3 ms·
Ironically, mild extortion is the point of the Tribune's "What's Your Problem?" column. People who can't get results from local businesses write the column, wh
by joezydeco 15y ago
Ironically, mild extortion is the point of the Tribune's "What's Your Problem?" column.
People who can't get results from local businesses write the column, where they're publicly shamed into doing something to help the consumer.
- spooneybarger 15y agoWhether yelp's business model meets the definition of extortion is debatable ( either way, i find it distasteful ). However, there is nothing extortionist about this.
- blahedo 15y ago> Ironically, mild extortion is the point of the Tribune's "What's Your Problem?" column. I don't think so. I can see why you'd say that---there's a certain family resemblance---but extortion when someone threatens to reveal a bad thing for their own gain; WYP is actually revealing a bad thing for the gain of the reader. If Jon Yates (the WYP author) ever ended a phone call "if you pay me (or otherwise grant me consideration) I won't run this column," then that would turn it into extortion. As I think about it further, another thing that makes it not-extortion is that with WYP the company that did someone wrong is given a chance to make it right, even before the deed is revealed. That's not typically a feature of extortion. (Edit: clarify last paragraph)
- noduerme 15y agoIf you consider consumer advocacy columns to be a form of extortion... consider that the newspaper doesn't request money from the subject to "fix" the column.
- joezydeco 15y agoThe people that ask this Tribune reporter for help are people that can't get a problem solved by another means because the company is uncooperative or in denial about the problem. So when someone calls the business and says "Hi, I'm calling from the Chicago Tribune, where I'm going to write a story about you that will be read by half a million readers", do you think that will get a better outcome to the problem than the individual calling again for the 25th time?
- noduerme 15y agoSure it will. But if the business had done nothing wrong, journalistic ethics (which play no role in the "moderating" position taken by Yelp between "customer reviews") would stipulate that the newspaper could not report anything other than verifiable fact.
- joezydeco 15y agoBut the business owner (or government agency in most cases with Trib/WYP) see it as "if I don't fix this issue, it's going to be in the newspaper where my boss will see it". The reporter doesn't have to be unethical in the slightest. The message is implied and, in most cases from what I've read in the Tribune over the years, very effective.