5 ms·
Both Facebook (now Meta) and Youtube bungled their fact checking by disabling posts and videos that were counter to some narrative, but not factually incorrect.
by dekhn 5y ago
Both Facebook (now Meta) and Youtube bungled their fact checking by disabling posts and videos that were counter to some narrative, but not factually incorrect. That places them in a bad position, and they need to be called out publicly, as no other mechanism so far has pushed them towards more accurate fact checking.
- borplk 5y agoThey didn't "bungle" it. It's working as designed.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't post this sort of shallow, grandiose rhetoric. It leads to low-information, high-indignation discussion—i.e. flamewar—i.e. the crap that we're trying to avoid here. If you want to make this kind of critique, fine, but you need to do it with substance and not just turn up the volume knob. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jsdevtom 5y agoWhile I agree with you for the most part, their responsibility should not be fact checking. That should be left to the individual.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoThey made themselves the fact checkers. If they're going to take the mantle of "fact checker", it is their responsibility to do it well.
- bagacrap 5y agoOn the contrary, it's politicians and old media who came up with the "fake news" slogan and demanded FB and others start censoring opposing viewpoints. FB is all too happy to help spread falsehoods and inflammatory articles since they both drive engagement.
- mitigating 5y agoNo, "Ninety-five percent of Americans identified misinformation as a problem when they’re trying to access important information." "According to the poll, 79% of Republicans and 73% of Democrats said social media companies have a great deal or quite a bit of responsibility for misinformation." (https://apnews.com/article/coronavirus-pandemic-technology-business-health-misinformation-fbe9d09024d7b92e1600e411d5f931dd https://apnews.com/article/coronavirus-pandemic-technology-b...) Talk about "fact checking" you just make a statement about what people think and provided no evidence to back it up. That's the main problem here. Also "old media"?
- ralusek 5y agoThinking "misinformation is a problem" is not the same as thinking "politically biased corporations should censor what they deem to be misinformation in accordance with their own biases."
- Kiro 5y agoThey only did it after being pressured by the same people that are now saying they should not have done it. It doesn't matter what they do at this point. They will come out as the bad guys regardless.
- philovivero 5y agoI note how your comment has been largely ignored by... the massive numbers of Facebook and Google employees reading this site. If there was an ounce of integrity in Tech these days, this would have been called out, front-and-centre, and remedies to it would have been enacted. Instead, here we are almost two years later, and we're pretending that never happened. In some cases it's even being memory-holed. I predict within 4 years, it will be common to call someone pointing this out some sort of rabid conspiracy theorist. You cannot trust FB. You cannot trust Google. You cannot trust mainstream newspapers. You cannot trust the CDC. They got caught lying to you. Repeatedly. Obey at your peril.
- aqfamnzc 5y agoWhat did the CDC lie about? (Honest question)
- satellite2 5y agoAbout the efficacy of masks. They said they were not efficace to avoid hoarding and to reserve the small existing stock for medical professionals.
- mitigating 5y agoA lie is intentional. I'm not saying this is the case here because I haven't checked but if they believed that masks weren't effective then later changed their view because of new information or whatever that's not lying.
- satellite2 5y agoAs a scientific organisation the public expect them to have opinions that are supported by data. Already, today appealing to the autority argument while data are widely accessible is graceless. But abusing your expert position is outright deceitful. A scientific should be able to say that they don't have enough information to form a position. I think medicine more widely is in crisis as they still have not incorporated the digital transformation. And that can be seen even at your local doctor level. The patients are very informed (and often wrongly) and are coming to the appointment with a lot of data. A lot of doctors simply brush off those concern and go about with their standard diagnostic process. What patients expect is that the doctor take their proposition at face value, congratulate them for listing their symptoms and coming with a lead, and repeat the process with them, pinpointing the eventual inconsisencies in the symptoms or simply offering them another diagnostic that is also compatible but statistically more probable. That's the behaviour of the new expert, enjoy sharing informations and discussing them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]