5 ms·
Content aside, Reddit is possibly the worst performing large commercial website I have ever seen. Like half of all page loads and requests end with “something w
by paxys 5y ago
Content aside, Reddit is possibly the worst performing large commercial website I have ever seen. Like half of all page loads and requests end with “something went wrong”. Search has been unusable from day 1, and somehow getting worse. Their new video player makes me want to throw my computer across the room. I have been using it on and off for a decade now and I can’t think of one aspect of the site (whether in terms of performance, reliability, UI, usability, features) that hasn’t degraded in quality.
Happy about the IPO, but PLEASE invest in some engineering and infrastructure work.
(Edit: weird that this comment was sitting at the top of the page for an hour and then suddenly moved to the very bottom. Someone on the HN team must really like Reddit.)
- fortylove 5y agoThe page loads ending in failure has not been my experience at all. Search is not great though, agreed.
- kactus 5y agoThe redesign and video player issues finally convinced me to stop using Reddit and delete my account after 10 years, last year. Haven’t looked back.
- thundergolfer 5y agoI use Reddit daily, and for the last ~week their UI has added multiple things to click and be taken to my 'Reddit recap', which I think is supposed to be like Spotify's 'your year in review' feature. Reddit's product managers very much want me to check out my 'Reddit Recap'. Well I've navigated to my recap about 30 times now in the last week, from multiple links, in app and desktop, and it's still totally broken. On desktop now, it doesn't show anything except a "retry" button which is incorrectly stuck to the left side of my screen (CSS fail). I can understand things being broken, but its really bad form to funnel a user to a prominent feature, have that feature be broken, and then have a broken and terrible error state. I do wonder what kind of engineering team bungles a big feature release like this.
- sergiotapia 5y agoThe second old.reddit.com goes offline, I'll probably never visit the website again. I haven't used the new version once (what is it 4 years old now?) - they toyed with literally the perfect UX for what? For a PM to have something to do?
- jethro_tell 5y agoTo sell ads inline so they could ipo and bail.
- egypturnash 5y agoOh god the recap is hilariously broken. Doesn’t work on my iPad or my iPhone browser. Haven’t tried the app because fuck the app. Sorta works on my desktop browser. Kinda.
- campital 5y agoI experienced a somewhat comical bug where the Reddit recap chose my most downvoted comment as my "Comment to end all comments" (probably because its absolute value was greatest). Seems unlikely that this was an intentional easter egg (it was accompanied with "Out of all the comments you made in 2021, this one sure got a lot of upvotes"). Also, I just discovered that the built-in screenshot generator for Reddit recap is broken as it only captures the rendered portion of each card, leaving out the scrollable overflow. This case alone offers a strong testament to the poor quality of most Reddit features.
- StanislavPetrov 5y ago>I do wonder what kind of engineering team bungles a big feature release like this. No doubt a team that is very diverse and equitable.
- sillycube 5y agoThe thing is I don't understand why I want to see the recap
- edoceo 5y agoThis is all their attention grabbing tricks -- by MBA style middle managers to juke the stats for their OKRs and KPIs. Reddit is to that part of their life-cycle where the soul gets crushed out for the capital (it's a re-run, you've seen it before). I'd wager $1 that over the next few years Reddit becomes even more of an Attention-Vampire (or tries to) It's almost feeling Reddit, Facebook, Twitter -- these "social" echo chamber sites are all getting to the contempt phase of life -- the next disruptor cannot come soon enough.
- protoax 5y agoCompletely agree – search is absurdly poor considering the resources available to any solo developer these days. The mobile app is generally usable, if all you want to do is doomscroll without interacting with a single piece of content. Even normal interface interactions induce ridiculous UI delays that I haven't seen in any level of software product for years.
- vlunkr 5y agoThey've also made some (or most?) subreddits unavailable on the mobile site. It's obviously a hostile attempt to force people into the mobile app.
- yannoninator 5y agoAfter this exit, expect engineering to go way down.
- enryu 5y agoWhy do you think that? Is there a record of engineering performance going down in other companies that had exits?
- greenknight 5y agoThis is the thing, i hate their new ui... and if ever they get rid of their 'old' ui I would leave reddit. Their "New UI" was brought in in 2018, and to me was like a digg moment. To me, Hackernews is what Reddit was 10 years ago, just without subreddits. Clean top quality content.
- kingcharles 5y agoIt's weird. I was a huge user of Reddit from its launch to 2013 when I fell off the Internet. I didn't use it again until 2021, so I had a big jump in UI. As a UX designer I really don't get all the hate about the current interface. It works great for me.
- jorvi 5y agoIt has horrible performance issues even on something like 11400f with a 3070Ti.
- 0x0nyandesu 5y agoIt's just a small amount of actual content in the space compared to the old interface (still up at old.reddit.com)
- Gigachad 5y agoThe actual visuals and layout are fine imo. I don’t need to see a billion posts at once. The problem is it runs like shit, gives errors all the time, and has a billion nag popups.
- romwell 5y agoIt's literally 10x slower on all devices that I have, shows less content (particularly, long comment threads), and 100 other reasons they I'd sure hope you understood as a UX designer. It's 2021, I don't want to see a "Loading..." icon like I'm on dial-up in the 90s. Compare with https://old.reddit.com https://old.reddit.com — open them side by side, refresh, click around. We can have a serious discussion about what sucks in the "new" UI, but I really hope it's obvious.
- winternett 5y agoI'm beginning to see why they banned several subreddits and accounts, began forcing people to use the app, had tons of front page content re-upped as bootlegs from tiktok, and then turned the place into a Frankenstein of all the other social media sites.. Finally the truth comes to light... Whelp... Thanks for the fish, it was nice until it tanked about 2 years ago.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoAnd more than doubled the subscription price too.
- 0x0nyandesu 5y agoIf they get rid of old.reddit.com I won't be able to use it..just can't. It will die for me like digg.
- winternett 5y agoNew reddit is scary... Almost like IG with boxes around everything, and all the controls are hidden in places you'll never find them. It's like driving a poorly serviced 92 Fiero through a hidden curve on the autobahn. But even old reddit has the same recycled content and reposts, so there's that... :\
- scantron4 5y agoAt least you have the giant stickied Covid Misinformation comment on on every single post on .... r/funny. The place I go for all of my up to date covid information.
- romwell 5y agoI don't know what you're talking about. Reddit is lightning fast, and is very stable... ...oh. I got it! You might be trying to use the dumpster fire that's https://reddit.com https://reddit.com Ignore that, and head over to the actually functional Reddit at https://old.reddit.com https://old.reddit.com It's like HackerNews in terms of performance. You can still set it as default. The "new" UI they have is unusable, and may God have mercy for the poor souls that walk into it.
- SkyMarshal 5y agoI was thinking exactly the same thing, till you mentioned old reddit, and I remember I've never actually used new reddit. I just opted out in Preferences when it was first released and have been using old reddit ever since. It's still the same good reading/content experience it was 10yrs ago.
- jolux 5y ago> The "new" UI they have is unusable, and may God have mercy for the poor souls that walk into it. This would be reasonable if there weren’t subreddits that are totally broken on old.reddit.com and proclaim loudly in their sidebar that they no longer support it.
- Spivak 5y agoYou use custom CSS?!? Oh god it’s so awful. Turning that off is half the reason to be logged in.
- jolux 5y agoI wasn’t aware I could turn it off, guess I’ll go do that.
- romwell 5y agoAside from disabling custom CSS being an option, I haven't ever stumbled into that problem. Could you link to an example? In curious :)
- 5y ago
- technion 5y agoAren't every one of those facts supposed to be the sort of thing that gets you downranked on Google? Slow pages, pages that don't load, pages appear in Google but when clicked present a logon wall? I've posted on own blog on Reddit and found that a search for the exact title has, as the first hit, that reddit post. And my blog itself is on page three. It's infuriating.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pingsl 5y agoI once ran some ads on Reddit to promote my website. What I found from the ad report was 99% of Reddit users were using the mobile app. So I am afraid Reddit won't care about the web UI much now.
- tzm 5y agoAt this point, I've learned to expect this type of criticism on HN.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- VirusNewbie 5y agoDoes anyone know why reddit's engineering is such a shit show? It seems comically bad. MySpace was more reliable.