3 ms·
Agreed. It would be interesting to see how those European cities do it. I don't recall feeling obstructed by it, the way I do in US cities recently (I don't min
by wolverine876 5y ago
Agreed. It would be interesting to see how those European cities do it. I don't recall feeling obstructed by it, the way I do in US cities recently (I don't mind it, but I notice it).
IME, in Europe, the outdoor dining is usually directly adjascent the restaurant (in the US, it's often on the curb side of the sidewalk), though that is really speculation based on limited experience. Perhaps that is actually on restaurant property, and they set back the indoor structure. Or perhaps European sidewalks were built with that capacity in mind.
Also, perhaps the US, usually more restrictive with alchohol, has been less accepting of drinking in public. It doesn't seem like a problem to me, but then I hardly ever see anyone drinking in public. A city block with lots of restaurants and drinkers?
> Sometimes, that asshole Chesterton put up a fence without a good reason at all.
I find that is very rarely the case, especially for rules widespread across the country. Usually 'no good reason' means 'no reason I know' or 'not a reason I care about'.
- xyzzyz 5y agoResidents of San Francisco have not been in my experience shy about drinking in public, or, for that matter, shooting fentanyl or defecating. These are rather everyday occurrences in the city, so I imagine people can handle some outdoor dining in restaurants too.
- wolverine876 5y agoA good point, though many on HN aren't so happy about those outdoor activities.
- xyzzyz 5y agoAlas, they get worst of both worlds: the city government is doing little about those shooting heroin on the sidewalk, because it is too busy focusing on the scourge of urban life, that is, restaurants offering sidewalk dining.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe talking points are endlessly repeated, but does that make them true? What makes this true?
- xyzzyz 5y agoThis is true, because the restaurants and other businesses actually have something to lose when they defy the petty tyranny of the city planning bureau. The bureau knows this, and it doesn’t like the idea of losing the power it has, so it comes down hard to punish those who do not kowtow to it. On the other hand, the heroin addicts don’t really have anything to lose, other than freedom to roam around the city. Since city is not interested in depriving them of that freedom (as jailing the homeless addicts for disorderly conduct would be inhumane, according to San Franciscans), it has no tools to actually incentivize different behavior — it has no punishments left, and so it’s left powerless.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> The bureau knows this, and it doesn’t like the idea of losing the power it has, I don't think government-bureaucracy-as-a-person-with-desires is a useful way to think or talk about this stuff.
- xyzzyz 5y agoAlas, the bureau is the people running it.
- wolverine876 5y agoHow about the law, their superiors, the politics, institutional culture, etc. No CEO has the power you ascribe to these people.
- Guvante 5y agoAs the article hints at alcohol is likely the distinction between the two. It specifically calls out that liquor licenses are the beaucratic hurdle that is hardest to overcome.
- dougmwne 5y agoSomething else to point out is that outdoor dining has positive externalities as well. Streets with lots of people on them sitting, watching, instagramming, are safer and better observed than empty streets or streets with just cars. The permitting process is so focused on preventing the negative that there is no advocate of the positive.
- raxxorrax 5y agoWhy security again? Fresh air would do it. People being afraid constantly are in need of some serious punching, they can be afraid of that for all I care. Policies of the last decades were constantly focused to cater to schizophrenic needs. Security isn't advocating something positive since it implies that you would need it.
- dougmwne 5y agoWhich would you rather walk down as a single woman, a street empty other than a single man or a street full of sidewalk cafes and people? While the safety could be argued to be more perceived than real, (though I doubt that, it’s city street smarts 101 not to walk down dark empty alleys in the middle of the night), that increase in people’s comfort leads to the positives, healthy vibrant street life, pleasant utilization of public space, and walkability.
- raxxorrax 5y agoDepends on location and country but I don't want to further the notion that it is unsafe for women to walk down a street alone because it is not the reality in most modern societies. Trying to accommodate irrational fears is often not helpful, it can even be abusive because you validate these fears. This is even a common mechanism to isolate people in abusive relationships. Don't go outside, there is danger in every dark alley! Some other women might just try emphasize their vulnerability to fish for a protector. How evil of them, but hard to be angry about that. If you always accommodate people for their comfort, you refuse them growth. As I said, it depends on the location. The locations that don't have the problem did not solve it by arbitrary security mechanisms.