9 ms·
It would be good to see an autopsy, to find out if it's actually the battery that went into thermal runaway, or something else that shorted and dumped all of it
by userbinator 5y ago
It would be good to see an autopsy, to find out if it's actually the battery that went into thermal runaway, or something else that shorted and dumped all of its energy.
I have no idea how much heavy metals I've been exposed to by inhaling the toxic smoke. I don't know how much smoke my pregnant wife inhaled. I worry how much chemical residue is on my desk, floor, walls, how much is getting recycled by my HVAC system, how much exposure my pets had.
That sort of paranoia doesn't help. In fact it may cause psychosomatic symptoms (nocebo effect). You've probably inhaled far worse if you've ever been to a barbeque, gas station, or just took a walk in one of the more crowded areas of the city.
- bluedino 5y agoI partially melted an electric kettle on the stovetop and my girlfriend at the time went to her moms house for three days
- baybal2 5y agoNo, lithium battery fires are really nasty, and that's why he got a chemical burn. LiPF6 is a contact irritant, PF5 it decomposes to is a gas, and also a respiratory irritant, and HF PH5 decomposes in the air is a dangerous poisonous acid. This is what everybody visiting a lithium battery factory is told on safety orientation. In case there is fire in the factory, run, preferably until you are few blocks away. If enough hot aqueous LF6 in solvent gets on the skin, you will get a chemical burn. In worst case, the same thing as HF poisoning will happen (it pulls electrolytes out of blood, and then death from heart failure.)
- userbinator 5y agoA lithium battery factory has many orders of magnitude more chemicals than a single low-capacity cell. "The dose makes the poison." It's not even clear if the battery caught fire, or if something else shorted out.
- romwell 5y agoWhat's clear is that Bose QC-35 II headphones caused bodily damage to the consumer who used it in a completely normal way and in accordance to the instruction manual, without any potential of such damage being indicated on the product that is generally assumed to be safe. We should stop nitpicking of which part of Bose QC-35 II headphones malfunctioned and caused the product to be deadly dangerous. Instead, we should focus on the following problems: * How do we incentivize the manufactures to take safety of their products seriously? * How do we make sure the manufacturers don't skirt the responsibility of selling unsafe products as safe ones? One doesn't get enter the free market without agreeing to some rules first. The rules are what differentiates a market from a scam. Actually delivering the product for which the money was paid is one such rule. Clearly warning about lethal dangers of the stuff you try to sell is another. Violations of either rule come with a cost - because these violations damage not only the customer, but the entire free market.
- userbinator 5y agoWhat's clear is that you seem to have a bone to pick with Bose for some reason or another, since you're apparently the only one spamming the equivalent of SUE THEM SUE THEM SUE THEM!!! in every single one of your comments.
- romwell 5y agoWell, first, I'm not the only one. That's the recommendation of one of the top comment here as well[1]. Second, I was spamming "Report to CPSC, then talk to a lawyer". The advice to sue or not sue is not for me to make. Third: > you to have a bone to pick with Bose for some reason or another They caused chemical burns to the person I am talking to while I tell them that they should consult a lawyer. That's my bone. ------ Another reason is that selling hazardous products that aren't labeled as such is a threat to the free market, which many people here are in support of. In short: what makes market different from scam is rules. Delivering the product for which the money was paid is one such rule. Warning about hazards of the product you try to sell is another. If there is no cost to violating the rules, the rules will not be observed, and the free market ceases to exist. I want Bose to bear the cost of violating the rules of the market, to ensure that they don't poison the well for other participants (in particular, who may be selling safer products after investing in safety). Is the above clear, or should I elaborate further? [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29602437 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29602437
- romwell 5y ago>It would be good to see an autopsy, You do realize that there was a quite real chance of someone seeing the OP's autopsy here? >That sort of paranoia doesn't help I guess you don't. I find it fascinating that we get people saying "both of these in this thread: * The inherent explosive and deadly danger of lithium is well known, the OP should have expected it, and should not complain * The danger of lithium batteries is overblown, the OP shouldn't complain It's quite a mindfuck to argue with both simultaneously.
- rndgermandude 5y ago>You do realize that there was a quite real chance of someone seeing the OP's autopsy here? That's an overstatement. The batteries in this thing are the most dangerous part, and yet they are too small to explode with a force that could cause an immediate fatality, i.e neither the explosion itself nor the shrapnel it could generate from the casing or the other components in the headphone are powerful enough. The risk here is burns, and maybe toxic exposure. And while burns can be rather bad (especially since it's Lithium), of course, also depending on how much flammable "stuff" you have on your head (hair, hat, headscarf, etc), burns are not the same thing as death. The risk of a fatality is extremely low. The risk of lasting scars and disfigurement, deafness (on the battery side at least) and even blindness has a somewhat higher chance. Then again, just look at the picture in the article. You can see how little damage is there to the actual "fragile" head phones plastic casing. Mostly intact. It wasn't a major explosion, it wasn't a major fire, and there probably wasn't any shrapnel whatsoever. >>That sort of paranoia doesn't help >I guess you don't. This was clearly referring to the "toxic fumes" bit. And it is a fair thing to say, in my humble opinion. The fumes from the battery and plastic certainly aren't great, but unless you deliberately stay there and huff them without opening a window, your exposure will be rather minute, especially considering how small this event had to be. Indeed, what you inhale at a barbeque or just from burning food, or staying at the outside of a gas station for too long will be worse. The "chemical burns" claim in the article is just confusing to me. I'd get it if the claim was that only the hands had a burning sensation like that, but the arms too but nothing besides that? Such a thing is either caused by direct contact (so hands only) or from fumes/spraying (which would mean exposed areas like the face should be affected as well). The way the story represents it makes me think it might be a psychosomatic effect only, but not necessarily of course. There is a "sweet spot" where these things might have sprayed particles only in a very limited area where hands and arms were affected but other exposed skin was too far away, but that sounds unlikely to me at least... Regardless, nobody should expect these things to blow up, and it's fair to complain when they do. If it was a singular/very rare incident, fine, really bad luck. If there are a number of reports like this, this could indicate a systemic engineering or manufacturing problem.
- bmitc 5y agoWhat other thing in the headphones could possibly cause such a fire and burns? Whether or not the battery started it or something else did, it is clearly the battery that provided the serious problem, so if it's there, the danger is there.
- romwell 5y agoWhile I agree with you, if you may, I will augment what you said slightly: >Whether or not the battery started it or something else did, it is clearly the defective Bose QC-35 headphones that provided the serious problem, so if you have them, the danger is there. Which is something that they should put on the label.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> Which is something that they should put on the label. It might already be there? Just that the warning is so standard and ubiquitous that it is universally ignored (lots of things contain lithium and have the potential to explode). I prefer the version that takes an AAA battery. A bit safer, especially if you avoid using rechargeables.
- southerntofu 5y agoI use only wired devices. Exceptionally when i need to travel i'll take a lithium battery with me for a laptop/phone, but otherwise everything stays wired at all times.
- romwell 5y ago>It might already be there? Just that the warning is so standard and ubiquitous that it is universally ignored (lots of things contain lithium and have the potential to explode). No, the warning is not there.[1] The manual instructs the user to take headphones off if you experience a "warming sensation", that's all. The generic warnings aren't for normal operation; as in "improper use, like <...>, may lead to <...>". There was no improper use here, which is why it's a concern. Additionally, there are many ways in which a device can fail. These Bose QC 35 II headphones not only caught fire, but also caused chemical burns. Clearly, the engineers were aware of the dangers, but the product managers decided they can get away with saying "take them off if there's a warming sensation" without adding "BECAUSE THIS MEANS THEY ARE ABOUT TO CATCH FIRE AND SPRAY YOU WITH HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS, RUN FOR YOUR LFIE". [1]https://assets.bose.com/content/dam/Bose_DAM/Web/consumer_electronics/global/products/headphones/qc35_ii/PDF/811772_og_quietcomfort-35-wireless-ii_en.pdf https://assets.bose.com/content/dam/Bose_DAM/Web/consumer_el...
- bserge 5y agoWell, someone paying $400 for a pair of headphones is probably not very knowledgeable outside their narrow field of expertise. I bought a few power tools recently and would've paid 2x-3x as much if I went with the usual Bosch/Makita/Hitachi. But no, they're mostly the same exact stuff as other, Chinese made tools. I'd you look carefully, you can buy the same design/materials/electronics for much less by just foregoing the brand name. Black&Decker is now just a front for the cheapest shit. If they still have any quality stuff I haven't seen it. It's not about the country of manufacture, they literally use the cheapest stuff at the same price as better tools from other brands. Whether it's made in China or Japan or EU, it's the materials and design that matter. Pretty much only the high end hydraulic/pneumatic stuff has no competition so you have to buy a known brand at a high price.
- ekianjo 5y ago> much heavy metals I've been exposed to by inhaling the toxic smoke Sounds like a hypochondriac person.
- pdpi 5y agoSounds like somebody who just had something blow up on their face (quite literally). The burns are real. There is actual palpable damage. It’s only natural to go into “what other things might have gone wrong?” mode in response. Sure, it’s probably an overreaction, but it seems to me like an eminently reasonable overreaction given the circumstances!
- semi-extrinsic 5y agoIf you're being literal, they didn't actually blow up, and the person removed them from their head before they started smoldering. The biggest problem for OP is that they messed up their first response, maybe due to inadequate fire safety training or just panic. After throwing the headphones out on the porch, they should have jumped in the shower and stood in running cold-ish water for at least 15 minutes. This is the basic rule that applies to any situation with a burn, if it's from spilling coffee or touching a hot pan or whatever. It's what we learn in primary school. I would not be surprised, if they do go to court, that this would substantially reduce the compensation for OP.
- pdpi 5y agoChemical burns don’t play by the same rules as fire, and water sometimes makes things worse. Lithium is an alkaline metal so, if I had the presence of mind to think about that, I’d wonder whether lithium batteries are one of the “keep away from water” sort of things.
- semi-extrinsic 5y agoLithium-ion batteries don't contain metallic lithium, so water is perfectly fine. The current state-of-the-art method for extinguishing burning electric vehicles is that firefighters use a special rig to lift the whole car into an open top container (like you use for waste on construction sites) and then fill that with water and let it sit for a few days.
- loa_in_ 5y ago> You've probably inhaled far worse if you've ever been to a barbeque, gas station, or just took a walk in one of the more crowded areas of the city. That's just dismissive attitude that accomplishes nothing and adds nothing to the discussion.
- najqh 5y agoI think it's a good answer. "is this too bad? no, you've been exposed to worse and nothing happened to you"
- fouc 5y agoExposure is cumulative though. If someone keeps getting exposed to "innocuous" things like cigarette smoke, they may very well find 20 years later they've got lung cancer and end up dying young.
- loa_in_ 5y agoYes, if you assume that author knows the extent of OPs exposure to the fumes and what was in them. I assume no such thing.
- krisoft 5y ago> Yes, if you assume that author knows the extent of OPs exposure to the fumes and what was in them. What was in them: we know it was a burning modern electronics, plastic fumes and a battery fire. Extent of OPs exposure: we know it was one event of fixed duration, close contact with a single burning equipment. Not a chronic exposure, not a pyre of a dozen headphones. We of course don’t know details on the margins, like which parts did melt on the pcb or how many breaths did the author inhale of this smoke, these are small details. Even if we assume that these unknown variables fall on the bad side of their respective spectrum, we can still bound our estimation. (Like for example assuming that nearly all the nastines from the single headphone went into the smoke and the author did sit around for an hour in the smooky room.) This means that we know a lot about both of those questions and can estimate the unknowns with reasonable worst-case thinking. (Which is the conservative thing to do in this situation) > That's just dismissive attitude that accomplishes nothing and adds nothing to the discussion. You say that, but it is not true. It is an understandable reaction on OPs part, once the initial shock is over and they see that they are still alive to think about if they have suffered any unknown long term harms. While obviously this kind of exposure is not good, and the OP is unlikely to ask for a repeat it is unlikely to cause lasting harm. In fact worrying about it might actually cause more harm. Thinking this through calmly and logically is not dismissive, and might actually help the author.
- rbrtdrmpc- 5y agoI own those and opened them a couple of times to replace the battery and the earpads, no need of further investigation, the battery is placed there and for sure there is a short circuit protection in place by mandatory design, it is also unlikely they got pierced by something since they sit in a large space and the battery itself is rounded, so expansion is took into account, to me it seems that the battery was already compromised from the factory which is very very very bad edit: no idea if the internal thermistor can fail by any means and it could have messed up the charge/discharge logic
- jacquesm 5y agoCould have been dropped in a bad way. This is the reason why Lithium Ion cells go bad, external damage. There are numerous examples of people falling with their e-bikes, not even visible damage on the outside of the bike or the pack other than maybe a scratched up handlebar and then 12 hours later the whole thing suddenly goes up in flames. Here is one example caught on video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbWmCiMJdT8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbWmCiMJdT8
- rbrtdrmpc- 5y agoAs i said the battery has a lot of space, is glued, and sealed shut within a “box”, you should be able to throw them out of the window with no problem at all, I’ve dropped mine a lot and they are already 5/6 yo
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, I would expect them to be designed for that, especially given the proximity to the body. I've reviewed a design for a LiPo powered wearable once and the list of recommendations was surprisingly long when it was all done. One thing that I find curious about this instance is how it failed, I'm very surprised that what appears to have burned through is the inner shell, rather than say a burst wall in the outer shell. That said: headphones are subject to all kinds of abuse and that's why I'm particularly interested in what went wrong here, either, as you say, Bose has an inbound quality control issue or there was possibly some thing that this pair of headphones was subjected to that pushed it outside of its design parameters (electrically or physically). It's hard to say for sure without a much more detailed autopsy of the device (fortunately not of the user...). I have a Sony rough equivalent of this device, and if I would ever drop it on a hard surface I'd stop using it simply because I would never trust a Lithium Ion battery after it has been subjected to a shock load. But I'm a bit paranoid about them, the more you are familiar with some tech the less comfortable you feel while using it. As for your edit: thermistors can and do fail, but the battery protection circuitry is hip to that and should simply stop charging the battery if the thermistor ever open circuits or short circuits. Theoretically I guess it could fail with a resistance that indicates a safe operating temperature but I have never seen that happen (and I've worked on tons of Li-Ion packs, enough to see a couple of failed thermistors, all of them open circuits).
- ghusbands 5y agoActually, it's not a small thing. There are often reporting requirements for even small spills of dangerous chemicals, like those contained in batteries, and even small amounts of some chemicals can be dangerous for humans and local soil and groundwater. Were I the OP, I'd be contacting the local public-service hazardous waste team to ask questions about what needs reporting to whom and what cleanup and medical checks may be required.
- FlotsamFlow 5y agoYeah, I agree. I actually have these headphones and love them, so for a second I was a bit worried. However, this is clearly an isolated case, so I'm sure there's more to the story, and certainly swearing off all wireless/rechargeable gear is an overreaction. I didn't hunt for very long, but a cursory search didn't turn up anything like this with these headphones or Bose for that matter. And while I don't trust corporations implicitly, I do draw distinctions between companies like Ford or Samsung that might wait until absolutely necessary to do a recall and a company like Bose that has always seemed to have a lot riding on their reputation with their target customers. And given my interactions with other companies after product failures, I would be stoked to be offered the brand new flagship line (QC45) assuming I had no real injuries. Then again, if I were of a litigious nature (and thought there was a potential payday) I might focus on how the trace amount of "heavy metal" smoke from LIon batteries that lingered after I threw the headphones outside might affect my pets, wife, unborn child and HVAC system instead of being reasonable.
- tomxor 5y ago> That sort of paranoia doesn't help. In fact it may cause psychosomatic symptoms (nocebo effect). You're not wrong, but I don't think it's an unreasonable reaction when you've literally been diagnosed with chemical burns, especially when it was not initially obvious. If you read the post in full, this is separate from lipo fire event, he tried to retrieve the serial number and later after handling it noticed a worsening burning sensation on his hands and arms... that kind of separation in time from a silent exposure of something to horrible side effects really fuck with your mind.
- analog31 5y agoWhich component of a pair of headphones contains as much energy as the battery?
- RL_Quine 5y agoThe plastic case almost certainly contains more energy than the battery.
- analog31 5y agoExcellent, now figure out how that plastic suddenly bursts into flames. Many of the plastics used in consumer electronics are referred to as "self extinguishing," or are otherwise quite hard to ignite.