6 ms·
Getting $100k sticker price worth of stocks per year is worth about $100k a year. If stocks go up they are worth more, otherwise less. On average they will be w
by Jensson 5y ago
Getting $100k sticker price worth of stocks per year is worth about $100k a year. If stocks go up they are worth more, otherwise less. On average they will be worth more than cash, and for a big company it is rare for them to go down a lot, so I'd say that getting the $100k worth of stocks a year is at least as good as just getting the cash.
Edit: Not sure why people think otherwise. Maybe they are used to companies where you have to pay money to get those stocks? Big companies gives them to you for free, there is no exercise cost.
- jdright 5y ago3 years receiving vested stocks. If price stayed the same, it would be worth 200k. Today it is worth 80k. So no, thanks. Stocks are not worth unless you're FAANG
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThe stocks vest progressively. You don’t literally have to wait 3 years to cash out. If you can’t afford a single but if variance then I guess RSUs won’t make you happy. But for everyone else they work just fine (unless your company goes down in flames, in which case you have bigger problems and are probably job searching anyway)
- rco8786 5y agoIncredibly untrue. I’m sorry that your particular company saw a 60% decrease in stock price over 3 years. But this is not the norm for any reasonably healthy company.
- mojomark 5y agoFully concur. I recieved stock appreciation rights (SARs) as a bonus at one company for a few years. CEO drove company into the ground that effectively wiped out all of these SARs. I was bitter at the CEO for making stupid decisions, but not at the fact that my bonus was in the form of SARs. If I'd have stuck to my guns more, the company would have probably succeeded and the SARs could have had significant value. Bottom line, with stock payment, you have a say in their ultimate value. Do good work, company value invreases, you enrich yourself.
- intuitionist 5y agoI think many people on HN may be too young to remember the early 2000s, when you’d kill someone for your stock price to be down only 60% over 3 years, but it absolutely happens to good companies too.
- overrun11 5y agoYou aren't guaranteed your salary either though and in many of those cases in the 2000's workers were laid off. Being paid entirely in cash salary doesn't make you immune to market turbulence.
- srb4 5y agoI thought I was going to be rich with my first job at a startup out of college but the dot com bust basically made it all worthless. Stock is great but cash would have been better.
- pb7 5y agoWhat would you have done with the cash? Hold it? That’s how the poor stay poor.
- alisonkisk 5y agoIt happened 1 year in 20, after an incredible run up, and good companies recovered.
- rco8786 5y agoWe can talk about normal expectations without having to explicitly state that black swan events can happen. If you took a stance of “I’m not going to take any pay in equity because I saw what happened in 2001” you would have left millions of dollars on the table over the last 20 years.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agoI think that once you start looking for hard evidence on software company stocks, you're in for a learning experience.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agoIn reality, most stocks decline. You know this from VCs hitting 10x semi-frequently and still losing money. Statistically speaking, they're correct.
- rco8786 5y agoThis is literally the opposite of reality. The private/VC market is not relevant here. We’re strictly talking about publicly traded companies.
- okhobb 5y agoNo this is actually true. Most stocks do go down (or at least only match much less risky investments like short-term bonds), but the stock market goes up because some stocks go up a lot. This is why all investors diversify. For example, the Russel 3000 Index goes up ~10% a year because they remove bad stocks and replace them with ones that seem better. But, employment at a single company with stock-based compensation is a concentrated bet on that single stock during the employment timeframe. Recently learned this from the excellent and very pithy Michael Batnick blog https://theirrelevantinvestor.com/2020/09/10/most-stocks-suck/ https://theirrelevantinvestor.com/2020/09/10/most-stocks-suc... who was citing https://wpcarey.asu.edu/department-finance/faculty-research/do-stocks-outperform-treasury-bills https://wpcarey.asu.edu/department-finance/faculty-research/...
- overrun11 5y agoI agree the stock market has positive skew but in your career you will have enough bets to smooth out the effects of betting on a single stock. Additionally, you're not really making the same bet as an equity investor because your bet has optionality. Your downside is capped at less than a year in loss earnings because if the stock goes down and the company cannot bring you back up to market rate you just switch companies. If the stock goes up, you enjoy 4 years of above market compensation before getting reset to market rate.
- okhobb 5y ago
- smrtinsert 5y agoClassic survivorship bias
- rco8786 5y ago/shrug. The vast, VAST majority of public companies do not lose 60% of their value in 3 years. I guess that’s just me surviving though.
- Jensson 5y agoIf the stocks go down before they vest you can just leave for another company and reset your compensation to the normal level, it isn't like the contract says you have to stay. If you keep the stocks after they vest then that is your fault for keeping them instead of selling them.
- sys_64738 5y agoI don't think you realize how wrong you are. Many average, boring tech companies pay RSUs big style. Not FAANG big but they're worth crazy amounts.
- baobabKoodaa 5y ago> at least as good as getting cash This claim is patently false. If you receive $100k in cash, you can immediately exchange that to $100k in public company stock. The opposite is not true (if you receive stock with a vesting period, you cannot immediately exchange it to cash). Therefore, getting cash is at least as good as getting public company stock, not the other way around.
- alisonkisk 5y agoWhen you get an offer of $100K cash + $100K in stock, that's before appreciation. So 3 years from now your equity is appreciated but your cash is not, so you get $225K in cash equivalent.
- baobabKoodaa 5y agoThis is false. If you immediately exchanged your cash to stock (as I specified in the post that you are replying to) then 3 years from now your "cash" option is worth exactly the same as your "cash + stock" option.
- rgcase 5y agoThis is wrong. It would be true if you received all the cash in a lump sum as soon as you're hired, and you used it to buy stock, but if your cash "vests" in the same way as equity typically does then you'd lose out on the opportunity for it to appreciate before vesting like shares can.
- pb7 5y agoNo one is giving you 4 years of paychecks on day 1. But they do grant 4 years of equity that is appreciating while you’re waiting for it to vest. That’s the difference. Cash is worse.
- Rastonbury 5y agoIf it's about timeframes it can be thought of as like a year end bonus being paid out when it vests. With some risks in terms of share price (which is like variable cash bonuses). The only reason most prefer cash is because it's a hard number that base increases/bonus are computed by and for negotiation in next job.
- citizenpaul 5y ago>Not sure why people think otherwise. Because stock compensation can be vastly different experiences therefor not just as good as getting cash.
- rco8786 5y agoIt’s weird to say this though. Because stock comp is purely additive in almost all cases. The amount it adds to your pay is variable, and in extreme circumstances can even be $0. But it’s not like you can really lose money because of equity based pay, under normal circumstances.
- citizenpaul 5y agoYou could be compelled to accept a lower salary with the expectations of stock being worth lots of money then it actually (as is the usual case) ends up being less than salary would have. I mean this scenario only happens at just about every startup if you read peoples experiences though I don't know if there are or if its possible to have a study done on this since the data is likely private.