14 ms·
Incorrectly deleted from Facebook? Getting back on might take connections
- in3d 5y agoThey simply should do paid-by-minute support and make it a profit center. Stop pretending that their service isn’t about making money from users or that they want to do free tech support. Everyone knows how big web companies make money by now, no need to keep up appearances.
- hakfoo 5y agoDidn't Yahoo do that to immense blowback? If you needed password resets or something, you had to sign up to a paid support tier?
- pushcx 5y agoConnections are pretty flaky, unfortunately. Every couple years Facebook bans my spouse's account for, I can only guess, having the last name spelled more phonetically as "Bot" instead of transliterated as "Bhat". (It helps Americans get a little closer to correct pronunciation). A friend who's worked there about ten years puts in a good word and it's unbanned. Unfortunately not this time, it's been two months now.
- protomyth 5y agoThey're also fairly regularly delete Native American accounts with English translations (which is there legal name) of Native names. These translations predate the internet.
- paulpauper 5y agolol it's both hard to delete your FB account but also to get it back
- Turing_Machine 5y ago"I wouldn't belong to any club that would have me as a member." -- Groucho Marx
- emerged 5y agoI guess you could delete it by purposefully making them hate you. But then they probably keep all your data and you can’t login to remove any of it.
- IntrepidWorm 5y agoYou can't remove it regardless. You gave Facebook rights to the data the minute it was uploaded.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoSome time ago I read the tip that if you send them a data protection request to either completely delete everything on you or unban you, they'll unban you, because option 1 is too hard for them...
- kingcharles 5y agoI found another way. Just get all your "friends" to hate you instead.
- wly_cdgr 5y agoJust make a new account bro lol
- jeromegv 5y agoThat’s the thing. They keep track of your IP and likely fingerprint your browser. It’s really not that easy.
- totony 5y agoFrom my experience they don't care. Pretty sure they know their system is flawed and instead of investing in support staff they let you create new accounts. There's maybe an exception if you spam a lot.
- devtul 5y agoFunny story, deleted my FB acct several years ago, then a couple months ago I found a group for my school and tried to reactivate my account but now it says I was banned. Silver lining is I won't be in FB again.
- adrianmonk 5y agoI'm in this boat with Instagram. My account is permanently banned, and I didn't do anything. And I mean that literally. I have never done anything with the account. I created it years ago, but I never got around to posting a photo or anything. It's just an account with no activity. When I try to login, I see this: > Your account has been permanently disabled because it didn't follow our Community Guidelines. This decision can't be reversed either because we've already reviewed it, or because 30 days have passed since your account was disabled. Learn more about why we disable accounts in our Community Guidelines. So, it's an issue of community guidelines, so what are those? Presumably this: https://help.instagram.com/477434105621119 https://help.instagram.com/477434105621119 Those guidelines are all about content, and of course I didn't post any. My next thought is maybe someone (like a spammer) took over my account and posted something bad. But I have a strong, machine-generated random password, so that seems unlikely. So I tried contacting support through the mobile app (since I can't through the web site), and a bot sent me a 5-digit number and asked me to reply with a photo of myself holding a piece of paper with that number. I did that and got no response. (But maybe because the ban is permanent I wasn't supposed to be able to contact support.)
- ivank 5y agoIt's probably because you had no activity. Someone may have run out of ideas for deleting bot accounts and wrote a query that caught idle accounts with no posts.
- prmph 5y agoThe exact same thing happened to me recently, and yet I had some activity, though not much. And there was absolutely no content in my account that could be construed as violating any terms of use. I posted pictures like once or twice a year. Suddenly my account was disabled, with instructions to send an image of myself holding up some code; but nothing has happened since I sent it.
- whymauri 5y agoI wonder if any due diligence is done on approximating good user impact from a hypothetical like this, or if they would just YOLO it.
- mattbee 5y agoYup, mine got deleted a couple of weeks before my 42nd birthday, as they had determined I was under 13. I'd only been on it a year. The form for uploading my ID didn't work, just said "Sorry, please try again later" until the deadline for appeals had passed. Tried all kinds of file formats. Absolutely no idea what triggered it, or what I could have done differently. Facebook is a once-a-week dumpster dive of community / friend news that I always follow up in other ways, so I'm investing even less in it this time round!
- LegitShady 5y agoi had twitter ask me for my drivers license abkjt an hour after making thr account and i just decided i preferred not sharing it with twitter and never worried about it again. bullet dodged and thx corpo for helping me make the right choice.
- lelandfe 5y agoIn September, IG deleted my account. No email, no warning. I lost an unbelievable amount of memories. To open a support ticket about it, I had to send in a photo of me holding up a sign with a captcha on it. Despite following up on the ticket 8 times, I still haven't even gotten a response back. Just miserable. Finally made a new account in October. That new account has been "temporarily blocked" 5 times so far. I've had to provide my phone number, a 360º video of my face, and more. I really don't know why Meta hates me.
- Radim 5y agoAnd yet you keep coming back? Fascinating. Of course I don't know your motivation, but your description sounds like some variant of the Stockholm Syndrome – an extreme form of domestication, an unwholesome dependency. Are these social sites that much a part of your identity?
- smugglerFlynn 5y agoI find it strange when people downplay network effects of facebook/instagram. It’s not as simple as switching to another brand of toothpaste. These platforms have huge network effect, so good luck trying to connect with your friends over another channel (which no one uses). Life will just go on without you. Social networks should be heavily regulated or forcefully decentralized. It’s not about the product anymore, it’s about society.
- 908B64B197 5y agoI'm starting to wonder if these ban appeals shouldn't simply be handled by small claims courts. Basically, the company has to have a human justify why it banned a fellow human. No response or no account reinstatement simply makes the company in contempt of court. If the company has a legitimate reason to ban it should be pretty easy to argue (this user posted this graphic content in exhibit A.)
- vinaypai 5y agoI'm no fan of Facebook, but I think this is pretty extreme. Other than laws barring discrimination against protected classes, nobody has a right to demand that any company provide them services.
- jlawson 5y agoYes they do have that right, if the company has no substitute, and if doing without it is a substantial impact on life. For example, the power company. The telephone company. A sole ISP with no local alternatives. A company that owns an important toll road near your house. Monopolistic social media companies. Etc.
- Karunamon 5y agoThey don't have that right now. There is no legal framework yet for demanding a social media company provide you an account. Many of us would like to see that changed.
- fredsmith42 5y agoIf you own a Quest VR headset and have purchased games, a ban means you cannot play or download them. I would hope that would be reasonable grounds for a suit in small claims court. If they make membership in the social network a requirement of using a product you purchased, that comes with responsibilities on their end too.
- 5y ago
- egberts1 5y agoI got Facebook-deleted for using a VoIP phone number. There were no Terms and Conditions against VoIP at the time. And no way back to Facebook.
- bserge 5y agoDeleted? More like liberated. Rejoice and never look back.
- drunkpotato 5y agoDeleted my Facebook account years ago, and no regrets.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoSame here! Have an Instagram for dog and a LinkedIn and that's my only social media. All the people I actually wanted to be friends with I'm still friends with.
- fknorangesite 5y agoThanks for letting us know.
- technothrasher 5y agoPerhaps we need an updated version of this article? https://www.theonion.com/area-man-constantly-mentioning-he-doesnt-own-a-televisi-1819565469 https://www.theonion.com/area-man-constantly-mentioning-he-d...
- Underphil 5y agoI don't understand how this is in any way relevant. This article is for people who do want to recover their account.
- sm4rk0 5y agoIt can remind/ecourage them about the plan B - why bother?
- edmcnulty101 5y agoWe really need an open source version of Facebook that is federated like Mastadon.
- wizzwizz4 5y agoYou mean https://friendi.ca https://friendi.ca? (Older than Mastodon, better privacy controls, supports more of the Fediverse.)
- 3np 5y agoThere is also the more IG-like Pixelfed (https://pixelfed.org/ https://pixelfed.org/) For those who don’t know, ActivityPub enables all of these (Mastodon, Pleroma, Pixelfed, Friendica, Misskey, etc) to work transparently between implementations and servers.
- iszomer 5y agoAnd a bit of a pain to separate and isolate yourself across it. I no longer have the inclination to blast myself everywhere on the intertubes. That era of "signing up for everything" is over. Deleted my FB account last year but rarely used it to begin with. Never linked my IG account with FB either but am waiting for a reasonable excuse to delete it as well.
- 3np 5y agoIf you want more fine-grained control over federation than Mastodon (which already has the basic knobs), Pleroma is more flexible in that regard. It’s trivial to set up in a way that your content never leaves your server if you want, blanket or per-post. Note I’m saying that content flows across servers and implementation, not that all of these share federated auth. You can not “sign in” on any other server than the one you registered with. Some people have multiple accounts on multiple servers, some stick to one. fosstodon.org is a great one for floss and Linux talk if you don’t want to run your own. BTW, check my HN profile if anyone wants to be friends :)
- bastardoperator 5y agoCount it as a blessing and move on... Also it's pretty easy to understand why a group with hitler in their title including references and photos of hitler was deleted on accident.
- ketzo 5y agoAnecdote time! I have a family member who runs a non-profit organization. They had contracted a social media agency, and one of the things that agency did was make a Facebook page for them. After the page had gotten some traction, and the contract with the agency was ending, their employee removed himself as an admin on the page in order to “hand over the keys.” Except he hadn’t made anyone else an admin yet. So the page had no administrator, and because it had strict settings, it meant that literally no one could get into the account. This page was not big, but it was not small; we’re talking ~50,000 impressions/post. Over four months, my family member couldn’t get access back to this account. She sent in her ID, some tax documents, a picture of the literal business registration with her name on it (that shared the name of the page). The old administrator confirmed, to Facebook over email, that she was intended to be the new administrator. Nothing. Facebook left her hanging. I reached out to a friend of mine who was a dev at Facebook. Issue resolved in 48 hours. Over a weekend.
- yumaikas 5y agoAt least facebook employs enough devs that, hopefully, the Bacon number to a Facebook dev is 2-3.
- cialowicz 5y agoFor this crowd, maybe. What about the majority of the world? They’re SOL, which seems unacceptable.
- charcircuit 5y agoThe rest of the world can just email them. It's not like facebook employees are cut off from the rest of the world.
- jeromegv 5y agoEmail whom? OP just talked about how emailing support did nothing. What are you supposed to do if you don’t know anyone at Facebook?
- bezoz 5y agoI am a facebook employee and even I had my instagram account banned ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- z82s3 5y agoWho did you reach out to get it unbanned? Do FB employees have some official channel for reinstating their own accounts or accounts of friends and family? (Also, please don't work for Facebook. You have talents that can be applied at a more ethical company.)
- veb 5y agoThis is a bit mean. You do not know the circumstances of OP. Do you know them personally to be able to say this? Is this so-called more ethical company going to pay them the same or give them the same sort of pay and benefits? What if this person has a spouse, or children that need specialised care that costs a lot? What if they also have a mortgage and provide for their parents as well as their family? Just saying "Please don't work for Facebook" is just so tone-deaf. Maybe YOU can work for a more ethical company, doesn't mean OP can.
- cute_boi 5y agoIt is not mean to tell people don't work for Facebook or nestle which makes money through Shenanigans. Politicians don't do anything against Facebook as they have lot of wealth to lobby politicians. As long as intelligent people are going to support mammoth corporation like Facebook what can we normal people say? I don't know if it applies for majority of people but in my social circle we treat palantir with stigma and actively tell people not to work for them. So, is it really mean to tell that? What can normal people do ? Telling people not work will help society in long run and also signals advertisers, consumers not to use their product:) It is similar to why USA has banned companies to not use any kind of cotton produced from xiangxinag although they might not personally know if that company is in mortgage and can afford to survive if they don't use cotton from china?
- z82s3 5y ago
- smm11 5y agoThe solution here is don't use Facebook or Instagram. It's not complicated.
- josephcsible 5y agoThe problem with that is that social networks have network effects. If you don't use them, you miss out in ways that using other ones instead doesn't make up for.
- christophilus 5y agoThat’s the biggest benefit of quitting.
- simple_phrases 5y agoIf you work in marketing, that might mean being unable to do the job you were hired to do.
- dessant 5y agoMy Facebook account has disappeared without a trace, after having been disabled and publicly reinstated by Facebook months before [1]. I don't understand how is this level of incompetence tolerated at a company that wants to mediate social connections and own the metaverse. Will I be forever banished from a part of society because your primitive algorithms are allowed to make incontestable decisions without true oversight? As Facebook's services are increasingly the only way to interact with modern society, permanently locking out people can alter lives. We deserve due process. [1] https://github.com/wit-ai/wit/issues/1946 https://github.com/wit-ai/wit/issues/1946
- ghaff 5y ago>As Facebook's services are increasingly the only way to interact with modern society, Seriously? I use Facebook now and then but "only way to interact with modern society"? I don't know a single service I need that requires Facebook. One can think Facebook has too much power without making it out to be this all powerful overlord. I'd probably tend to lose contact with a few folks if I dropped Facebook but it's hardly essential.
- dessant 5y agoFacebook isn't just about old high school friends, to some it can mean finding a free stroller and clothes for their baby, finding a buyer for their produce, or getting support in times of need.
- landryraccoon 5y ago> As Facebook's services are increasingly the only way to interact with modern society Wait what? I haven't used my Facebook account in years, what am I missing? But I just had a thought : If Facebook is really that essential for interacting with society as you claim, shouldn't it be regulated as a public utility?
- dessant 5y agoServices such as Facebook Groups, Facebook Marketplace and WhatsApp have become essential in some places. Employers can use WhatsApp groups to coordinate with employees, this is widespread even among government agencies. Facebook Marketplace has succesfully supplanted classifieds in many places. Being locked out means you have less access to goods and services, from used furniture to babysitters, caretakers, food and apartments for rent. You can also lose the main audience of your products and services, which can be catastrophic for members of an impoverished population. Facebook Groups can be the only way to connect with certain support groups or have access to services, especially in communities with limited public services provided by the government. Once we step out of the affluent bubble, it becomes evident that a deleted Facebook account can ruin lives. I agree that these companies should be regulated to some degree, to ensure that all people have access to de facto essential services.
- ylee 5y agoMy Facebook account was shut down without explanation in 2019. Despite its age (15 years) I barely used it, let alone for anything "controversial", but did regularly log into it. I repeatedly tried to verify my identity by submitting an image of my driver's license, without any response. If a Facebook employee is reading this ... I don't want to create a fake new Facebook account (which would be against the TOS, anyway). My account is so old that it was created back when only those associated with certain universities could get one. I want that one back.
- weci2i 5y agoThe same thing happened to me in 2019. I fought hard for a while and then gave up. I thought maybe I could drum up some public support (and work my way to a facebook connection who could restore it) by blogging about it and posting here...but nobody cared.
- gscott 5y agoFacebook said I was hurting people by "liking" (thumbs up) on there posts. They still ban me from liking posts occasionally.
- veb 5y agoI've owed Facebook $150 USD from an ad campaign I ran for a non-profit group for years now. Maybe 6? They still haven't banned me. They'll occasionally ask (as a small alert you can cancel out of) for it. I was hoping they'd ban me so I wouldn't have to go through the hoops to delete the account. No such luck, haha. I rarely visit though, I'll use `messenger.com` for close friends/family, that's about it. I just learned to minimise my usage on `facebook.com` and it's been fine. I do understand others have a lot of difficulty doing this and deleting their account seems to be easiest for them. (but it's never really deleted tho is it?)
- wheresmycraisin 5y agoI made a facebook account for advertising a few years back... (facebook requires linking advertising/business accounts with your personal account, and I didn't have a personal one). I was 90% through creating my second ad, when the UI glitched out and went into some sort of infinite loop. Seconds later, I was locked out of all my accounts, and to this day I can't access it.
- type0 5y agoIt wasn't incorrectly deleted. They don't allow the use of Hitler in the posts, being Jewish doesn't give you a free pass on that.
- jkaplowitz 5y agoFacebook/Meta itself seems to disagree with you - the very article we're discussing says the accounts were reinstated after inquiries from the author of the article, and a Meta company spokesperson said the accounts were "incorrectly removed". Many uses of Hitler on Facebook would violate their rules against hate speech, so I'm not surprised they have automation looking for that name. But even Facebook now agrees that a play about a real person who was forced to taste Hitler's food before he ate it is not such a violation.
- sharperguy 5y agoThis sort of thing should be more of a motivation to move away from platforms like facebook than the privacy issues. Imagine giving a company the ability to cut you off from your friends, delete entire records of conversations that you had with them, your photos and memories, random connections made which could have influenced your life in the future etc. All on a whim or the result of a glitch or mistake, but providing no means of recourse. It needs to be much easier for people to store and publish their own pictures, contact lists, dates, connections, life events etc so that it can't all just be taken away at a moment's notice.
- nirav72 5y agoOn the flip side , Facebook keeps spamming me with an invitation to re-enable my account. An account I disabled back in 2012.
- christophilus 5y agoMy wife just got threatened by FB to have her account banned (For saying that she’d have punched a sexual harasser in the nose.) Anyway, I’m excited. Her life is about to improve dramatically. Question for folks in the know: what’s the best way to download all photos from your Instagram and Facebook accounts? I’ve got some drives I’m going to back her stuff up to, and I figure this is a good group to ask.
- kingcharles 5y agohttps://www.facebook.com/help/212802592074644 https://www.facebook.com/help/212802592074644 https://help.instagram.com/contact/505535973176353 https://help.instagram.com/contact/505535973176353
- patchtopic 5y agoI know just getting rid of facebook doesn't solve this issue as youtube, etc also suffer from it - but it is a good start.
- gunapologist99 5y agoWow, I just checked and I was deleted as well sometime in the last six months or so after a decade or so of existence. I'd deleted my old posts and left only one post that said "I don't post on Facebook, please check me out on Twitter." Now it doesn't even say I'm suspended; it just says that no account can be found with my password, even though it prompted me (after entering username and password) to find out if a totally different account, but with a similar name, was mine. This is actually quite funny. I'd struggled with the decision of whether to delete my account entirely, but I doubted whether it would actually be deleted or not. I bet this is a more thorough method of deletion than if I'd gone through the multi-week deactivate-wait-delete process!
- mhb 5y agoFirst prize is staying deleted? Second prize is getting back on?
- kingcharles 5y agoI got banned by Pinterest by mistake. I found a site which just said to pester the shit out of them for months and eventually they would capitulate. This technique worked. Took about 2 weeks of constantly filing appeals at least once a day. Eventually some support drone re-enabled me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- decremental 5y agoMy Facebook account that I effectively just abandoned one day in 2014. One day last year someone tried to access it and Facebook sent me a security alert. Now I can't log in to it unless I send them a photocopy of my ID.
- ncmncm 5y agoBeing automatically deleted from Facebook would be a dream come true, if it were really all deleted. Normally it is practically impossible to get that.
- mngnt 5y agoLooks like big tech emplyees have become the new aristocracy. They are the only ones that can change the situation and also the ones who benefit from it, be it in the form of social status or, as the article mentions, as Grey market sellers of unlocks and reinstatement.
- totony 5y agoSame, account got banned in 2019, never received a response to the support ticket.
- inglor_cz 5y agoOne of the reasons why I quit Facebook actively and on my own. Better not build your life around something as unstable and unpredictable.
- anotheraccount9 5y agoIncorrectly deleted from Facebook? That's a blessing. Leave it to that.
- Digit-Al 5y agoThe problem we have here is that the big social media companies want to become the commons of the web, but they don't want to take on the responsibility this entails. They want to be the storage source for all of your emails, photographs, and videos; and would even love to host things like your medical records; but if you are holding a person's entire life then that should entail a higher level of responsibility. To be honest, I don't think it's wise to entrust everything to a company that is supplying its services for free. If you are paying a company then you have a contract and the company is bound by legal responsibilities that can be enforced by the law. If you are not paying for a service then they have no responsibilities apart from those they hold themselves to, and you have no legal recourse if they suddenly deny you access to the services they are providing.
- juanani 5y agoIncorrectly did you a favor. Be thankful, now go and smell the roses