7 ms·
This is a neat and helpful comparison, but to me the issue was never really latency; it's more the fact that Wayland isn't neccesarily a direct upgrade over x11
by smoldesu 5y ago
This is a neat and helpful comparison, but to me the issue was never really latency; it's more the fact that Wayland isn't neccesarily a direct upgrade over x11 in a lot of ways.
Now, I can anticipate a number of responses to this. Firstly, a lot of people will (correctly) point out that x11 isn't a very good window server, and doesn't account for things like compositing, security or proper window management. Fair enough, they're all valid complaints. Wayland's solution to the dog bite seems to be pulling the teeth off the dog though, and I don't really agree with a lot of the design philosophy that went into making it. It reminds me of the recent GNOME releases, where their solution to inconsistent user theming and poor extension support was just to remove both features altogether. The trap that a lot of modern Linux developers seem to fall into is fragmenting their userbase under the guise of "finally fixing" some pain point or bug, and cutting off the users who disagree with them instead of Doing One Thing, and Doing It Well. Everyone is big-picture these days, wanting to take giant leaps for the Linux desktop experience without really considering how extensible or feature-complete their program is, and slamming the "f*ck it, ship it" button before it's ready.
Admittedly, there's not an elegant solution to any of this. However, in this specific example, I think the best course of action would have been to just outright plagiarize Apple's Quartz. The development cycle for Wayland has been painful to say the least, and a lot of it came from wildly unnecessary breaking changes, vendor apprehension and arguments about ideology that really shouldn't have wasted our time in the first place. Now that it's "ready", there's a couple hundred asterisks following every feature, and the experience is generally shaky enough to keep me fearful of God and contented with x11, no matter how bad it is.
Edit: Quick shoutout to PipeWire while I'm here, for actually creating a crowd-pleasing solution where nobody had to be thrown under the bus. They were given a herculean task of unifying 4 different audio standards, and they shipped it when it was ready instead of letting it languish in development hell. The result was fantastic, and distro uptake was almost immediate. If more projects were like PW, we wouldn't be here having this conversation right now.
- encryptluks2 5y agoThat is a lot of writing without linking to actual detailed issues you are having. It is complaining while making it near impossible for anyone to help you or figure out exactly what your issues are to try to resolve them.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoI read it fine, it removes/isolates a lot of useful features, and doesn't seem better in many real world use cases it is worst, like clipboard, screen warmers like redshift, global hotkeys, and VNC. I have tried these as addons, and they basically suck, and its complex to change them, and for what benefit? Some smoother graphics? I am on Linux, that is the least important thing. Basically if it doesn't give me real world benefits, I am unlikely to want to switch, and if it gives me more issues and less features for things that matter and isn't a drop in replacement it might as well be a scooter to my car.
- craftinator 5y ago> and for what benefit? Some smoother graphics? I am on Linux, that is the least important thing. This really sums up this side of the argument for me (though it doesn't address the security features of Wayland). If I want to watch an ultra high definition movie, or play a game, rebooting to windows is a miniscule price. Almost all of my work is done on Linux, and I value it because everything can be made to work, usually with little effort. Wayland adds some severe overhead to that work.
- GhettoComputers 5y agohttps://old.reddit.com/r/VFIO/comments/n3mjj3/native_vs_vm_benchmarks_using_passthrough_for_gpu/ https://old.reddit.com/r/VFIO/comments/n3mjj3/native_vs_vm_b... you can also do this. If you want to use wayland without issues GNOME works well if you wanna login to another session, VFIO will give you full windows game support (Win VM will use the GPU in windows driver mode). For anyone who wants a functional desktop on any DE, x.org is the best, and cannot be replaced currently by wayland in features or software compatibility.
- 1_player 5y ago> If I want to watch an ultra high definition movie, or play a game, rebooting to windows is a miniscule price. So you're saying let's not improve the Linux desktop because one can just reboot into Windows to do desktop things? What even is that argument? I want to have a nice desktop on Linux, thank you very much.
- dijit 5y ago“Not upgrades”? DPI scaling and full screen playback without screen tearing are pretty huge upgrades. You might argue that it’s not worth overhauling everything for that, but it’s undeniably a huge quality difference and was one of the major reasons I moved to wayland. Having a 1080p screen and a 4K screen “just work” has been my reality for a few years now - to the point where I get surprised when people talk about it as if it’s an issue. I do have screen sharing issues though. With basically everything.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoI can do font scaling in x.org, my screens also just work. I have DPI scaling but it doesn't seem to be switch when I take my laptop off the dock. Wayland sessions seem smoother, most software I use isn't adapted to the new model yet, and for the cost of losing my global hotkeys, redshift, and other useful things that matter, its not worth it to see smoother animations, I'd rather turn them off. Edit: I never had screen tearing on video.
- dijit 5y agoRedshift -> Gammastep Hot keys are handled by the compositor. Global ones especially. (Apps stealing keystrokes? Sounds like an anti feature) Point stands. But I’d rather we work on improving things than just living with X11- it’s like continually adapting token ring networks instead of embracing star topology. It’s fundamentally difficult or impossible to fix. The wayland authors (who are former X11 devs) talked about this extensively.
- AshamedCaptain 5y ago> Apps stealing keystrokes? Sounds like an anti feature Sounds like that right until the user tries to press Alt Tab on a full-screen VNC or VM client.
- dijit 5y agoAlt tab not being stolen might be jarring. But I’d rather not have apps overriding the compositor because then I might not be able to escape them. There is some comfort in the universality of many things.
- jgb1984 5y agoThank you for putting this into words. Wayland solves problems I never had, while creating new ones at the same time. I'll stick to Xorg + openbox for as long as I can.
- kllrnohj 5y ago> and cutting off the users who disagree with them instead of Doing One Thing, and Doing It Well Your complaint is the opposite. You're complaining that Wayland is trying to do one thing & do it well instead of trying to be a kitchen sink. X11 is the antithesis of Unix philosophy. It tries to do a hundred unrelated things (compositing, clipboard, drawing, input, etc...) > Admittedly, there's not an elegant solution to any of this. However, in this specific example, I think the best course of action would have been to just outright plagiarize Apple's Quartz. Or Windows' DWM. Or Android's SurfaceFlinger. Android being Apache 2 would have been the more obvious one to take code/design from in this case, but desktop Linux seems to have a general disdain for anything coming from Android.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago>X11 is the antithesis of Unix philosophy. It tries to do a hundred unrelated things (compositing, clipboard, drawing, input, etc...) And it works. Do you avoid desktop environments since they do everything, emacs which might as well be an OS, or music players that can also rename music too? Is a messenger app something you will never use if you can call or send music or pictures on it? My file manager can rename files, show pictures, rename them, and even open compressed files. Why is the Unix philosophy relevant when most linux systems use systemd? Do you even follow "Unix philosophy"? Installing a bunch of plugins to make wayland do 100 unrelated things is the same result.
- pantalaimon 5y agoActually Gnome 2 was really nice about that modularity. You could swap out the panel, the window manager or the file manager as you pleased. That's what really turned me off Gnome 3, they basically threw away an entire ecosystem of third party apps. MATE was able to pick of some of that, but especially when it comes to third party support, that level was never reached.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoXFCE still has that in it, and there are DE that are pick and choose, but I find it hilarious that having useful features means Unix philosophy is being violated and its and its bad that it has functionality that users enjoy.
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago+1 for pipewire it's a monument on how things should be done, without breaking anyone's workflow. edit: I really want to use Wayland, it is so much better for so many things, it looks better, font rendering is better, scaling is better, but it introduces new bugs that really are a no-go in my day to day usage, for example sometimes copy&paste shortcuts don't work. I'm sure it's the fact that I use KDE and support is not top notch, but I have no such problems on X.org. I would really love to see Wayland succeed, but how long is it gonna take?
- AshamedCaptain 5y agoYes, I am very positively surprised. I always though PulseAudio was growing to be one of these "too big to rewrite" projects. And PipeWire started with a premise that was very off-putting to me ("The PulseAudio of Video"). But I was tired of filing PulseAudio bugs (e.g. HFP support which never went anywhere), so I decided to try. Not only PipeWire turned out to be a purely drop-in replacement (not a single feature broke, and Bluetooth support started working correctly), but I immediately gained new power-user friendly features even while keeping the same clients! Like the ability to choose the codec used for A2DP. And then the small improvements started trickling in, such as absolute volume support in headsets. The stupid PA limitation of only being able to configure the 1st ALSA mixer element. And so on and so forth.
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago> and Bluetooth support started working correctly) For me it was mainly this! My Bluetooth headphones kept disconnecting randomly and the microphone never worked properly, no matter how many conf tweaks I tried. I installed pipewire in anger, expecting nothing and it magically solved every issue. Yes, my headphones are not expensive devices, but looks like that wasn't the problem, pulseaudio was! I sent them some money out of happiness and now I am lobbying for it at work.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoThat was truly a killer feature. Sadly I have 2 similar pairs and one I cannot change the audio quality on sadly, but wow it really works seamlessly to replace pulseaudio.
- throw7 5y agoWe need a Lennart to say 'fuck it', here's what I want, here's why, and I'm gonna do it. Unfortunately I don't think a whole gui display environment is in the cards for one person. Wayland is also missing that one cool feature that makes people say: yes, I want that; I need that. And I KNOW I don't want Gnome 3.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago>Wayland is also missing that one cool feature that makes people say: yes, I want that; I need that. Its new! That's good enough for a lot of adopters. Gamers (on linux lol) might care about graphics. Wayland is however feature rich in having more people see it as a less functional software and when I tried it, I appreciated x.org more and more. Edit: Gnome and wayland give slow mouse movements and can crash if you move mouse too fast.
- sph 5y ago> Wayland is also missing that one cool feature It has one killer and necessary feature. It's smooth. Have you tried resizing a window under X11 and doing it under Wayland? I have hated those half drawn rectangles caused by X and the app not being synchronized for DECADES. In 2021 I can have a GUI that's almost as smooth as Windows 7 was. I feel the rift in the Linux world grows bigger between the conservatives (fuck systemd! X11 was alright!) and the progressives (can I have HDR, fractional scaling, and hardware video acceleration on YouTube, please?). I want my computer to be modern and slick and fluid, I'm vain like that. Yes, Wayland is still a beta, but it's here to stay, like systemd, like flatpak, like pipewire. There was no status quo before, X11 was a beta and crappy in other ways. Not suited for modern hardware. Deal with it. The xorg repo is there for anybody that thinks they can do better than Wayland. The reason why xorg had to be abandoned is a Google search away.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago>I feel the rift in the Linux world grows bigger between the conservatives (fuck systemd! X11 was alright!) and the progressives (can I have HDR, fractional scaling, and hardware video acceleration on YouTube, please?). I want my computer to be modern and slick and fluid, I'm vain like that. I have fractional DPI scaling in x.org, I just don't use it since undocking keeps it on that on my small screen. I use systemd, pipewire, x.org, and never follow unix philosophy with my desktop environment not because I am some sort of political standard you set arbitrarily, I just use stuff that just works, like most computer users. > The reason why xorg had to be abandoned is a Google search away. Its mostly because you can't make it more perfect, but they did! https://www.gamingonlinux.com/2021/10/xorg-2110-sees-a-release-with-variable-refresh-rate-support-in-the-modesetting-driver/ https://www.gamingonlinux.com/2021/10/xorg-2110-sees-a-relea... >After three years without a full release, X.Org 21.1.0 has finally landed with new features and a lot of bug fixes. While the next-generation for all Linux systems will eventually be Wayland, plenty still default to X.Org. I really dislike how you turn linux into politics, announce it isn't suitable for modern hardware with zero reason, saying x11 (actually x.org was crappy as if the whole thread isn't talking about how much crappier wayland is) and deal with it. Leave your feelings at home.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> They were given a herculean task of unifying 4 different audio standards, Which 4? Also, it's not fully ready for the pro-audio side at this point.