8 ms·
EDF shares plunge after faults found at French nuclear power reactor
- sofixa 5y agoThat's one serious downside of nuclear, when there's an issue, you lose a lot of power generation ( on the other hand if you have a lot of wind turbines from the same model, in such a scenario you'd still have the same type of impact). However, nuclear is still more stable than renewables without massive amounts of storage which are currently infeasible, and the future French energy mix will continue to have a heavy nuclear component ( a few variants, including ditching all nuclear, were proposed and studied, and one of the most nuclear heavy ones was chosen).
- champtar 5y agoPresidential election is next year and some candidates want to completely get rid of nuclear as fast as possible, so this can change. Not sure these candidates understand this means more CO2, bigger dependency on Russia for gaz and more expensive electricity in the end.
- southerntofu 5y ago> this means more CO2, bigger dependency on Russia That's arguable, but certainly not definitive. This is based on the assumption that energy usage will only ever rise (until the final collapse of industrial civilization), generating an ever-increasing abundance of waste (food, electronics and other supplies) and empty buildings (3 million empty dwellings and counting). Some of us do want to build a lowtech society in which we don't have to choose between killing millions of species due to capitalist activity or living under a rock. > more expensive electricity in the end This part though goes against all current studies. When public subsidies for building/deconstructing nuclear plants are taken into account, nuclear is by far the most expensive energy source. This is of course assuming that they even know how to deconstruct those. It's not like like a site they stopped in 1985 and claimed would be a showcase ("vitrine") of how to dismantle nuclear plants had its plans go 20 times over budget and the estimation kept climbing along the due date currently scheduled for 2040. Or is it in fact just like that?! [0] [0] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Site_nucl%C3%A9aire_de_Brennilis#Un_d.C3.A9mant.C3.A8lement_exp.C3.A9rimental https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Site_nucl%C3%A9aire_de_Brennil...
- champtar 5y agoOur energy usage will definitely decrease and I'm all for it, I just hope it's in a controlled way and not a brutal collapse. I'm talking "short" term, if you shutdown nuclear plant for political reasons, you just burn more fossil fuel, Germany was nice enough to do the experiment for us, invest massively in renewables but shutdown nuclear plant so they can burn coal and emit 3x more CO2 per kWh than France ... (https://app.electricitymap.org/zone/FR https://app.electricitymap.org/zone/FR) For the price just have a look at latest RTE report: https://www.rte-france.com/analyses-tendances-et-prospectives/bilan-previsionnel-2050-futurs-energetiques https://www.rte-france.com/analyses-tendances-et-prospective... / https://assets.rte-france.com/prod/public/2021-12/Futurs-Energetiques-2050-principaux-resultats.pdf https://assets.rte-france.com/prod/public/2021-12/Futurs-Ene... The scenario with the most nuclear is the cheapest (deconstruction included). This report show the cost in 2060 which is less than half life of nuclear plant and full life of solar panel and wind turbine, I would love the numbers for 2080. Here some comments on reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/france/comments/qon812/jai_recompil%C3%A9_les_graphs_du_rapport_rte_en_une/ https://www.reddit.com/r/france/comments/qon812/jai_recompil...
- southerntofu 5y agoThanks for the link. That's an interesting material even though i disagree with some of the principles laid in the study. It takes for granted that electricity usage will continue to rise and that's a good thing. Personally i would argue electricity as a layer of abstraction is really good at hiding pollution, but is not energy-efficient for many tasks. It also assumes that we keep a giant interconnected grid (with huge losses) and that we need to centralize production just like we do with fuel/nuclear plants. That's what the "artificialisation des sols" line is about, and does not account for the possibility to produce energy more locally if we consume less of it. For example, what's more ecological: - a solar farm produced from high-waste silicon wafers that take many Watt-hours to build, deeply anchored in tons of concrete, running electricity for kilometers until it reaches an electric stove that itself comprises complex/polluting materials? - or a simple gaz stove made of simple metal, running gaz recycled from your cooking waters by bacteria (yes that's a thing) or from methanization of your local compost? Even these two scenarios i'm laying don't cut it if we want to investigate actual degrowth: what's the environmental cost that everybody has their own kitchen (stove/fridge/pans) and cooks for themselves? There's economies of scale to be made by reinstating communal kitchens. Even their scenario advocating for "sobriety" is very naive. It's focused on personal actions (or lack thereof), when the biggest energy/resources waste we have as a society is due to big business not individual actions. For example, they mention "digital sobriety" for users, when we tech people know the biggest resources used are because of surveillance/tracking companies (Google/Amazon/CloudFlare..) keeping huge datacenters filled with data that does not provide any value to the users: what does it matter if you trash 100KB of emails every day from your Gmail if Google keeps 500KB of data points about you in that timeframe (numbers from the top of my hat)? All in all, there's a lot to account for, and this RTE study unsurprisingly only accounts for what's related to their profiting of the situation. In such a biased setup, not surprising that green alternatives doesn't seem economically viable. I haven't finished reading the study, but if it claims nuclear is cheaper, that warrants serious proof: all studies so far point to the opposite as true.
- sofixa 5y agoNone of those presidential candidates has a chance to win, at least as of now. French presidential elections have a habit of sudden scandals changing the landscape.
- champtar 5y agoAnd yet we closed Fessenheim nuclear plant early.
- cesarb 5y ago> ( on the other hand if you have a lot of wind turbines from the same model, in such a scenario you'd still have the same type of impact) In such a scenario, with wind turbines, you could take the risk and keep them running; even if a few end up breaking up as a consequence, it's no big deal. You cannot do that with nuclear.
- Orphis 5y agoThe upside is they found it. They didn't try to cover it up, it didn't blow up or anything. There will be issues in any complex installation even with the best of planning, what matters is how you deal with those.
- natch 5y ago>They didn't try to cover it up How could we possibly know? > There will be issues in any complex installation even with the best of planning agree >what matters is how you deal True but the nature of the project and the potential dangers of the project materials also matter.
- Orphis 5y ago> How could we possibly know? They communicated about it. What else do you want? > True but the nature of the project and the potential dangers of the project materials also matter. What are you trying to say? They found a problem, used the protocols they had in place to stop the reactors and they'll take care of it. Looks like they knew the nature of the project and potential dangers and had an appropriate response.
- natch 5y ago>They communicated about it. That tells us nothing about what they did or tried to do before they finally did reveal some possibly partial information. So it doesn’t answer the question. How could we possibly know that they didn’t try to cover it up? For all we know, they tried very hard and failed. >What else do you want? Less naïveté when dealing with the topic of how the people running such projects tend to operate.
- southerntofu 5y ago> They didn't try to cover it up, it didn't blow up or anything. Most nuclear incidents do not involve stuff blowing up, but rather stuff leaking. As for covering things up, that's a specialty of this field, as any former nuclear insider will tell you.
- breckenedge 5y agohttps://archive.md/Ixq7X https://archive.md/Ixq7X
- trhway 5y agoThey temporarily lost 4 reactors / 6 GW. "It said the French utility could need to spend about 2 billion-3 billion euros ($2.3 billion-$3.4 billion) in 2022 to buy back some of its power to cover outages at the nuclear reactors." More money after bad money. The cost of solar 1GW farm with storage is well under $2B. The power transmission cable from Alger to France would still leave it under $2B/1GW. Instead France is doubling down on nuclear.
- brnt 5y agoFrance is currently occupying a bit of a baseload supplier for its renewable energy neighbours. It may make strategic and economic sense for them to double down: they have the expertise, installed base, friendly environment and market.
- wumpus 5y agoOther than those pesky maintenance issues for older plants, and their proven inability to build new ones at a reasonable price?
- southerntofu 5y agoAnd they have the (supposedly former) colonies providing nuclear fuel at the cost of protecting their environment and population. And abundant rivers with to cool down the reactors and destroy their local ecosystems. And very collaborative national media outlets who mostly don't cover the nuclear scandals due to being owned by Bouygues (french multinational well-known for telecoms but who also does a fair share of public construction including on the famous EPR) or by the french State. Cozy situation!
- Kuinox 5y ago*Citation & sources needed.
- southerntofu 5y agoAnd they have the (supposedly former) colonies providing nuclear fuel at the cost of protecting their environment and population. [0] And abundant rivers with to cool down the reactors and destroy their local ecosystems. [1] And very collaborative national media outlets who mostly don't cover the nuclear scandals due to being owned by Bouygues [2] (french multinational well-known for telecoms but who also does a fair share of public construction including on the famous EPR [3]) or by the french State [4]. Some additions: - misleading/missing news reports on nuclear topics was covered by the 2012 documentary "Les nouveaux chiens de garde" [5] (the new watchdogs) about media corruption and disinformation: they went through two days worth of news broadcast on two TV channels to compare how was presented (or not) the fact that Bouygues had major engineering failures on the EPR construction - the french government has a history of repression against ecological/anti-nuclear movements, ranging from the murder in 1977 of Vital Michalon by police forces [6] during an anti-nuclear protest, to the harassment and military (gendarmerie) occupation of Bure (Meuse) and surrounding villages, including dozens of house searches, a bunch of prison sentences, and an ongoing investigation of eco-anarchists for "criminal association" [7] - and don't even get me started on how to (not) deconstruct those facilities [8] [0] https://www.pambazuka.org/governance/french-nuclear-power-fed-uranium-niger https://www.pambazuka.org/governance/french-nuclear-power-fe... [1] http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2019/ph241/clark1/ http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2019/ph241/clark1/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TF1_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TF1_Group ; also see previous addition about TF1's non-coverage of EPR-related incidents [3] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%C3%A9acteur_pressuris%C3%A9_europ%C3%A9en https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%C3%A9acteur_pressuris%C3%A9_... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/France_T%C3%A9l%C3%A9visions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/France_T%C3%A9l%C3%A9visions - no specific source about "censorship" of nuclear incidents, however there is a strong and documented history of firing journalists and humorists who are too critical of the french State and corporations, and of self-censorship ; see also acrimed.org (french only sorry) [5] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Les_Nouveaux_Chiens_de_garde_(film) https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Les_Nouveaux_Chiens_de_garde_(... [6] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vital_Michalon https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vital_Michalon [7] https://bureburebure.info/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/EN-Bure-History-and-context.pdf https://bureburebure.info/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/EN-Bure... [8] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29600399 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29600399