4 ms·
Despite the debacle in Afghanistan, the US military remains extremely powerful with an unmatched capacity to project that power around the world. Russian leader
by nradov 5y ago
Despite the debacle in Afghanistan, the US military remains extremely powerful with an unmatched capacity to project that power around the world. Russian leaders are under no illusions about that. However, military power is meaningless if you're not willing to use it. President Biden has already clearly stated that the US will not intervene militarily to defend Ukraine, and will only apply economic sanctions.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe debacle in Afghanistan showed that the US military is incompetent when it comes to actually achieving their goals. Let's say the US does intervene in Ukraine. The US still won't be able to take Crimea for obvious reasons. Ukraine itself will be even more of a shithole. In the end, when the US leaves Ukraine, Will things be better or worse? Who knows, and that's why an intervention there is not on the table. If it was easy and straightforward and would deal a decisive blow to Russia, it would already be done.
- torstenvl 5y ago> The debacle in Afghanistan showed that the US military is incompetent when it comes to actually achieving their goals How so? That's a pretty novel interpretation. Why do you view Afghanistan as a military failure rather than a political one?
- sudosysgen 5y agoIt's really not a novel interpretation. The goal of a military operation is to achieve political goals. There is no clear delineation between the two. If the political goals weren't reached then the military failed. A military is only as good as its leadership, is it not? Well, the ultimate leadership is the president.
- torstenvl 5y agoThat is definitely novel, yes. Political success often depends on military success, but I've never heard anyone claim the opposite. The implication of your position is that the only way the U.S. military could have "succeeded" would have been to mutiny. That seems... odd.
- sudosysgen 5y agoWell, no. The only way for the U.S. military would have been for it to produce better advice for its commander in chief, and for the commander in chief to follow that advice. It failed at both levels. This is definitely not novel. I am basically quoting Clausewitz, which is basically as far as you can go from being novel in the military tradition nowadays. For instance: > We see, therefore, that War is not merely a political act, but also a real political instrument, a continuation of political commerce, a carrying out of the same by other means. All beyond this which is strictly peculiar to War relates merely to the peculiar nature of the means which it uses. ___That the tendencies and views of policy shall not be incompatible with these means, the Art of War in general and the Commander in each particular case may demand___, and this claim is truly not a trifling one. But however powerfully this may react on political views in particular cases, still it must always be regarded as only a modification of them; for ___the political view is the object, War is the means, and the means must always include the object in our conception.___ The U.S. military failed to act in a way that, to borrow Clausewitz's words, always includes the object in their conception. They therefore failed in their goals. Just as a foolish attack doomed to failure is a military failure, so is a foolish operation that could not achieve it's goals. Also, it's far from true that the military knew that what they were doing would fail. They really did believe just as much as anyone else, in the beginning, that they would be able to make Afghanistan into a perfect American puppet and model in the region, and in being wrong, they failed too.
- torstenvl 5y agoNo. You're saying the opposite of Clausewitz. Clausewitz says that the goals of war are political; that political success in war relies on military success. I agree with that and think it's nearly self-evident. You're saying the opposite. You're saying military success relies on political success. That's an entirely different proposition and one I disagree with. > The only way for the U.S. military [to succeed] would have been for ... the commander in chief to follow that advice The only way the U.S. military could guarantee such a thing would be a coup. I don't think we should be blaming the military for not carrying out a coup. Not carrying out a coup does not constitute military failure.