5 ms·
Lots of cities have had remote workers leave, permanently or temporarily, for obvious reasons. Is there anything showing that SF is somehow worse? What I do be
by wolverine876 5y ago
Lots of cities have had remote workers leave, permanently or temporarily, for obvious reasons. Is there anything showing that SF is somehow worse?
What I do believe I see is a strong relationship between reactionary/GOP political messaging and what is repeated about cities. The Republican National Convention's focus was the 'chaos' in cities, IIRC, though few noticed because other issues dominated. Reactionary messaging seems inredibly effective; whatever they say, people of all stripes are soon repeating. The emotionally intense, repetitive style also seems to match it - I don't see many reasoned arguments.
It can absolutely be self-fulfilling. Perception is reality. Look at many Americans worried about crime in cities, while crime is low and dropping. Homicides (a small portion) are up, but all over the place, not cities in particular. (Source: Recent FBI/DoJ report.) I live in a place with low crime, yet people say they are leaving because of it.
> A lot of the companies that ... went to Miami due to politics will never go back.
As of a few months ago, most people leaving SF went to the greater Bay Area, next elsewhere in CA, next the state of Washington.
Most companies go to SF for politics (or policy), but it's the norm and therefore unremakrable. You don't see a lot of leading companies outside the leading cities, maybe for a reason. Politics, especially when one group advocates ignorance, hate, and disrupting the rule of law, correlates with intelligent policy. Also, most people don't like living around ignorance, hate, and chaos.
- refurb 5y agoNo matter your politics, the quality of life is going downhill in SF. Property crime is up, racial attacks are up and more concerning are the brazen daylight looting of stores which shows criminals have little fear of consequences.
- miked85 5y agoWhat consequences?
- dougmwne 5y agoThis is a sensible argument, but there is absolutely a reality on the ground. San Francisco has horrid problems compared to all other US cities I have been to. It is even more extreme when you compare it to international cities. The crime, homelessness and excrement is extremely visible, in the statistics and while walking down the street. It is bad, it is broken, and it doesn’t need to be that way. I spent a month in 5 separate cities this year, one of which was Vienna. Vienna is spectacularly well run through the result of decades of well considered governance. A significant contribution is a yearly investment in public housing which has prevented property speculation bubbles and given marginal people a place to live. The first step to fixing a problem is to admit you have a problem.
- wolverine876 5y agoHave you seen any high-quality data on the state of SF? It's such a political issue that I have a hard time finding anything but propaganda and rants. Real data would help understand what happens where, when, etc., rather than a general 'human feces!' alarm bell. No American city is going to turn into Vienna! Also, it is said (maybe complete BS), the culture that makes Vienna so beautiful also produces fascists and the murder of many Vienna residents.
- more_corn 5y agoYou don’t need statistics you need real reports of quality of life from people living there. What you mistake as rants are people who live there telling you they hate it. What other data do you need?
- AlexandrB 5y ago> What other data do you need? Actual data. Emotional testimonials are a terrible way to set public policy. See also the security theatre we've instituted in our airports since 9/11. Going off of people's self-reported experiences is how you get policy driven by mass hysteria like the "Satanic Panic"[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satanic_panic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satanic_panic
- diogenescynic 5y agoWhy do we have to argue when we can just use Google? The data backs up what he is saying: >8 Out of 10 Residents Believe Crime Has Gotten Worse in San Francisco; Vast Majority Support Increasing Police Officers and Expanding Police Work https://sfchamber.com/new-polling-shows-that-8-out-of-10-residents-believe-crime-has-gotten-worse-in-san-francisco-vast-majority-support-increasing-police-officers-and-expanding-police-work/ https://sfchamber.com/new-polling-shows-that-8-out-of-10-res...
- wolverine876 5y ago> You don’t need statistics you need real reports of quality of life from people living there. What you mistake as rants are people who live there telling you they hate it. What other data do you need? At this date, we still don't understand that such things on the Internet are completely unreliable?
- post_from_work 5y ago>>>Homicides (a small portion) are up, but all over the place, not cities in particular. https://abcnews.go.com/US/12-major-us-cities-top-annual-homicide-records/story?id=81466453 https://abcnews.go.com/US/12-major-us-cities-top-annual-homi... Cities are hitting RECORD homicides though. Does the data show that suburbia is suffering anywhere near as bad of a spike? I dunno....I haven't picked through the data to compare [these 12 cities] vs [America ex-these 12 cities]. https://crime-data-explorer.app.cloud.gov/pages/explorer/crime/crime-trend https://crime-data-explorer.app.cloud.gov/pages/explorer/cri...
- wolverine876 5y ago> Cities are hitting RECORD homicides though. It's a real crisis and horrible for the victims. But ... very few people are murdered - it's just a rare thing regardless - and afaik most by people they know. > Does the data show that suburbia is suffering anywhere near as bad of a spike? Based on the Washington Post story on the FBI report that I read, as I recall, it was pretty much everywhere. Of course a suburban township with 1 murder last year and 2 this year has doubled its homicide rate.
- diogenescynic 5y ago> Of course a suburban township with 1 murder last year and 2 this year has doubled its homicide rate. So you made a hypothetical in your head and hand wave all criticism away? How is this not confirmation bias? If you like it fine, but to dismiss what everyone else is saying is strange. If you lived in the Bay Area, you could see it falling apart in real time. Homeless, crime, quality of life, drugs and everything else got worse and worse. It wouldn’t be a meme if it weren’t actually there.
- wolverine876 5y ago> to dismiss what everyone else is saying is strange The standard of evidence is 'what everyone else is saying'? We need to improve our education system.
- lumost 5y agoTo add to this, in Boston we are seeing a divergence between the condo and single family real estate market. Condo prices are way up, but single family prices are down. Based on anecdotal experience, I suspect that people who wanted the single family lifestyle are leaving the city whereas those who want the city lifestyle are entering. Remote work means you don't need to choose where you live based on commutes. Similar to the Bay Area, around here there are suburban campuses which are impractical to commute to from the city. I'd be curious of there is a similar effect in SF causing specific single family neighborhoods to empty out.
- wahern 5y ago> I'd be curious of there is a similar effect in SF causing specific single family neighborhoods to empty out. Single-family home prices have been on a tear the past year, and for 2020 prices flattened rather than drop. Condominiums took a huge hit in 2020 and have only recently recovered to their 2019 levels. I don't know if actual families (or couples looking to start a family) are moving into those homes, though.
- more_corn 5y agoThe thing that makes SF worse is that the lawlessness, drugs, human shit all over the streets really make you wonder if it’s worth $3,000/mo for a 1 bedroom. Other cities are simultaneously more pleasant places to live and cheaper. I.E The place is expensive and objectively terrible. City government has been experimenting with new progressive models for drugs (don’t criminalize addiction!) but failing to follow through and actually solve the problem. Pop quiz: If you decriminalize drugs without funding addiction treatment what do you get? What happens when you decriminalize petty crime without instituting any measures to otherwise prevent crime? Guess what happens? I don’t know the answers to society’s problems, but I can spot failure when it drops thou in broad daylight and shits on my bumper. And frankly I’m over paying a premium for that privilege.