grow down the tree, not up. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strangler_fig https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strangler_fig It's hard to grow up a tree because the tree blocks the sunlight.
- tomrod 5y agoI've seen Poison Ivy do this, at Cleburne State Park (TX), Cedar Lake. Nestled among a beautiful bunch of cedar trees is a nice spot for a picnic. You notice that one tree stands out with broad leaves, but it doesn't look like an oak. You then notice the very distinct cedar bark. It was wild.
- hinkley 5y agoEpiphytic. They are freeloaders instead of parasites. Although there is some though that for instance moss high up in some very tall trees helps them overcome their hydraulic limitations by allowing them to absorb some water from their limbs instead of just the roots.
- lproven 5y agoAn epiphyte is a plant that grows entirely on another plant – in other words, has no roots in the ground. Vines and creepers are not epiphytes, because they have conventional roots in the same soil as the larger plant (or other structure) that they cling to. I can't parse your 2nd sentence so I can't comment, but moss is not vascular and does not have roots or any mechanism to transport water internally. It just moves through the plant by capillary action. This is the key difference between mosses and clubmosses.
- hinkley 5y agoTypo. Too late to edit now. Studies of temperate rain forests suggest strongly that water storage of mosses in particular allows the tree to absorb moisture directly through the bark, or in some cases form adventitious root hairs into the moss. One of the main limits to tree height is how high they can pump water through a combination of pressure and capillary action. Sequoioideae in particular have adaptations that let them push water a little higher than other trees. IIRC some of those are common to Cupressaceae (thuja plicata being the apex tree in the PNW). We have conservationists here that have lamented the industry that has formed around harvesting moss from temperate rainforest trees. Some of these are sneaking into public lands and mass harvesting. The growth rate of these mosses barely keeps up with the rate of growth of the trees. A fully denuded tree may be dead before it's covered in mosses again.
- lproven 5y agoFascinating. Thanks for that!
- sb057 5y agoThis is why I don't respect rationalism as a philosophy.
- worik 5y agoThe problem is that what we do not know about genetics matters much more than what we do know.
- dgudkov 5y agoI'm not a botanist, but I understood that trees and herbs are genetically close when I visited Madeira and saw the Dandelion tree [1] - a tree which leaves and flowers are regular dandelions. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonchus_fruticosus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonchus_fruticosus PS. Ok, it's technically a shrub.
- mcphage 5y agoWhen you think about it, it would actually be crazier if our common words matched exactly with biological evolution.
- InfiniteRand 5y agoThis is one of the cool things about math, there are a lot of aspects of math which stem from thinking, "well what if I took a square root of negative one?" or "what if geometry worked this way?" and then someone does the thought exercise and fleshes it out into something interesting. And then there just happen to be aspects of reality that end up being very nicely described by these what if questions
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> there are a lot of aspects of math which stem from thinking, "well what if I took a square root of negative one?" I don't think that's what imaginary numbers stem from. If I recall, they came from the much more specific question of "what if I apply the formula for roots of a cubic polynomial, even when that formula produces some nonsensical intermediate values that end up canceling each other out?". It's less about "what if we do this?" and more about "we have this method, and it seems to work even in cases where it's not obvious that it should work".
- emj 5y agoThat is the reverse of this subject in botany, we have this method that we know works and is logical lets make our language more logical. The problem with that is the same reason we don't use imaginary numbers everywhere we can use them. Veritasium has a video description [1] with links to references about the history of imaginary numbers and polynomials. There are some great writing on this and understanding not the history but the problems that gave rise to imaginary numbers, this connection to taxonomy makes me want to read them again. There must be a study of this; failed attempts of taxonomy. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUzklzVXJwo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUzklzVXJwo
- betterunix2 5y ago
- gumby 5y agoPerhaps not, yet I have never seen anything so lovely.
- kspacewalk2 5y agoTrees sure are a beautiful strategy.
- jakear 5y agoI’ve become increasingly interested in what I think would be called “computational botany” if it were to be fleshed out. In looking at this and articles like it, and speaking with both trained and amateur botanists, a common thread is that the appearance of a plant has become increasingly detached from its scientific classification. A frequent refrain in nature hikes I’ve been a part of goes along the lines of: “this plant used to be family X, but then dna testing showed it was actually family Z” - “what? You’re kidding, that’s family Z? It has all the characteristics of an X!” - “Yep, Z. I don’t much understand it myself but apparently that’s what the dna says.” I think this is a bit silly. It’s akin to categorizing programs by the libraries they use or the programming language they’re written in rather than the problems they solve. What’s more useful to the layperson: “VSCode, IntelliJ, and Vim are Text Editor family; Slack, Talk2Me, and mIrc are Chat family” or “VSCode and Slack are Electron family; IntelliJ and Talk2Me are Java family; and Vim and mIrc are C family”? The idea with my proposed “Computational Botany” is that the only information used to classify a plant is that same information that would be used to generate a computer model of the plant. So if a specimen has all the markers of an X appearance wise, such that implementing its clone would take the least changes when starting from an existing X, it’s an X. Of course, the actual implementation of these models may end up requiring an unattainable God-level intelligence, but I leave that as an exercise to future me (or you!)
- samus 5y agoThe phylogenetic tree of life is organized not on the characteristics, but on the evolutionary origin of species. Species are in a specific branch of that tree if they share a common ancestor species with the whole branch. Shared characteristica were a good proxy for ancestry back when the mechanism behind inheritance of genes was not discovered yet. Of course, the concept of a species is a bit fuzzy (even the possibility of genetic compatibility for reproduction as a criteria has issues), but over long timescales the relationships should align into a tree. A big underlying assumption of this is that genetic material is only passed from progenitors to offspring. Specifically, horizontal gene transfer (common for bacteria, viruses and possibly others, but believed to be very rare for multicelled organisms) throws a huge spanner into efforts to derive phylogenetic trees. It can still be useful though under the assumption that not all genes are eligible for being transferred horizontally. Also organizing programming languages into a phylogenetic tree is doomed to failure because in general it's quite easy to transfer features from one language to another, and back, as languages are not picky about incorporating features from offspring languages.
- tooltower 5y agoThis just means that our notion of a tree does not map cleanly to a genetic lineage. That does not mean the concept is useless, even in scientific fields.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- samus 5y agoI don't get the premise of the article. A tree is just a growth shape of a plant (plants are quite flexible regarding growth shapes, and often adapt to the environment), and a category that our minds place a plant species into. And its clearly an ancient ability common to all vascular plants to develop woody tissues. So why would we expect the tendency of a plant to become a tree to depend on its position in the phylogenetic tree? (the authors had me there for a moment. I thought they wanted to show that the phylogenetic tree is not really a tree!)
- bejelentkezni 5y agoI was under the impression that what made a tree was its woodenness so I was probably more of the target audience, and was impressed by the article.
- da39a3ee 5y agoYou’re right that is what makes a tree. But don’t you feel that it’s obvious that different lineages of plants could acquire, and lose, woodenness independently of each other? And therefore 100% unsurprising that “tree” is not a monophyletic group.
- asimpletune 5y agoAfter reading this article yes, but obvious? No at all.
- williamdclt 5y agoDefinitely not obvious. I have no idea how complex "woodiness" is, evolutionarily. It's like if you asked me "don’t you feel that it’s obvious that different lineages of animals could acquire, and lose, feathers independently of each other": probability is certainly non-zero but is it negligible or is it actually likely? No idea, I'm not an evolutionary biologist, and would read an article about it with interest
- yxhuvud 5y agoIt is obvious that it can happen, but it is not obvious how common it seems to be.
- yesenadam 5y agoWell, I thought this was a fascinating and well-written article. p.s. I learnt not long ago that there's no such 'thing' as an antelope: "The term antelope is used to refer to many species of even-toed ruminant that are indigenous to various regions in Africa and Eurasia. Antelope comprise a wastebasket taxon (miscellaneous group) within the family Bovidae, encompassing all Old World ruminants that are not bovines, caprines, deer, or giraffes." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antelope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antelope
- Areibman 5y agoThe term for these sorts of categories is called "Wastebin Taxon"
- yesenadam 5y agoThat's pretty much a worse than pointless comment, isn't it, without some reason/justification supporting it. The wiki page for the term in question begins "Wastebasket taxon (also called a wastebin taxon, dustbin taxon or catch-all taxon)", so it does seem there's no one correct term.
- t786342723 5y agoThe posh word is "polyphyletic"
- DarylZero 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wastebasket_taxon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wastebasket_taxon
- Rebelgecko 5y agoWhat's the difference between a ruminant and an ungulate?
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoGrass eating Vs hooves.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- worik 5y ago> Imagine if actually there were amphibian birds and mammal birds and insect birds flying all around Bats (mammal) Mosquitoes (amphibian) Any number of flying insects. My least favourite is a two inch long flying cockroach that I encountered on a visit to Tāmaki Makaurau
- yesenadam 5y agoThe paragraph continues > ...and they all looked pretty much the same – feathers, beaks, little claw feet, the lot. You had to be a real bird expert to be able to tell an insect bird from a mammal bird
- ajuc 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hummingbird_hawk-moth#/media/File:Macroglossum_stellatarum01(js).jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hummingbird_hawk-moth#/media/F... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hummingbird_hawk-moth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hummingbird_hawk-moth I've seen this insect in person and I was persuaded it was a hummingbird that somehow got to Poland. It's huge for an insect, feeds of flowers hovering in place just like a hummingbird does, nothing like an usual flying insect. It has texture that look like feathers and when it feeds it often looks like he has a long straight beak. Only on photos or very up-close you can recognize some things don't match. We argued for a few hours what it was until we found it's actually an insect.
- divbzero 5y agoMosquitoes are insects too. The closest to a flying amphibian might be a flying frog [1]? [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flying_frog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flying_frog
- causi 5y ago"Tree is not a distinct clade" is the version of the title that isn't clickbait horseshit.
- inglor_cz 5y agoHow many people know what clade means, though? I had a pretty rigorous and extensive course of biology in high school, we spent a lot of time poring over various details, but the word clade never even fell. (Granted, that was 1992-1996, so things might have changed.) I only met the expression cladistics and clade much later in some popsci literature.
- causi 5y agoMost HN readers I'd wager. Regardless, "Trees are not a distinct evolutionary group" or "Trees are not all related to each other" or any number of other accurate or semi-accurate headlines are better than "There's no such thing as a tree".
- camtarn 5y agoI would happily wager against you. I made a similar comment further up the page: I think some people massively overestimate the amount of general knowledge people have about biology. Like the article says, a lot of people are still at the 'did you know a tomato is a fruit??!' stage.
- dsr_ 5y agoI think the first time I encountered /clade/ was in Bruce Sterling's Shaper/Mechanist stories. "Cicada Queen" was written in 1983, but I expect that I thought he made the word up for several more years.
- hsn915 5y agoDon't scientists use phenotypical similarity to deduce ancestry when it comes to fossil remains? If phenotypical similarit is so unreliable, what are the implications?
- metanomicon 5y agoShape seems to be a very superficial trait. One need only consider an elephant's trunk. In terms of shape and size, it has more in common with my leg, but ask anyone, "What is an elephant's trunk?" and they will immediately tell you "A nose!" When it comes to examining various lifeforms and fossil remains to determine ancestory, it seems to be more a matter of homology - the relationships between parts. Whether it's the same part over long periods of time (ex. comparing differences in the thumb) or different parts within the same individual (ex. comparing the big toe and thumb) or interspecies similarities (ex. the similarities of hands, feet, paws and flippers), evolution is a story of relationships, not size or shape. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2097084 https://www.jstor.org/stable/2097084 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homology_(biology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homology_(biology)
- harrisi 5y agoI typed out a lot about how I've never compared my nose or leg to an elephant's trunk, but it seemed beside the point. The general idea was it's interesting to think of how we identify things, and this comment reminded me of Is The Man Who Is Tall Happy?[0][1] and the idea of psychic continuity. [0]: https://youtu.be/cv66xFD7s7g https://youtu.be/cv66xFD7s7g [1]: side note: this documentary was pretty influential to my interest in compilers (specifically lexing and parsing), and is an interesting watch.
- k_sze 5y agoCan we say the same about moths? I’m an avid participant on iNaturalist. I record lots of moth sightings because there really are many beautiful moths in Hong Kong. There’s a “Hong Kong Moths” project on iNaturalist, but adding observations to that project can be very frustrating because the observation must be in one of the defined (sub)families. But to an amateur like me, a moth is a moth is a moth. Sometimes even the machine identification is way off and I know it’s a moth because of the general body features. And I wouldn’t want to put it in a random (sub)family just to get the observation included in the project. I’d have to @mention some moth expert (e.g. @hkmoths, Dr. Roger Kendrick) to help me ID the observation first.
- ckastner 5y agoThis reminded me of the fascinating obversation of convergent evolution, the "independent evolution of similar features in species of different periods or epochs in time" [1]. For example, the concept of flight has evolved independently numerous of times (insects, birds, pterosaurs, and bats), so it would not be unreasonable to assume that it would evolve again, were life to start over from scratch. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergent_evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergent_evolution
- svara 5y agoPrevious discussion from half a year ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27094382 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27094382
- 2-718-281-828 5y agoThis is also a thing with mushrooms. The Common Earthball [1] f.x. is more related to a Porcino [2] than to a Meadow Puffball [3] which itself is related to the Field Mushroom [4]. Seems like genes are more like a toolbox where evolution takes from what it needs. After all we share a significant amount of common genes with totally different animals like flies. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scleroderma_citrinum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scleroderma_citrinum 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boletus_edulis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boletus_edulis 3: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lycoperdon_pratense https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lycoperdon_pratense 4: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agaricus_campestris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agaricus_campestris
- ajuc 5y agoInteresting. I couldn't understand for a moment why this should be surprising. Then I remembered English has 2 words for "grzyby" - fungi and mushrooms. Is that it?
- 2-718-281-828 5y agono - a mushroom is a large fruiting body of a fungi. if you want to know what I mean look at the pictures.
- lproven 5y agoNo. I would guess you are thinking of "toadstool" versus "mushroom". Fungi is a technical term for a type of organism, not the fruiting body.
- 2-718-281-828 5y agotoadstool is colloquial for poisonous mushroom.
- lproven 5y agoI know. But while all toadstools are mushrooms, not all mushrooms are toadstools...
- VeninVidiaVicii 5y agoI thought the premise was that “phylogenetic trees” don’t exist. Interesting phraseology.
- croisillon 5y agoI'm surprised he describes the pineapple as a tree?
- thomasahle 5y agoHe even calls them "definitely a tree". Too me the look more like grass...
- jeroen 5y agoSame for the banana. I would put those under "definitely not a tree".
- croisillon 5y agoRight, banana is more ambiguous to me. Since they can grow a few meters high I would call them a tree.
- rusanu 5y ago> Why don’t more plants evolve towards the “grass” strategy? Grasses have a trick: Grass blades grow at the base of the blade and not from elongated stem tips. This low growth point evolved in response to grazing animals and allows grasses to be grazed or mown regularly without severe damage to the plant. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poaceae#Description https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poaceae#Description
- rob74 5y agoFascinating article, but I think it could benefit from some more examples. Since it mentions "a tree evolving into a dandelion (or vice-versa)" and then a paper about wood evolving independently at least 38 times in the Canary Islands, the perfect example is Sonchus Canariensis (https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=2834 https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?p..., better picture: https://garden.org/pics/2014-03-30/Kelli/5ef4db.jpg https://garden.org/pics/2014-03-30/Kelli/5ef4db.jpg). I saw this plant during a hike on Tenerife a few years ago and found it so fascinating that it has stuck in my mind ever since. It's basically a colony of dandelions (ok, they're a bit larger, but still clearly dandelion-like) growing on long woody stalks. Not quite a tree yet, but definitely a shrub. I guess its peculiarity of only having leaves at the tip of its "branches" limits its growth, because the water circulation in a "tree" is made possible by the negative pressure produced by water evaporation on the leaves, so a "branch" can only get so long with leaves only at its tip? And, since it later also mentions theoretical "insect birds"... well, there are some insects who are regularly mistaken for hummingbirds: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hummingbird_hawk-moth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hummingbird_hawk-moth. In photos you can quite clearly see that it's an insect, but if you see it in real life it hovers around flowers just like a miniature hummingbird, and it's a bit large and bulky for a flying insect, so the confusion is understandable. BTW this is also an example of convergent evolution, and it's interesting that these moths don't exist on the American continent, where the actual hummingbirds have occupied this ecological niche.
- derbOac 5y agoI wasn't really surprised by the claim of the article but also hadnt thought about it explicitly much. Bunchberries, for example, are really common where I am, and they're a type of dogwood (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornus_canadensis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornus_canadensis). It's really obvious they're a dogwood too, once you get past the fact they're not woody. Also, "tree" can get really fuzzy really fast with different shrubs in between.
- jmuhlich 5y agoThat species of moth doesn’t exist on the American continent but other similar and related ones do, whose range does overlap with that of hummingbirds. For example: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hemaris_thysbe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hemaris_thysbe
- asimpletune 5y agoThis is why relying on inheritance for OOP should be kept to a minimum... because even in real life, there's no such thing as as tree.
- verisimi 5y agoThe world is whatever it is. The classification we overlay on what we perceive might (or might not) relate to physical reality. One is objectively real, one is theoretical. We can have all sorts of theories about how things have come to be, but again these might (or might not) relate to reality. We do not and cannot achieve a theory of everything, even if we kid ourselves that we can be papering over the cracks. Physical reality just isn't that sort of thing that we can know as well as all that. And this doesn't even mention how our data perception in only on a narrow range. Nor the fact that our theories drive the observations, rather than observations driving the theories. We can certainly hack bits, and get them to do things, understand nature's tricks and re-implement them in a different context. But really understanding it? Not so much. PS very interesting that the author mentions 'neoteny'. This is where a 'species' stays in a prolonged juvenile state. I've long thought that this sounds like modern life, where people do not want to take personal responsibility for their lives, but instead look to various authorities (government, corporations, their mum) to do it for them.
- bradrn 5y agoThis is one of my favourite articles! But as someone who has recently become interested in botany, what I find really crazy about this is that there are so many different ways for plants to become trees. A listing (surely incomplete): • Normal trees, like what you see every day, with bark and wood and so on • Monocots like yucca and aloe and Draecena, which have no bark and become woody through ‘abnormal secondary growth’ (which I don’t properly understand but has something to do with wood development being scattered throughout the plant instead of in a ring around the edge), and tend to avoid branching except when the growing tip is disturbed • Other monocots like palm trees and Strelitzias, where the ‘wood’ is actually the bases of dead leaves wrapped very very tightly together, firmly enough to keep the plant standing up • Fern trees, which… I’m not at all sure about, but seem to work on the same principle where leaf bases sorta get fused together. But the Dicksonia in my front yard seems to extrude some sort of thin fiber — does that perhaps help to hold the trunk together in some way? • And then there’s things like papaya and banana and giant horsetails, which become trees without any wood at all, and have presumably innovated other ways of holding themselves up It’s interesting to walk around my neighbourhood and realise that many of the trees I see have evolved almost completely different methods to get to the same result!
- jvanderbot 5y agoI bet this is crazy common, where vastly different species have similar characteristics. What animal characteristics exhibit convergent evolution? * Wings in bats / birds, for one. * Tails and fins in swimming mammals vs fish. * Eyes? Cephalopods?
- brnt 5y agoWhen I started my studies, we had a tour of the hortus of our university. A retired taxonomist gave us the tour, and was lamenting how genetic research had changed quite a bit of the taxonomy of his gardens, and that the old art of careful observation and encyclopedic knowledge of the appearance of plants was lost on his successors.
- gwbas1c 5y agoIn many parts of the US, there's poison ivy, a noxious weed that can cause severe itching, rashes, ect on contact with skin. It's common where I live, so I've become very good at identifying it. Sometimes it's just groundcover. Sometimes it's a shrub. Sometimes it's a vine. It's surprising how its stem can take many different forms.
- bobthechef 5y ago
- btilly 5y agoFollowing a link in that article lead me to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welwitschia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welwitschia, where I found what will be probably be the best sentence that I've read today: Plants in Angola are better protected than those in Namibia, because of the relatively high concentration of land mines in Angola, which keep collectors away.
- zellyn 5y agoAnyone know where bamboo(s?) would fit on this chart?