3 ms·
>Isn't that kind of podunk scale for an industry to have a rock solid hold on US politics? Not when a Constitutional Amendment makes that industry "too big to
by krapp 5y ago
>Isn't that kind of podunk scale for an industry to have a rock solid hold on US politics?
Not when a Constitutional Amendment makes that industry "too big to fail" because its thesis on the necessity of the right to keep and bear arms depends on there being an industry manufacturing arms to begin with (at least at modern scale,) and when the industry overwhelmingly supports one political party, driving animosity with fear-based rhetoric against the other.
You just don't have the same intersection of identity politics, culture and even religion with any other industry in the US that you do with guns, even if the money spent elsewhere is greater.
- nradov 5y agoThe individual right to keep and bear arms is a natural right of all free people. It doesn't depend on the existence of the small arms industry. When the US Constitution was written there was hardly even an industry; most firearms were craft built.
- jaywalk 5y agoIf what you're saying were true, it would mean that manufacturing guns and/or ammunition for anything other than personal use could be made illegal without running afoul of the 2nd Amendment. Which is absurd.
- SQueeeeeL 5y agoThis entire thread is why gun control constantly keeps existing as an issue, you two people who should be political allies are now splitting hairs over relatively minor issues compared to the cost of healthcare and wage stagnation
- bumby 5y agoApparently, this can be pursued at the State level, so it may not be unconstitutional. https://malegislature.gov/Bills/192/HD4192/Cosponsor https://malegislature.gov/Bills/192/HD4192/Cosponsor
- Maursault 5y ago> The individual right to keep and bear arms is a natural right of all free people. Gun advocates are always going too far. It's not enough that the Founders specifically and narrowly intended the 2nd Amendment to be a check on tyranny and intentionally exclusive of self-defense, it has to also include self-defense due to popular and intellectually dishonest misinterpretation. No, a right to keep and bear arms is not a fundamental and inalienable right, so it is not a natural right, it is instead by definition a legal right subject to the laws of the State. It can be repealed. Self-defense is a natural right which can not be repealed nor is it subject to the laws of the State, which is why including it in the 2nd Amendment is superfluous and in fact dilutes the power of the 2nd, bastardizes it, transforming it from a self-less right to an intensely selfish, egotistical and psychological entitlement, making everyone less safe. It is ironic that Right of center dress themselves in such a way, as an advocate of rights, while at the same time dismantling the US Constitution's Bill of Rights. This is an assault on the Constitution, not advocation of it. First we lost the 4th Amendment protections, because police are entitled to search you and your car. Then we lost habeas corpus. Then we lost the 5th Amendment. Then we lost the 2nd Amendment. The words have not changed, they are just misinterpreted or ignored. There is patriotism, but it is quite distinct from the insistence by many if not most gun advocates for anarchy. Gun advocacy is not patriotism, it is more often psychological entitlement than not. We can only hope there still exist advocates of the 2nd in it's original unadulterated intention, who would selflessly sacrifice their lives to protect others from tyranny, should the need arise, as opposed to the idiots who will shoot and kill others while claiming heroism for haphazardly protecting property. Best example in modern history of a proper exercise of the 2nd Amendment is armed Black Panthers surrounding a courthouse. If you can't align yourself with the principle, you are no advocate of the 2nd Amendment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dasil003 5y ago> When the US Constitution was written there was hardly even an industry; most firearms were craft built. You mean at the dawn of the industrial revolution, before which, you know, everything was craft built?
- nradov 5y agoYes that's what I mean.
- krapp 5y agoWe live in the 21st century, not the 18th century. If liberty requires that access to guns be a universal and inalienable right, then the capacity to manufacture and provide guns must scale with the population, and a small arms manufacturing infrastructure is necessary now to supply 300 million Americans with the access to firearms that the Constitution deems necessary for the US to remain a free state. Otherwise liberty diminishes because fewer guns wind up in fewer hands. The Second Amendment does very much depend on the existence that industry, because if the government were to allow small arms manufacturing to fail, it would be de facto abridging the people's right to keep and bear arms. It's the only industry that has to exist in the US, by fiat.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoGuns are almost a drug to the fading significance (psychologically, economically, politically) of the middle class white male. It's phallic, it makes you feel powerful and safe, it goes boom, and it is intimately tied to the mythos of the United States of America (well, and the Confederate States of America). The amount of guns purchased by "gun nuts" reminds me of the stats on alcohol consumption: something like 80% of alcohol is consumed by alcoholics. So you can mobilize a very rabid base politically. Also, the gun manufacturers are tied in with the military and the diplomatic powers that be of the US (aka THE power brokers of the US government and the world).
- bumby 5y ago>You just don't have the same intersection of identity politics, culture and even religion with any other industry I think this kind of monolithic homogenous group is fiction. I hear the same thing from other people about tech. Both sentiments lack a nuanced perspective.