4 ms·
Standard internet discourse. Numbers are bad - "See everyone, things are fucked. I told you so." (which is what this post is about) Numbers are good - "Meh, I
by paxys 5y ago
Standard internet discourse.
Numbers are bad - "See everyone, things are fucked. I told you so." (which is what this post is about)
Numbers are good - "Meh, I never trust the underlying data anyways. It is all meaningless."
- kelseyfrog 5y agoI was being a snark, but I would still genuinely like to hear why someone would feel confident in the method.
- Aunche 5y agoIt's the consumer price index. Rent is consumed. A house is an asset. You can sell it at a profit. Your intuition is correct in that it's not quite that simple in the real world. Housing is already the least liquid asset, and people get an emotional attachment to their homes, so they often die without cashing out on their homes. As a result, they feel poorer than they should as suggested by CPI. IMO, the problem isn't the CPI. The market is just fundamentally distorted because the government pumps money into real estate into subsidized loans.
- harry8 5y agoA. Here's a wildly understated measure (like for like equivalent cost of housing systematically under-estimates inflation as defined as the increase in what you have to spend). This other accurately measured thing (wages) is not keeping up even with that biased measure. Argument: It sort of is keeping up with the real thing (what you have to spend because we'll just take cpi) if you squint at a particular period? Actually it isn't, it's still being systematically underestimated. CPI is a crap measure of what people actually face in increase of what they have to spend. What you can actually buy, the purchasing power of wages has not been going up. People aren't being fooled into be angry and bitter. Talk to them. Listen to what they say about their constraints in life. Ideally find some people you like for whom you can feel empathy with their situation.