4 ms·
Highly Vaccinated South Korea Can’t Slow Down Covid-19
- bediger4000 5y agoI read this headline as being carefully anti-vax. The article itself only has a couple of paragraphs showing before the paywall, but they don't seem to match the anti-vax spirit of the headline. Why is WSJ so slyly anti-vax?
- newbamboo 5y agoMaybe they want to protect people?
- thehappypm 5y agoI don’t read this as anti-vax, more vax-realist. Vaccines clearly improve immunity, to the point that there are these obvious and measurable improvements in outcomes with them. But at the same time they aren’t this amazing pandemic-ending, sickness-eliminating magic, either. Better to accept this reality than live in a fantasy land.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThey're also famously climate change deniers (though some of their owners other properties just flipped en masse so that might not be true anymore). You have to assume they're not stupid and that they can somehow make enough money from short term denial that it makes up for the reputation hit of being completely on the wrong side of an important issue. I'd guess that skepticism of government intervention in general is worth enough to them to justify a very large number of deaths, but it would be interesting to know if they have that worked out on a spreadsheet somewhere or if they just hired a bunch of people, told them to undermine government intervention, and this is just part of the predictable costs of that.
- peteradio 5y agoWhy is anything less than pure praise of vaccines considered anti-vaxx?
- Arnt 5y agoI don't think it is, in general, but that description seems to apply to what's submitted to HN. For example I've seen quite sensible articles arguing that vaccinating children under 12 is counter-productive and/or better not done, but not submitted here. So maybe the question can be changed to why is that kind of thing submitted to HN so much?
- peteradio 5y agoI'm not able to parse your last sentence do you mean "why isn't"? Otherwise it seems in tension with the rest you wrote. You'd have to use the search feature to see what gets submitted but doesn't reach an audience. Often times these discussions are flagged and if OP doesn't care to get it unflagged then it falls off the radar.
- Arnt 5y agoWell, submitted and upvoted, then. (I use hnapp.com and see things that receive 3 votes IIRC, or maybe 5.) Stories like this one receive upvotes. Its headline says "can't slow down covid", the body text doesn't go out on a limb and claim that the vaccinated majority are falling ill at the same rate as the unvaccinated minority, but it doesn't say anything else either. Just a slyly misleading headline and 14 upvotes.
- nradov 5y agoThere's nothing anti-vax in the article or headline. I don't understand how you could have interpreted it that way. Your insinuation is unwarranted.
- xyzzy21 5y agoThe vaccines: 1. Do NOT prevent transmission/infectivity to others 2. Do NOT provide long-term immunity to you 3. Do NOT act without strong and possibly harmful side-effects These are facts acknowledge by the CDC, FDA and peer reviewed science. This story falls without these known facts!! Being aligned to actual science rather than the religious imitation of scientism primarily practiced by rabid COVID-ians cult members isn't being anti-vax! It's science and common sense.
- tinus_hn 5y agoAs far as I have read the vaccines could possibly cause a small chance of some side effects that are very dangerous. That doesn’t match the ‘strong and possibly harmful side-effects’; what are you are referring to?
- timeon 5y agoIs this 'all or nothing' attitude really science and common sense?
- nate_meurer 5y ago> 1. Do NOT prevent transmission/infectivity to others Which doesn't fucking matter. No vaccines, with a single exception, provide durable sterilizing immunity. COVID vaccines were never expected or intended to either. They were designed to provide protection against serious disease, and all the evidence so far points to spectacular success in this regard. > Do NOT provide long-term immunity to you This is simultaneously wrong and a misdirection based on fuzzy terminology. . If by "immunity" you mean protection against infection, then you've just repeated your first misleading point. If "long term immunity" means protection against serious disease, then the evidence so far says you're wrong. But if you're using your own special definition of "immunity" then I guess you can make whatever assertion you want. > Do NOT act without strong and possibly harmful side-effects Complete your sentence by telling us the statistical risk of an adverse reaction, and how it compares to the risk of serious long term effects from getting COVID. Then you might have a useful statement. > These are facts... No, these are twisted, dishonest re-phrasings you've made in an attempt to turn widely known and accepted limitations of the vaccines into some sort argument against vaccination in general. > Being aligned to actual science... Coming from you, this is just... funny actually.
- tinus_hn 5y agoRead the entire article at: https://archive.md/Ob4GG https://archive.md/Ob4GG