5 ms·
While you're correct, I think there is something to be said about the popularization of the technology. Most people aren't aware of GPS trackers other than movi
by godelski 5y ago
While you're correct, I think there is something to be said about the popularization of the technology. Most people aren't aware of GPS trackers other than movies and think they are much harder to come by. AirTags are also less nefarious by nature. If you get caught with a GPS tracker on your person that's pretty suspicious. If you're caught placing an AirTag on someone's car it's easier to pretend you dropped it and are looking for it. I'd also say that the popularization increases the chance of use in the moment. You already have the AirTag and can decide do that tracking. With the GPS you have to do forward planning. I do think there's a difference here that could lead to more people being tracked. Crimes of opportunity are different than planned crimes, and I assume much more common.
It is good that Apple is notifying users when being followed. But it seems that too many false positives are getting people to ignore the messages. Though this is a hard thing to combat.
- yawaramin 5y ago> If you're caught placing an AirTag on someone's car it's easier to pretend you dropped it and are looking for it. That doesn't make any sense. If someone catches me placing an AirTag in the undercarriage of a car, it's pretty difficult to pretend that I dropped it there.
- godelski 5y agoDepends how you were caught. On your back reaching up? No. On your knees? Yeah. Consider that this tag was placed in the wheel well, which doesn't require getting on your back and would only take a few seconds. It isn't like someone is there for a significant period of time. Especially since you can then produce said AirTag after inquiry and people will generally believe the claim even if suspicious. All you have to do is create _reasonable_ doubt. That's different than _certain_ doubt. This is because weird stuff like that is much more common than nefarious acts (though we remember nefarious acts more easily). I think you are likely overly estimating yours and the average person's awareness. Scam artists and magicians exploit these kinds of effects frequently and with an extremely high success rate.
- educaysean 5y agoYour argument isn't very convincing. AirTags are one of the few location tracker that the public can recognize by sight and identify its use. This makes AirTags much less effective for use by malicious actors than other generic black-plastic case electronics.
- ineedasername 5y agoIt's only less effective if it's somewhere that can be seen. I think most people don't check the insides of their wheel wells more than, well, at all. In which case the device could be neon green and it wouldn't matter for the purposes of visual detection.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoMy friend just had someone jack up his car and hack off a catalytic converter with a hacksaw in broad daylight, to steal it. How long does it take to place an airtag, 3 seconds? I think the chances of you being caught placing an airtag are slim to none.
- filoleg 5y agoA bit of an off-tangent: does your friend live in Seattle? Because catalytic converter and bike theft in broad daylight have become a staple here, but it is definitely not the norm in other cities. So I wouldn't judge how easy it is to do something like that in general, based on a city where the prosecution is notorious for letting all kinds of criminals get released the morning after, which leads to the police not bothering with "minor" crimes like this (i.e., what's the point, if they will just get released the morning after and you waste both your time and the department time).
- ClumsyPilot 5y agonah, it's a town in UK I can't make sense of what's going on with prosecutions there, sometimes I hear about people getting away with major crimes, other times some poor sod gets charged for possessing 'material useful to terrorists', The Anarchist Cookbook, which you can buy on Amazon. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-northamptonshire-58926030 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-northamptonshire-5892603...
- johnnymonster 5y agoSecurity by obscurity is not security at all. Thinking you were safe because “people didn’t know about it” is not safety at all! Bad people are going to be bad. They don’t need AirTags for that. Knowing it can happen is far better for everyone to know about than living in a false sense of security.
- chrismcb 5y agoSecurity by obscurity is actually pretty good security. Obviously but fool proof, but pretty good. Of course it depends on how good your obscurity is. Plain text passwords are not very obscure. And thus is mainly where the phrase comes from.
- rsj_hn 5y agoAs someone who has been in this field professionally for almost 20 years, my thoughts on this have changed quite a bit. The idea of condemning security through obscurity traces back to cryptography, not security in general. In cryptography, you want the security of your protocol to not depend on the protocol being secret, but the cryptographic keys themselves being secret. There are a lot of good reasons for this, the main one being that the whole point of cryptography is to create protocols that can survive public scrutiny and thus are more easy to implement and more robust. So for example, without cryptography you'd need to secretly pass a message by courier who might take a secret route, constantly changing his route and delivery time. With cryptography, you can encrypt and sign the message, and then broadcast it over an insecure channel. The second option is much easier than the first. So the whole enterprise of cryptography is based on the principle of abandoning the confidentiality of the protocols themselves. But there are many situations that require security which are outside of cryptography, because the security of the overall system cannot be reduced to high entropy secrets, and in that case, there is some security benefit that is obtained from obscurity. For example, we are concerned about username enumeration because we understand users choose weak passwords that might be found in databases, so we do not publish usernames and consider it a vulnerability when usernames are leaked. As another example, we consider information disclosure consisting of stacktraces leaked to the user to be a vulnerability. Similarly, there are data centers that cannot just get up and move, and so locations and protocols of these installations are also kept secret. So while it's true that things which are hard to change should not rely on secrecy in order to maintain their security level, and we should constantly be improving and hardening our protocols so that they can resist public scrutiny, nevertheless it's not the case that all protocols have been or are able to be improved so that their security properties are reducible to high entropy bit strings - in fact most systems don't fall into this category and most will never fall into this category - and for these systems, part of the security will continue to rely on obscurity, even though we are painfully aware of the drawbacks of this approach.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tekknik 5y ago> Most people aren't aware of GPS trackers other than movies and think they are much harder to come by. AirTags are also less nefarious by nature. If you get caught with a GPS tracker on your person that's pretty suspicious. These are used in RC a fair amount, not sure why it'd be anymore suspicious than having an AirTag