4 ms·
>thinly veiled legal threats How is asking someone questions a legal threat?
by charcircuit 5y ago
>thinly veiled legal threats
How is asking someone questions a legal threat?
- pdonis 5y agoAsking someone questions about their compliance with a law is not the same as asking someone questions about an innocuous subject.
- charcircuit 5y agoIf I ask if your site complies with COPPA, that's not a threat that I'm going to sue you.
- kube-system 5y agoIf I ask you a peculiar question you may wonder what my motivation was for asking it.
- kelnos 5y agoMaybe you know that, but I don't.
- pdonis 5y agoYou might claim that it isn't, but if you are just asking me that question out of the blue I'm certainly going to wonder why you're asking and what you're up to. A random individual that goes around asking individuals who have websites if their websites comply with some law can't claim that they're just behaving in a normal everyday manner.
- msla 5y ago> How is asking someone questions a legal threat? Asking questions is an implied threat often enough that a question can indeed effectively be a threat.
- dqv 5y agoThey weren't just asking questions. From the email: >My questions are about your process for when I do submit a request. It's really easy to read this as "I am going to be submitting a request." >I look forward to your reply without undue delay and at most within 45 days of this email, as required by Section 1798.130 of the California Civil Code. So I'd say there is some legal threat here.
- charcircuit 5y agosubmitting a request isn't at all like a lawsuit
- dqv 5y agoNo one said it is.
- MaulingMonkey 5y ago> I look forward to your reply without undue delay and at most within 45 days of this email, as required by Section 1798.130 of the California Civil Code. This reads as a thinly vieled command to respond, not a mere request, citing legal code and (incorrectly) asserting it's applicability as a basis for the authority to give such a command, with the implication being the possibility of legal action if the demanded response is not provided.
- smsm42 5y agoThat code talks about businesses, and not just any businesses, but ones with revenue over $25M: https://oag.ca.gov/privacy/ccpa#sectiona https://oag.ca.gov/privacy/ccpa#sectiona Random blogger who's not a business does not have any connection to this. It's more like if I tell you I'll sue you for murder, high treason and collusion with the Martian invasion, is it really a legal threat? There's literally no legal way for me to sue anybody like that.
- MaulingMonkey 5y agoA baseless legal threat is still a legal threat, and that legal threat may well merit the time and energy to hire a lawyer to verify the baselessness of said threat, and to file the motion to dismiss should a lawsuit be filed despite the baseless cause of action, lest one suffer a default judgement on account of a failure to respond.
- lazide 5y agoThe last paragraph where it referenced a specific legal code is where it is a threat. Asking someone questions to see if they will incriminate themselves is an easy low cost legal trick that works surprisingly well.
- Supermancho 5y ago> How is asking someone questions a legal threat? It isn't. Being paranoid about lawsuits against some personal blog shows a lack of legal sophistication and this type of sensationalism promotes an irrational fear of being somehow financially vulnerable to almost any legal predation. That's simply not how the US system works. There have to be actual damages for a court case to go forward to the worst-case expensive end (depending on what most people consider "crippling"). Courts aren't pernicious and are very sensitive to anyone attempting to waste court time on exploitation (except in Texas courts supporting patent trolling, obv). Any judge would have this resolved by giving the parties a 15 minute sidebar to come to an actionable resolution or sanction both sides in some motivating manner. The US legal system has a vested interest in not taking everything to a long drawn out fight, due to limited court time, even if it is presented differently in media (or the comments in these threads, which are laughable).
- wslack 5y ago> Being paranoid about lawsuits against some personal blog shows a lack of legal sophistication and this type of sensationalism promotes an irrational fear of being somehow financially vulnerable to almost any legal predation. And yet, many people reacted just like this writer. Perhaps, given that the reaction was widespread, it could and should have been anticipated, instead of expecting every person to have your evident legal knowledge.
- masklinn 5y agoAnd above somebody posted a link to 3 different counsel who took the message seriously (one an inside counsel who did not feel confident about their read and referred it to outside counsel).
- dawnbreez 5y agoFollowing those questions by citing a statute of the law, however, IS a legal threat. Implicit in citing specific parts of the law is the threat that those parts of the law apply to this situation.
- 5y ago