3 ms·
Aren't there entire abandoned cities, and yet-to-be-filled suburb developments in the world? Are autonomous driving companies not using those, stuffed full of "
by pavel_lishin 5y ago
Aren't there entire abandoned cities, and yet-to-be-filled suburb developments in the world? Are autonomous driving companies not using those, stuffed full of "stunt" drivers who are employed to do nothing but simulate regular city traffic?
- xvedejas 5y agoWhat would that accomplish? The goal is for these cars to self-drive in locations where people live, and that does include mapping those locations over many drives. Autonomous vehicles still have a good safety record, and California's willingness to suspend a permit when nobody was injured does signal to me that they'll take it very seriously when a company's safety record falters.
- Syonyk 5y agoThe current state of self driving cars can't handle basic, well behaved, standard traffic. There's no way it's ready for the sort of adversarial stuff you'd get hiring a bunch of people to drive around simulating traffic for a car. I guarantee it's a great way to find out how your car is at dealing with being cut off, at people running stop signs, etc - and there's certainly value in doing that. Just, not while you still can't avoid hitting stationary objects along the edge of the road.
- KennyBlanken 5y ago> The current state of self driving cars can't handle basic, well behaved, standard traffic. Some self-driving cars can't. At one end, you have the Uber self-driving vehicles which were caught committing numerous traffic offenses by dashcams and cyclist helmet cams within the first days of their illegally testing their fleet on public roads, and then one of their cars ran over a pedestrian that the vehicle's sensors detected but the computers misclassified, somehow - and Uber had disabled the SUV's own auto-braking systems that probably would have saved the woman's life. At the other end you have Google's self-driving cars have had, I think one at-fault crash across the entire fleet in many, many years and millions of miles of testing? They've been involved in a lot of crashes, but every single one until their one slow-speed scrape with a bus was the fault of another driver. That was 5 years ago or so. Somewhere in-between is Tesla's FSD "Beta" which, as has been shown by numerous youtube videos (at least, the ones that Tesla doesn't abuse DMCA to take down), behaves extremely erratically repeatedly in the space of less than half an hour in an urban environment. This includes veering off a turn at pedestrians on a curb corner, and in another incident veering toward a light pole. In general, it seems to have a lot of problems making turns.
- adrr 5y agoCruise and waymo can go tens of thousands of miles without safety driver intervention.
- deepsun 5y agoAirport shuttles already have driven millions miles. No driver seat nor wheel.
- Jensson 5y agoYou really under estimate how much externalized risks some people are willing to accept. If people can save millions by risking others lives then many will do so. This is why we have regulations, such as this permit process which is basically the government saying "your technology needs further testing".
- oblio 5y agoHeck, many industries are based on pollution or addiction: tobacco, alcohol, fossil fuels, casinos, sports gambling, etc. Basically stuff the owners don't do, but they're perfectly fine if it happens to others (for the pollution bit, I'm reasonably sure the stakeholders and executives live in nice, low pollution areas).
- gresrun 5y agoWaymo built a bespoke, 113 acre facility for this very purpose back in 2017[0][1]. Full disclosure: Google employee, working on nothing to do with Waymo. [0]: https://blog.waymo.com/2020/09/the-waymo-drivers-training-regime.html https://blog.waymo.com/2020/09/the-waymo-drivers-training-re... [1]: https://www.wired.com/story/google-waymo-self-driving-car-castle-testing/ https://www.wired.com/story/google-waymo-self-driving-car-ca...
- Jensson 5y agoGoogle did that, but there are no regulations forcing everyone who build self driving cars to do that.
- nradov 5y agoDARPA did that in 2007, testing autonomous vehicles in realistic urban conditions using an abandoned Air Force base in California.
- dreamcompiler 5y agoHere's one of them. It's a modern, former company town now used by DHS for counterterrorism training, but AFAIK it's not used for self-driving car testing. Maybe because it's too far from the Bay Area or it's just not well-known. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Playas,_New_Mexico https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Playas,_New_Mexico