9 ms·
What is a Bitcoin worth?
- Mohdmusa 5y agoOh hackers please don't crypto a special like bitcon lunar crush and savemooon
- anonymousiam 5y agoFTFA: "Now, so far, Bitcoin has not performed well as money. Quick recap: money issued by central banks, fiat money, acts as a ‘store of value’ – it preserves the spending power of income and wealth, so that you can be confident that a pound, say, will buy about as much in a year’s time as it would today." Heh. The above assumes that world governments will not collude to inflate their currency. Full disclosure: I have no cryptocurrency assets whatsoever, and never have.
- thehappypm 5y agoWorld governments are panicking because inflation is around 6% when compared to a year of deep pandemic restrictions. 6% is a joke for crypto, both up and down.
- botev 5y agoInflation is probably around 15% lol
- mattwilsonn888 5y agosomething something price discovery something something emerging market
- 3np 5y agoIt doesn’t even have to be collusion. There are strong incentives for export nations to devalue their currency. The US has been accusing/criticizing China of doing so, for example. It’s a race to the bottom. The existence of BTC as a deflationary asset is a threat to the power of central banks to keep their economy under control; there is a way out for individuals and businesses.
- lottin 5y agoWhen a country to devalues its currency it sells its production to the rest of the world at a lower price and it buys production from the rest of world at a higher price, compared to before. This is the opposite of a "strong incentive".
- 3np 5y agoSome countries will profit more from that - the reduced global purchasing power is worth it to sell their goods at more competitive prices. This is not a novel idea and is found in literature. Hence the qualifier.
- lottin 5y agoLet me get this straight. If I'm getting paid less per hour, this is good for me because it means I'm selling the stuff I produce at a more competitive price?
- 3np 5y agoLess in global terms, more in local terms. > A weak domestic currency makes a nation's exports more competitive in global markets, and simultaneously makes imports more expensive. Higher export volumes spur economic growth, while pricey imports also have a similar effect because consumers opt for local alternatives to imported products. This improvement in the terms of trade generally translates into a lower current account deficit (or a greater current account surplus), higher employment, and faster GDP growth. The stimulative monetary policies that usually result in a weak currency also have a positive impact on the nation's capital and housing markets, which in turn boosts domestic consumption through the wealth effect. https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/090215/3-reasons-why-countries-devalue-their-currency.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/090215/3-rea... https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm751 https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm751
- lottin 5y ago
- alfiedotwtf 5y ago> Heh. The above assumes that world governments will not collude to inflate their currency. ... or default. It will be interesting after the midterms next year if Biden ends up a lame duck President, and Mitch manages to block any further raising of the US debt ceiling. Everyone says it's practically impossible for America to default given its debt denominated in U.S. dollars, but blocking its ability to borrow more so it's unable to pay bond coupons will trigger a default. I wouldn't discount cryptocurrencies as a store of value just yet.
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoCryptocurrencies can default as well, when a glaring vulnerability is discovered and the blockchain forked. It's happened before and it'll happen again.
- tata71 5y agoFork of which chain?
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoEthereum, at least?
- landemva 5y agoMitch is part of the club. He may grandstand and then he will ease the spending through.
- rfd4sgmk8u 5y ago50% of the value of everything on earth. The other half is the stuff. The paintings from 400 years ago, the mansions, apartments, houses and buildings, all the stonks of equity representing human enterprise, the options and futures on those stonks, the commodities, like the wheat and gold and cows and iron. the energy sources and generators, the oil, the gas, uranium, the solar rays and the wind that blows. the heat from the earth. the promises, the debts, cryptotokens -- all the way to the 4th and 5th level+ derivative liquidity reward pool stake locked ponzischemes. the dollars and euros and yuan in the pockets and databases around the world. Effectively, infinity / 21 million. $100k? $1M? $10M? $100M? Infinity Dollars. Infinity Euros. Infinity Yuan. or not :-)
- gfodor 5y agoA bear case for Bitcoin in 120 years based on the single aspect of the loss of mining rewards. Legit funny!
- mrorbitman 5y agoI think raising this concern is a great first step into seriously thinking about bitcoin. Learning about bitcoin is a string of epiphanies and concerns, much like the actual bitcoin price chart over time. No one gets to "maxi" without first going through all the ups and downs and common questions and misunderstandings
- anonporridge 5y agoFirst step for an individual who has given very little thought to bitcoin, sure. It's definitely one of the more legit, systemic criticisms of the system's ability to be self sustaining long term. First step for this specific concern at all? Definitely not. It's been raised and debated for years.
- Lucadg 5y agoI think going maxi is a negative rather than a positive. It's when you go too far in the journey and seek for simplicity. Crypto is a complicated and fast moving world, so it's understandable that some people become religious (as in stop accepting new evidence) and tribal. Still, it's always good trying to keep an open mind.
- rlt 5y agoModern “Bitcoin Maximalism” has similarities to religion, but I think it’s possible to independently arrive at the conclusions that there needs to be a single dominant cryptocurrency, and for various reasons Bitcoin has the best chance of being it.
- Osiris 5y agoAnd a lot of reasons it's terrible. Front and center is the number of transactions per second it can process. It's no where near being able to handle the volume of transactions that happen around the world.
- dnamlin 5y agoIMO a much more-thorough analysis of the essential point discussed here: https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-security-modeling/ https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-security-modeling/
- anonporridge 5y agoAlso this one, https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-energy/ https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-energy/
- crazypython 5y agoEven if fees are $50, it's still useful as a competitor to ACH and other payment systems. Commercial bank to bank transfers costing $50 in total fees isn't unusual. I heard the Fed is working on lowering bank transfer fees. > For one thing, it’s likely that transaction fees will rocket, as miners try to replace revenues no longer provided by the emission of new Bitcoins. Difficulty readjusts every 2016 blocks, changing money needed to mine a block. Congestion would be temporary. > The hope was that by having a hard-coded limit on the number of Bitcoins ever to be produced, the value of a Bitcoin couldn’t be inflated away by an endless supply of new coins. Technically not true, the code was written incorrectly so as to trigger undefined behavior / underflow, allowing far more than 21 million bitcoins. This was corrected in a non-controversial hard fork.
- vmurthy 5y ago> Commercial bank to bank transfers costing $50 in total fees isn't unusual This is interesting. What amounts are we talking about here? What would be the equivalent tx costs if BitCoin were used do you know?
- crazypython 5y ago$50 is for wire transfers, usually used for amounts above $1000. $35 for sender, $15 for receiver. The equivalent transaction costs would be $0.53- Bitcoin fees don’t increase if the amount is higher: https://mempool.space/ https://mempool.space/ (and it works on weekends and arrives in an hour) If Bitcoin means “be your own bank,” Bitcoin is a decent bank. You can even get a trustless, psuedonymous Visa debit card with Lightning: https://paywithmoon.com https://paywithmoon.com
- mrorbitman 5y agonot to mention lightning, which is where a majority of transactions would actually be occurring.
- lmm 5y ago> Difficulty readjusts every 2016 blocks, changing money needed to mine a block. Congestion would be temporary. The number of transactions per block is fixed (IIRC it's about 6 transactions/second), so transaction fees will always rise to the level that the world is willing to pay for 6 transactions/second at.
- ericls 5y agoThat's too complicated, the worth of a bitcoin can be defined in the following two ways: 1. the price the last person paid to buy a bitcoin 2. the price the next person is willing to pay to buy a bitcoin Until human beings figure out the Truth of the universe or at least the meaning of life, the word "value" means nothing. We don't deserve to use the word "value", because we haven't being able to define it.
- tptacek 5y agoThat argument proves too much, obviously.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 5y agoIMO this article actually does hit on something that is frequently missed: the chain is worthless if there are regular re-orgs The chain's security is primarily paid by the block subsidy The block subsidy trends to zero. Either the fees need to increase or the security property falls away and 1 Bitcoin = 2 Bitcoin
- tromp 5y ago> The chain's security is primarily paid by the block subsidy > The block subsidy trends to zero. These statements are misleading. As the block subsidy trends to zero, the chain's security will be primarily paid by transaction fees. This will likely happen within two decades, in which the block subsidy will diminish by a factor 2^5 = 32. > Either the fees need to increase or the security property falls away The security will diminish, but not fall away completely as long as bitcoin maintains a constant backlog of high-fee paying transactions.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 5y agoTotally agree, the key insight is that Bitcoin in the limit e.g. 50 years from now will need regular high txn fees to stay secure, we've only seen high txn fees periods twice in 12 years. In the limit Bitcoin either is a chain that you can use for under 60 bucks a txn (two of which are needed for each lighting network channel) and it has meh security or it costs greater than 60 bucks a txn and is like an extra expensive wire txn system and used as financial infra. As long as the problem is somewhere in the future it is in the present because it's all about speculation & speculation depends on future value. There are two other things to think of in this thought experiment: other cryptocurrency, they can set higher subsidy, use different L2 solutions And dark miners. Even if bitcoin's security parameter is stable is it goes down then miners will turn off and try to sell their hardware at a discount. If that happens >50% then there's a persistent threat that a single actor bought it all and is waiting to turn it on.
- jetsetgo 5y ago80% of dollar ever in circulation was printed in last 2 years. Any alternative to dollar is incredibly valued. People are underestimating crypto. There are here to stay, including Bitcoin.
- phase5 5y agoThe guy has absolutely no idea what he's writing about. He lost me at: money issued by central banks, fiat money, acts as a ‘store of value’ – it preserves the spending power of income and wealth, so that you can be confident that a pound, say, will buy about as much in a year’s time as it would today.
- anonporridge 5y agoThe key term there is "a year's time". That's generally true for most fiat money in stable countries, but it becomes an absolutely terrible store of value for anything longer than a few years.
- gonzo41 5y agoThat's why most money kept with banks is kept in interest bearing accounts to at least keep up with inflation (obviously things have been a bit off kilter since the GFC and covid). Or that pound quickly moves into circulation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- shimonabi 5y agoI've found through personal experience that arguing with crypto people is like arguing with religious people. There is absolutely NO argument in the world that could make them doubt their own belief that cryptocurrencies are the future of money. Nassim Taleb says that Bitcoin is worth exactly 0.
- mattwilsonn888 5y agoWhat could convince you, as a skeptic, that crypto currencies are a technological step forward and deliver value to humans?
- kelseyfrog 5y agoAt least or better carbon parity than existing systems, feasible transaction rollbacks when mandated by law. Sorry, not willing to accept these bugs as features. /gen
- tata71 5y agoLoopring on ETH, Nano (To your first point, not your second.)
- lmm 5y agoA use case that delivers positive value (i.e. not just enabling crime). I found some of the cryptokitties-style experiments interesting, but not when every transaction costs $50 (and the security of the chain only works if the underlying "coin" has value, so that seems inherent and unavoidable).
- mudlus 5y agoI suspect most people won't understand the value until they immediately need the privilege of using it--a privilege which anyone with a computer has, but no one is required to exercise (unlike every other national currency).
- 5y ago
- joelthelion 5y agoZero: - It does not bring back dividends - It does not work well as a currency - It's not a good storage of value (too easy to get stolen) The only thing it's mildly good at is enabling otherwise illegal transactions, such as ransomware.
- gonzo41 5y agoIt's got some use as a commodity of speculation for gamble-vestors and for unscrupulous billionaires. I wouldn't be happy about my retirement savings being in or dependent on bitcoin.
- trixie_ 5y agoIt works amazing. I can send large sums of value across the world, in minutes, without going through a bank. Moving money any other way (ACH/wire) feels primitive by comparison. Plus often you have to use a bank as an intermediary which doubles the send time - not anymore. This goes for mineable crypto and stable coins alike. Mineable crypto has the added benefit of controlled inflation which is amazing for storing value without the rug being pulled out from under you. Easy to get stolen? You can literally store millions of dollars yourself with a 12 word pass code that never touches the internet. Given how irresponsible the government has been printing trillions of dollars, dollars are not a store of value. Stocks and real estate are good, like crypto it’s about diversification. All asset classes will fluctuate. Crytpo is still early days. But as a liquid store of value really nothing beats it. Inflation controlled, fast to transfer, easy to verify, able to hold yourself, zero weight, decentralized, etc.. <- THIS is the intrinsic value of crytpo and what makes it valuable. Show me another form of money with better properties than these and I’ll use it.
- wruza 5y agoI can send large sums of value across the world, in minutes, without going through a bank Oh, I can do that too. The problem is when I’m on the receiving side, because most goods are sold in fiat and I have a hard time explaining where this large sum of fiat came from to unfreeze my bank account. You’re talking like bitcoin is a uncontrolled sea, and now that it’s there, it’s so easy to send a boat from Asia to North America. Problem is, North America is US and Canada, both running their border protection services. And there is just nothing in the sea itself.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iza230 5y ago“According to all known laws of aviation, there is no way that a bee should be able to fly. Its wings are too small to get its fat little body off the ground. The bee, of course, flies anyways. Because bees don't care what humans think is impossible.” -bee movie
- waynesonfire 5y agoIts worth the electricity it takes to mine the remaining coins and support the transactions.
- Mohdmusa 5y agoDon't hacker please
- peter-m80 5y agoScarcity? I can go and buy Bitcoin right now but I cannot buy a PS5. 21 Million btc? Bitcoins are divisible so if the unit is considered the smallest division, there are 2.100.000.000.000.000 units. What happens when the last btc is mined? Well, storing and shipping gold bars is also expensive and that doesn't make gold worthless
- mattwilsonn888 5y agoYou're mixing up liquidity and scarcity. PS5's are not liquid and they are not divisible. They are also not durable or easily transferable. Scarcity does not give Bitcoin value - there could be a massive Bitcoin inflation even at any moment and the value of the whole network in total would remain the same, its the security guarantees and unrelenting openness that give it value.
- js8 5y agoThe assumption that purpose of (non-crypto) currency (fiat or not, that's beside the point) is to store value (rather than facilitate exchange) is wrong. It's basically wishful thinking. You cannot really "store" economic value without maintaining the productive capacity needed to counter its depreciation (due to laws of thermodynamics). As an extreme example, you cannot buy bread for 10 years today, keep it and then just eat it. Instead, you need "access" to a bakery and a wheat plantation. So the value is really stored in the functioning society, which maintains the production capacity. (And thus society is what you have to care about, to libertarians' dismay.) Money (currency) is just a convenient abstraction, an accounting trick, to keep track of one's share of the society's productive capacity. As an aside, if the production capacity of society decreases (e.g. due to war, or natural disaster, or underinvestment during COVID), you get an inflation because suddenly sum of all accounts (money) is greater than the total production capacity, and so your share in economy, expressed in your savings, also shrinks (in absolute terms).
- tzfld 5y ago> The only real intrinsic feature that Bitcoin has is scarcity => the value couldn’t be inflated away => If it is true that there may be some inherent value in Bitcoin. Not sure about this reasoning. I have a piece of rock with a unique shape. There is no other piece of rock with this particular shape, so it's incredibly scarce. Still it doesn't mean it has any value.
- Gys 5y agoI do not own any crypto, NFTs, etc. To me, the only reasonable explanation for the success of Bitcoin is the story behind it. A mathemetical, virtual thing, created by some mysterious guy, challenging the powers to be, 'mined' by underground groups all over the world. That is just so cool ;-) I never saw the meme culture coming and still am not sure if it is temporarely or something that will stay. It gives value to things that have (had) no clear value previously. Their only value comes from stories, discussions around it, like GameStop on r/wallstreetbets and NFTs. Most people do not understand and do not want to understand. They just want to be part of something cool and at the same time become rich ;-)
- mattwilsonn888 5y agoIt should be of interest to fence sitters that skeptics exactly like yourself often take pride in their lack of understanding and use that to express how obvious it is that the whole thing is a sham. What really spurred me to go all in a year ago was reading the best and brightest from HackerNews absolutely tearing into 'crypto' and seeing clearly that they didn't know what they were talking about. Made good profits, and took an optimistic approach to learning about real problems crypto has, meaning I had a good idea of what new projects were going in the right direction. You're only contribution to the list of issues is that "it feels cool," and "some people bought it without fully understanding it," which I fail to see your authority in saying as you have only just done the inverse: gathered a superficial understanding and not bought. So far it seems you're astrology has picked the wrong horse.
- selestify 5y agoThat's a good point. Why is it you think that people on this site are so irrationally offended by crypto?