7 ms·
Judge rejects Purdue Pharma's $4.5B opioid settlement
- latch 5y agoDupe from a few hours ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29586740 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29586740
- starklevnertz 5y agoCan anyone explain why opioids are still being sold and prescribed?
- foxhop 5y agoA large portion of the population is addicted and the street alternatives have a habit of killing poeple.
- mousetree 5y agoThere are people who still have legitimate need for pain medication
- skywal_l 5y agoBut what are the the criteria to decide legitimacy of those needs? Pain is a symptom. It is your body signaling a problem. Indeed, sometimes, there are no solution to those problems but I doubt that all those who got prescribed opioids and got addicted didn't have an underlying solvable problem. If you are obese because you eat too much and your knees hurt, the solution is not an opioid. The whole discourse about pain being a condition that must be addressed is nefarious. Except in some pretty rare case (like terminal illness), pain is a symptom for which the healthcare organizations must find the root cause of and treat properly. Using expedient like opioids is a recipe for failure and a problem of that only the medical community can address. Serious introspection for those in charge of healthcare system in the US (and many other countries) is necessary. Also, serious failures of the FDA for labeling opioids as not addictive and putting the breaks on fixing it for years.
- najqh 5y agoThere are lots of illnesses that cause pain for which we have no fix, just palliative care. Not everybody is a fat guy with sore knees.
- oneoff786 5y agoYou seem to have made up the example of obese knees with no prior knowledge of what actually causes opioid prescription as evidence that it “might” not have good foundations. You realize that’s backwards right? Throwing out a made up example with no idea if it’s representative is just distracting. This entire post would be better reduced to “what are the most common reasons for legitimate opioid prescription”
- op00to 5y agoThat wouldn’t let the poster signal that he’s better than others.
- donkeyd 5y ago> I doubt that all those who got prescribed opioids and got addicted didn't have an underlying solvable problem. The US health care system is set up to cause exactly these kinds of issues. If you're in pain because of a bad hip, if you're uninsured, it may be much cheaper to just buy pain killers in stead of getting surgery. Once you get used to the pills, the pain is even worse if you stop taking them and might get withdrawals. Opioids are indispensable in cancer treatment and after many surgeries. In some cases they can be used to combat chronic pain or leading up to surgery. But you're right, they shouldn't be a replacement. If the US wants to fix this epidemic, just decreasing sales of opioids won't be enough, they'll have to provide the alternative. If people can't get affordable health care, they'll get affordable pain killers.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoOpioids are also prescribed for short term healing from major surgery, of which there is no root cause beyond having major surgery or other painful injury.
- alienchow 5y agoFentanyl is used in epidurals, for one.
- hermes8329 5y agoIt's used in all sorts of surgical procedures. I've had it a few times, used as a relatively minor painkiller under those circumstances. Which sounds crazy considering how much news is about how strong it is. But it works well in those controlled circumstances
- aaronmdjones 5y agoYou would have been given micrograms of Fentanyl. Certainly not a milligram, and certainly not 2mg, which will probably kill you. For comparison, you require more than 10 times as much Heroin to do that. This illustrates it pretty well; a lethal dose of Heroin (left) and Fentanyl (right): https://www.statnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Heroin-Fentanyl-vials-NHSPFL-768x432.jpg https://www.statnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Heroin-F... This is why it's been in the news and why you've read about how strong and dangerous it is. Usage in a medical setting is much safer because they have a known purity and precise dispensing and dosage schemes; something you won't find and can't achieve on the street.
- Tuna-Fish 5y agoFentanyl that you get in an OR and the "fentanyl" on the streets are actually two different chemicals. The street drug "fentanyl" is actually carfentanil, which is about 100 times more potent that fentanyl (or about 5000 times more potent than heroin). It is favored by criminals because when it's highly concentrated, you can fit ~the same amount of doses in a suitcase that with heroin would take a 20ft container. That suitcase, when bought from a legitimate Chinese pharmaceutical manufacturer, will also cost very little. Then if you can smuggle it into the states, you can run a billion-dollar drug empire from it, and never have to smuggle in anything again. This is why all supply-side measures against opiates are never going to work again. There are already enough of them in the hands of criminals in the US to cover the demand for decades, if not centuries. It's also why "fentanyl" on the street is so deadly. When the active ingredient is so potent and arrives concentrated, if the dilution process is even a little uneven, a single dose can easily be accidentally a 100 times more potent than you expect it to be. Even if you use other drugs, never use street fentanyl for any reason.
- ceejayoz 5y agoBecause they can be safe and effective for treating some conditions if used cautiously. Not every opiate has the issues OxyContin does.
- i000 5y agoOxyContin is not significantly more (or less) addictive or dangerous than other opiates. The problem with it is that it has been marketed by Purdue as 'safe', and that it is over-prescribed. I recommend the book Pharma by Gerald Posner, which goes into this in excruciating detail - but well worth a read.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIn its original formulation, the extended release oxycontin could be easily crushed without losing much potency. Other opiates have long had measures to combat this; fentanyl, for example, is frequently prescribed in patch form; extended-release morphine turns to an unusable gel if you crush it. Purdue's sales practices are important, yes, but the impact all this has had on pain patients is severe; attitudes like "why is fentanyl legal" and the comment that started this thread are hurting people with real medical needs.
- jasode 5y ago>Can anyone explain why opioids are still being sold and prescribed? If you take a look at the various alternatives for pain medication: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analgesic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analgesic ... you'll see that every pain drug has tradeoffs and opioids are still often the "best" solution even though it has potential for abuse and addiction. - acetaminophen/aspirin like Tylenol/Excedrin and ibuprofen like Advil are not addictive but they can only treat mild pain - local anesthesia can eliminate sensation of severe pain but it only lasts a few hours and also causes localized numbness and paralysis. This means you're not functional. So hypothetically trying to use it for knee pain will mean the person can't even walk around. The ineffectiveness of alternatives means doctors and patients will keep relying on opioids until science comes up with something better.
- tialaramex 5y agoThe problem was never that they don't work the problem was that they're addictive. So since they do work this means it remains appropriate to prescribe them, it just isn't appropriate to give them to everybody to pop one every day before work and say it's "non-addictive". Drugs that work but have a terrible reputation are almost always still available. For example Thalidomide works, but it causes birth defects. Well, if you're a 45 year old man and the doctor can fix what's wrong with you using Thalidomide, what do you care about birth defects? You get a lecture about why child-bearing age women must under no circumstances take this drug, and then you're issued a prescription. If you were a young woman, and there was no other option, you'd get an even sterner lecture, explaining that you absolutely must not become pregnant while taking this drug, that the best way to not become pregnant is to not have sex, but that if you're going to have sex you absolutely must prevent pregnancy, and if you get pregnant you must immediately stop using Thalidomide and come see a doctor... and then you're issued a prescription. The main exception is drugs that had powerful societal bias (often driven by racism or sexism) against them, which might get outlawed even though if doctors were allowed to they'd probably sometimes prescribe them. In the UK these are "Schedule 1" drugs and it requires a specific government license to even test what they do.
- eterm 5y ago> You get a lecture It's stronger than that, you get a three page consent form that you sign to say that, for instance, you won't get anyone pregnant.
- GeekyBear 5y agoWe learned the lesson that opioids are too addictive to be used to treat everyday pain back in the 1970's. However, Purdue Pharma's claim to fame with opioids was that their time release formulation was not addictive, so unlike traditional opioids these could be safely used on a daily basis. Obviously, this claim was fraudulent. Opioids still have their place, for treating terminal cancer patients, for instance. Short term use after a catastrophic event is still warranted.
- sidewndr46 5y ago
- S_A_P 5y agoAs someone who had major surgery a few months ago I am glad they are for sale and prescribed. No I am not taking opioids now but in the few days after surgery they kept me mostly pain free. Perdue deserves to be punished. Opioids are a public health crisis when abused. That doesn’t mean that they don’t have legitimate uses.
- simon_o 5y agoWhy are Americans so ... feeble? In most other places of the world, pain is simply expected and accepted after a surgery.
- donkeyd 5y agoBecause they're extremely effective in treating extreme pain. In some cases, this is necessary because pain limits recovery. Use of them needs to be managed extremely well though and when that doesn't happen it's easy to get addicted.
- odiroot 5y agoThey are very very important for late stage cancer patients.
- jeltz 5y agoBecause they work. When I had a relatively mild hip fracture (greater throcanter broken clean off) they enabled me to walk and sleep. I went off them as quickly as I could and switched to paracetamol only, but the first week would have been hell without them. Sure I could have survived on week of pain but one week of opiates has no risk of addiction.
- sfifs 5y agoOne of my family members gets terrible debilitating migraines. When they get it, the whole day gets lost, vomiting, dehydration, maybe a trip to urgent care. An opioid based tablet they are prescribed for migraine cuts this to about 2 hours. The tablet is issued only by the clinic itself or in a major hospital pharmacy and you can't buy it in regular pharmacies. The problem in US is lack of controls and perverse profit incentives in the American healthcare business.
- sniperjoe360 5y agoHi, I prescribe opiates often as a cancer doc. Opiates act on the central nervous system and decrease the perception of pain but don't address the pain itself. They are quite useful in the short term as bridging therapy (a few days to weeks) analgesia while you work as hard and as quickly as possible to address the physical cause of pain. On the same token, there are great alternatives too. For musculoskeletal pain, a combination of 1000mg Tylenol and 800mg Ibuprofen all at once has efficacy close to that of low dose opiates. This regimen however carries increased kidney and liver injury. There are also less addictive opiates such as tramadol (rate of addiction 1 in 100,000). But again, all of the above is simply to mask the pain. The most important aspect is quick and vigorous pain source control.
- hansthehorse 5y agoOpioids took me from suicide level pain to just tolerable pain over 6 months after I had a half golf ball sized hole scooped out of the base of my tongue due to cancer. It was a bad week when I stopped but it's doable. Opioids have a place.
- dstick 5y agoGood. For those that haven't watched them yet, there are 3 John Oliver segments on the subject that will back up the "Good." statement: Opioids https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pdPrQFjo2o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pdPrQFjo2o Opioids II https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qCKR6wy94U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qCKR6wy94U Opioids III (this one focuses 100% on the Sacklers) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uaCaIhfETsM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uaCaIhfETsM
- PMan74 5y agoThe Pharmacist on Netflix also worth a watch https://www.netflix.com/ie/title/81002576 https://www.netflix.com/ie/title/81002576
- diimdeep 5y agoAlso https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dopesick_(miniseries) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dopesick_(miniseries)
- kriro 5y agoJust watched part 3 and I've gotta say, I love the website stuff. "You gotta buy the .com"
- fallingknife 5y agoDoctors prescribe drug -> pharmacy dispenses drug -> pharmacy orders from manufacturer. All I hear about is pharmacies and manufacturers getting sued, but why not doctors? Why do they seem to get off the hook when they are the main cause. Sure, Perdue marketed it to doctors (and I don't even see a way that pharmacies were responsible at all), but "I was manipulated by marketing" isn't a convincing defense from an expert.
- gostsamo 5y agoAlso, the producers pay he doctors and provide different insentives to make them prescribe their drugs.
- fallingknife 5y agoEncourage, not make. And that makes all the difference. If you take the money, you take the responsibility with it.
- gostsamo 5y agoSo, giving the money is not part of the problem? The responsibility of one of the sides does not relieve the other one from it.
- scotty79 5y agoI think doctors were directly lied to that those drugs are non-addictive.
- stathibus 5y agoThis may have been a valid argument some decades ago. Greedy doctors killed my aunt by selling her all the drugs she asked for. This is commonplace in the US.
- joshgel 5y agoSorry that happened to your aunt. Doctors aren’t reimbursed for prescribing medications directly (except chemotherapy infusions). Was the physician selling the medication directly? That’s not commonplace. Clinicians may financially benefit from not refusing their patients requests and thus losing the patient to another doctor that will acquiesce. But that’s a tricky topic to untangle.
- GeekyBear 5y agoI've got to say that I am pleasantly surprised, since it was pretty obvious that the fix was in. The Feds and forty-three states had already approved a settlement that that only required the family return a fraction of their ill-gotten gains, and stripped the victims of their right to seek redress in the courts. If ever there was a case that called for piercing the corporate veil and clawing back all of the ill-gotten earnings, this would be it.
- moron4hire 5y ago> Steve Miller, chair of the Purdue board of directors, said in an emailed statement that the ruling "will delay, and perhaps end, the ability of creditors, communities, and individuals to receive billions in value to abate the opioid crisis." > "These funds are needed now more than ever as overdose rates hit record-highs, and we are confident that we can successfully appeal this decision and deliver desperately needed funds to the communities and individuals suffering in the midst of this crisis," Miller added. I mean, if that's what you're concerned about, you can just do that now, without a court decision. You can just spend money on opiod addiction relief. You fucking muppet.
- 323 5y ago
- desdiv 5y agoTo be fair, it could two (mostly) disjoint groups voicing those two conflicting opinions.
- vmception 5y agothey're not even conflicting opinions. demanding consumer protection and the consequence for undermining it only exists in legalization frameworks.
- BrazzVuvuzela 5y ago> I find these two positions very hard to re-conciliate. Why do you need to reconcile them? "HN" is not a person and does not need to have consistent beliefs. "HN" is a loose association of independent people who believe different things and choose to comment on different matters. If you think some individual is being hypocritical, take it up with them.
- MexicanMonkey 5y agoIMO these two positions are no hard to re-conciliate. The thing about "drugs should be legal and available" is that it should go hand-in-hand with honest information about those drugs. What evil pharma companies do is lie and misrepresent information about those drugs. The amount of incorrect marketing done about OxyContin is just insane.
- GeekyBear 5y ago> On another hand, HN demands extreme punishment against a pharma company which produced opioids. They didn't just produce opioids. They fraudulently claimed that the opioids they produced were non-addictive. >Purdue admits it illegally and misleadingly marketed its opioids, including “to more than 100 health care providers whom the company had good reason to believe were diverting opioids” for misuse; illegally paid doctors to prescribe more opioids; and took part in other fraudulent and illegal practices. Purdue says it did all of this between 2007 and at least 2017 — after a separate guilty plea in 2007 forced the company to pay more than $600 million in fines. https://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/10/business/11drug-web.html https://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/10/business/11drug-web.html https://www.vox.com/2020/10/21/21526868/purdue-pharma-oxycontin-opioid-epidemic-department-of-justice https://www.vox.com/2020/10/21/21526868/purdue-pharma-oxycon...
- savant_penguin 5y agoShould you be free to use whatever drug you want? Do doctors hold any responsibility over getting you addicted by drugs they prescribe? (Aren't doctors the experts?) Now that marijuana is legal, should you sue the legal stores if you get addicted?
- sofixa 5y ago> Do doctors hold any responsibility over getting you addicted by drugs they prescribe? (Aren't doctors the experts? In this case doctors wrongly prescribed ( when it wasn't necessary or in too high doses) a drug for personal profit. They're guilty, and so is the company that paid them to do that and kept bullshit marketing reassuring doctors and patients everything is ok.
- arkades 5y agoI keep hearing this, but there is no mechanism I am aware of for a doctor to see a cent related to prescription of outpatient medication. What’s the purported mechanism by which docs were making money on this?
- drekk 5y agoPurdue would give them kickbacks, vacations, etc. as part of their marketing outreach. It's not like the doctors made commission on every pill
- sofixa 5y agoIf you keep hearing this, maybe take a look at all the despicable bullshit that Purdue have been caught in. If you like the video format, you can start with John Oliver's "Opiods" episodes.
- HeyZuess 5y ago> Should you be free to use whatever drug you want? Your body, your choice? There are many ways to answer this, and no matter how it is answered there will always be a group of people who disagree. This is why as a society we have a framework for making those decisions which sometimes gets it right and sometimes gets it wrong. If we legalized all drugs and let people do what they want, do we stop a 10 year old from taking meth, after all it their choice. I think it would be absurd to have 0 restrictions, but that would go against the concept of being able to make free choices. > Do doctors hold any responsibility over getting you addicted by drugs they prescribe? (Aren't doctors the experts?) If they prescribed them outside of the boundaries of their professional framework, then yes. > Now that marijuana is legal, should you sue the legal stores if you get addicted? You buying marijuana intentionally is a little different from being under the mindset that a licensed medical professional (and health system) is acting within your best interest. Part of this problem also is Purdue mislead people on the addictiveness of their product. However in saying the above, there is a lot more to this than just supplying a drug. They broke other laws such as the anti kickback.
- kaminar 5y agoBunch of addicts. The lot of ya.
- dannyphantom 5y agoHmm. There are five drug classes for controlled substances and oxycontin was always a class 2 narcotic which carries the second highest risk of being abused. I don't think most doctors/pharmacist really bought into the idea there was zero chance of abuse. I think in the beginning Richard Sackler the best intentions (by Creating a successful drug and racking in a bunch of money and there is no crime in that)but ended getting in way over his head leading to Purdue spiral out of control. I don't believe he created the opiod pandemic but he certainly played a role in it. But as Al Pacinos character says in scarface, "You need people like me so you can point your fckn’ fingers and say, “That’s the bad guy.” And that guy happened to he Richard Sackler
- hilbert42 5y ago"I don't think most doctors/pharmacist really bought into the idea there was zero chance of abuse." APPENDIX TO WILLIAM S. BURROUGHS Naked Lunch : Burroughs quote in The British Journal of Addiction, Vol 53, No.2 "LETTER FROM A MASTER ADDICT TO DANGEROUS DRUGS (August 3rd, 1956. Venice (p. 189, Paladin 1992 ed.):" "I have Taken morphine for acute pain. Any opiate that effectively relieves pain to an equal degree relieves withdrawal symptoms. The conclusion is obvious: Any opiate that relieves pain is habit forming, and the more effectively it relieves pain the more habit forming it is. ..." William Burroughs. There is no argument about this and there hasn't been any for about at least a century or more. This is medicine/pharmacy 101 stuff. All those who thought/think otherwise are fools and should not be anywhere near such decision-making processes. Those qualified in pharmacy or medicine and involved in the pushing and peddling of oxycontin had to know EXACTLY what they were doing - that's to say the serious damage they were doing to patients' health not to mention the deaths - the 65-year old Burroughs quote being the scientific orodoxy in hundreds of medical and pharmacopeia texts. Burroughs, an opiate addict for 15 years, is one of the most articulate drug users to have written on the matter of opiate addiction and the fact that his descriptions of the addictiveness of opioids has been widely published for decades in the popular press meant that not just the professions knew the details intimately but also that everyone did. Nothing that Purdue or the Shacklers can say or do can absolve them from their responsibility for the deaths of over 800,000 people - a truly staggering number. The original settlement was a fucking farce of the first order. Why the Shacklers weren't stripped of everything they own then locked up and the key thrown away simply amazes me. What's wrong with US justice that it can fail so terribly? Here, justice is nothing other than a joke - a joke run and told by the accused. Moreover, what went wrong with the medical profession and the regulators? Why was the FDA AWOL on this matter for decades - a matter with very well known and long-honed parameters? After all, the matter of narcotics and addiction is the subject of international treaties. We all know the issues and yet it still happened. The Purdue, Sacklers and oxycontin matter is one of the greatest failures of public health of all time: a tragedy of unprecedented proportions - and as far as I can determine, no one - except the dead - have paid any penalty whatsoever.