5 ms·
“Not upgrades”? DPI scaling and full screen playback without screen tearing are pretty huge upgrades. You might argue that it’s not worth overhauling everythi
by dijit 5y ago
“Not upgrades”?
DPI scaling and full screen playback without screen tearing are pretty huge upgrades.
You might argue that it’s not worth overhauling everything for that, but it’s undeniably a huge quality difference and was one of the major reasons I moved to wayland. Having a 1080p screen and a 4K screen “just work” has been my reality for a few years now - to the point where I get surprised when people talk about it as if it’s an issue.
I do have screen sharing issues though. With basically everything.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoI can do font scaling in x.org, my screens also just work. I have DPI scaling but it doesn't seem to be switch when I take my laptop off the dock. Wayland sessions seem smoother, most software I use isn't adapted to the new model yet, and for the cost of losing my global hotkeys, redshift, and other useful things that matter, its not worth it to see smoother animations, I'd rather turn them off. Edit: I never had screen tearing on video.
- dijit 5y agoRedshift -> Gammastep Hot keys are handled by the compositor. Global ones especially. (Apps stealing keystrokes? Sounds like an anti feature) Point stands. But I’d rather we work on improving things than just living with X11- it’s like continually adapting token ring networks instead of embracing star topology. It’s fundamentally difficult or impossible to fix. The wayland authors (who are former X11 devs) talked about this extensively.
- AshamedCaptain 5y ago> Apps stealing keystrokes? Sounds like an anti feature Sounds like that right until the user tries to press Alt Tab on a full-screen VNC or VM client.
- dijit 5y agoAlt tab not being stolen might be jarring. But I’d rather not have apps overriding the compositor because then I might not be able to escape them. There is some comfort in the universality of many things.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago>Alt tab not being stolen might be jarring. It is jarring to need to remember different keystrokes by the compositor if you use more than one computer, especially if they're not all linux. Why do you think its worth all this pain? Every "feature" of wayland sounds like a regression. I hope someone makes x.org in rust
- dijit 5y agoSounds like you just don’t like change honestly. Which I could agree with you- I dislike change too, I fight systemd because I don’t see it benefiting me. But this is a bit silly, you keep coming up with rotating surface level complaints but the main reason X11 was replaced was because it was architecturally broken not because they wanted to solve specific issues. That there is no great community around wayland is because of naysayers like yourself. Things are easier to solve than they used to be but people are doing everything they can to avoid using wayland. Things like nvidia forcing people to use X11 have caused distro maintainers to do double the work to maintain backwards compatibility; which means it hasn’t had as much love as X11 over the years either. Normally I would take the stance of “what ever works” but you sound like you’ll do anything to justify not switching. Arguing about creature comforts or that your compositor has more control over your UX than some random program is an absolutely surface level argument when we’re talking about fundamental and required architecture changes for us to go forward with desktop Linux. That you don’t understand how dire the situation was becoming is quite telling. It’s not worse, it just doesn’t have the community stuff behind it yet, and the reason is the mentality you have.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago>Sounds like you just don’t like change honestly. I would gladly hop in a better car, if the newer car has less features and is worst, I will not. >That there is no great community around wayland is because of naysayers like yourself. Things are easier to solve than they used to be but people are doing everything they can to avoid using wayland. Rust has plenty of naysayers, as does pipewire. People hate Apple stuff with a passion, but they are all good. Wayland works on GNOME, which is a fact. I even said if its "good enough" it will take a long time for more application support, unless I hate myself and resign myself to no configuration GNOME. The reason it has no community is because it sucks. >Normally I would take the stance of “what ever works” but you sound like you’ll do anything to justify not switching. Arguing about creature comforts or that your compositor has more control over your UX than some random program is an absolutely surface level argument when we’re talking about fundamental and required architecture changes for us to go forward with desktop Linux. You don't get to decide what the direction of desktop linux is, or what people want to do with their open source software. I could say that the dolphin is the stupidest animal in the world, and nobody would take me seriously. Wayland sucks, if tomorrow x.org didn't exist, I would not continue to use linux. There is no benefit for most users in this thread. I even said I used it on a touch device to get rotation working on my touch tablet, but you ignored that because I have a different preference than you. Every "feature" of wayland sounds like a regression if doublespeaking as regression in features is going forward. >That you don’t understand how dire the situation was becoming is quite telling. It’s not worse, it just doesn’t have the community stuff behind it yet, and the reason is the mentality you have. There is a new maintainer, I will continue to use the best tools for myself, which will not be wayland for any non touch computer. Wayland design is... good It's taken over a decade to add a fraction of x.org features, random plugins needed to make it imitate x11, and with less features it still crashes? If it such a required architeture change, why is it making everything worst? What does forward even mean, less features with more crashes? No thanks. If it was so great why does it still suck compared to the so called dire x.org? >It’s not worse, it just doesn’t have the community stuff behind it yet, and the reason is the mentality you have. Do you love broken userspace? That's great, choose a compositor that breaks your userspace? My mentality of having robust software is the opposite. Suprise! Nobody wants to use crappier software with less features despite the dire "problems" of x.org, they made a rational choice, which bothers you so much. Why does it matter what I run? You look down on everyone's problem as invalid, calls our mentality wrong, and can't even define what forward is, or why anyone cares, because nothing you say is a benefit matters. Don't be suprised if wayland never gets used or doesn't ever gain traction, other half baked projects like btrfs that are inferior to even older software are not going to be used over better alternatives. You are dishonest about screen tearing being an issue, and calling my custom hotkeys "stealing keystrokes", saying its fundamentally broken when wayland breaks more things, and instead of the project acknowledging user needs, they ignore it and somehow wonder why nobody want to use it. I'll end by saying wayland is fundamentally broken, it has less features, no gains to non graphics or productivity, no benefits and more drawbacks to most users, the wonderful future of the "forward thinking" design that strips useful features and ignores what people like about x.org is beneficial to everyone. No, it is inferior in every way except for gyroscope screen rotation and slightly smoother movements, something that is compartively worthless to the suite of useful x.org features.
- jcelerier 5y agoI'd definitely not want to work on a desktop where I can't have an app set up a global hotkey. Do you never record with e.g. OBS, simplescreenrecorder or things like that ?
- GhettoComputers 5y agoI tried to setup my music controls with dbus but not all the keyboard shortcuts function either for some random reason, so its fundamentally broken if you want to change it still can't do all that x.org does.
- dijit 5y agoPersonally I use sway and tell my compositor to bind certain hot keys to certain commands. The downside is that once a command is bound it cannot be reused: so if I wanted to have OBS and simplescreenrecorder that both use “meta+S” to start recording then that’s not possible. The biggest issue I have with wayland is that OBS and screen recording simply do not work, I’m not sure if there are effective workarounds but a consequence of one program not being allowed to spy on another program is that you can’t record the screen.
- mariusor 5y ago> is that OBS and screen recording simply do not work That is not true (at least in sway). You need the xdg-desktop-portal-wlr installed and running for it. Gnome and Plasma have similar desktop portal utilities, but I'm not sure they fully support the screen sharing wayland extension.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago> Redshift -> Gammastep I use a widget that I can scroll my mouse to change the color, does it have it? It doesn't look like it does. >Hot keys are handled by the compositor. Yes I know, I don't like it, I have hotkeys setup in a way that I like, and I don't want to redo it all, I even tried. >Global ones especially. (Apps stealing keystrokes? Sounds like an anti feature) Framing app hotkeys as theft of my input is like saying that my window I am tying in is stealing my keystrokes. If you consider breaking userspace as an benefit, I am confused. It is an optional feature I turned on myself, and you call it keystroke theft, when it was ME that enabled it. Linus Torvald's one rule is that userspace should never be broken. This breaks userspace. > It’s fundamentally difficult or impossible to fix. Or its not broken. >The wayland authors (who are former X11 devs) talked about this extensively. They are still improving it like btrfs, but I would rather stick to something that just works, and so far it has more problems, anti features, needs configuration to be functional, and for what benefit? No battery benefits, no extra functionality in fact less features, breaks workflow, and smoother animations. I also forgot to mention it breaks some of my terminal emulators, every time I try it I have a horrible experience, it breaks things that matter to me, and still does for most people. Even if its "good enough" it will take a long time for more application support, unless I hate myself and resign myself to no configuration GNOME.
- hjek 5y ago> redshift, This was also a showstopper for me. Now, however, in Debian Sid `redshift -m wayland` works fine (although Gnome also has its own > my global hotkeys, They can be configured in your compositor. For those used to using i3, Sway makes this easy by being mostly compatible.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago>They can be configured in your compositor. For those used to using i3, Sway makes this easy by being mostly compatible. Pretty annoying to do this, too bad there's no easy import. A lot of effort for a lot of loss of functionality for smoother animations. Nice to know that redshift is updated thought!
- smoldesu 5y agoDPI scaling is undeniably nice, unfortunately I never got far enough in my Wayland journey to see the benefits. Screen tearing is an interesting issue to parse, but it's also perfectly fixable in x11 if you force the compositor pipeline. Especially since my main monitor has G-Sync, I've not really noticed any tearing on Linux unless I use a desktop that explicitly lacks a compositor on an integrated GPU. I really like what the Wayland people are trying to achieve, I just don't agree with their methodology, and their results have spoken for themselves.
- zajio1am 5y ago> full screen playback without screen tearing are pretty huge upgrades. Tearing in full screen (video) playback was not an issue for decades, since X video extension and later OpenGL-based playback. Fullscreen video and 3D is easy, because it is one program that controls buffer flipping. It is windowed video/3D that always has tearing.
- dijit 5y ago> Tearing in full screen (video) playback was not an issue for decades Either you're being hyperbolic about the length of time or this is simply untrue. I have been using Wayland full time for 3 years, and 3 years ago the main driver of me switching was screen tearing. I was heavily invested in the X11 ecosystem with highly customised fontconfig's, so this was quite painful for me at the time and I definitely tried to solve the screen tearing issue. Part of it was that Linux did not have hardware acceleration in browsers, which is where I spent most of my time (especially for video playback, such as YouTube). So those extensions didn't help, and when you get used to the buttery smooth scrolling experience of MacOS and iOS it feels quite janky going back to linux- especially when you've invested so much into making it a more beautiful experience for yourself.
- zajio1am 5y ago> Either you're being hyperbolic about the length of time or this is simply untrue. I am not hyperbolic, X11 has this Xv API, video players generally use it since early 2000s (as that was only reasonable way to even scale video to fullscreen with contemporary computers). Browsers - well, that is a different issue. I do not think Firefox uses it and have no idea about Chromium. > Part of it was that Linux did not have hardware acceleration in browsers, which is where I spent most of my time (especially for video playback, such as YouTube). Linux also have hardware decoding acceleration API (even multiple ones - historic XvMC, NVidia-specific VDPAU and current mainstream VA-API), their support in software is more spotty than basic Xv API (AFAIK MPlayer implemented VDPAU but not VA-API, MPV required for some time explicit option to use VA-API and i have no idea about VLC). Firefox got support just recently: https://ubuntuhandbook.org/index.php/2021/08/enable-hardware-video-acceleration-va-api-for-firefox-in-ubuntu-20-04-18-04-higher/ https://ubuntuhandbook.org/index.php/2021/08/enable-hardware... I would generally suggest to view web video such as YouTube in MPV video player using its youtube-dl integration. It is much better experience than playing video in Firefox.
- pineconewarrior 5y agoIf Wayland fixes screen tearing I might be able to stand desktop Linux. Is it time to give it another go? Has the font rendering improved at all? My eyes can't handle some of the ugliness and my skill with code ends where the browser closes, so I've never tried to fix it.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoI don't have screen tearing on x.org. If you use GNOME and wayland I never once felt I had an issue, but GNOME is more limiting for configuration than OSX.
- noahtallen 5y agoHow is that last statement true? macOS is basically not customizable, and gnome can be themed, even with the new changes (https://blogs.gnome.org/alatiera/2021/09/18/the-truth-they-are-not-telling-you-about-themes/ https://blogs.gnome.org/alatiera/2021/09/18/the-truth-they-a...)
- GhettoComputers 5y agohttps://www.maketecheasier.com/how-to-customize-mac/#Custom-Color-Scheme https://www.maketecheasier.com/how-to-customize-mac/#Custom-... So this?
- smoldesu 5y agoI'm going to be real with you, if your definition of 'theming' is setting an accent color and choosing between light and dark mode... I think I feel really bad for you.
- noahtallen 5y agoNo, according to the post I shared, you can do more than that: > You can also recolor any part of a widget however you like And they show an example of a gradient background and stuff like that. And I mean, for most people, a theme is just coloring things how they like and setting the font and visual things. While full-blown stylesheets are very cool, and I think still “allowed,” you can’t really officially support that in a compatible way. You have to set an API so that everything can be consistent. For example, it can currently be a huge pain to change the accent color on PopOS away from orange because you can’t just set a variable somewhere. It seems like the new system will improve that. Either way, leaps and bounds ahead of macOS
- Aardwolf 5y agoI don't see any screen tearing on X11, with cinnamon on archlinux, on a 4K monitor, with Nvidia. No tearing when dragging windows around, scrolling text, playing fullscreen games at 4K (both native and with steam proton) or watching video at 4K. This without doing any special configuration, as far as I remember. As for font scaling, I just choose a big enough font or default zoom level in the browsers, VTE's and text editors I use, looks perfect.
- 1_player 5y agoScreen tearing on X11 on NVIDIA has been a known issue since forever, unless you, yikes, add some options in your xorg.conf. And display scaling != font scaling. You don't fix scaling by making your fonts bigger, everything, including UI has to scale.