9 ms·
Managed by Bots: surveillance of gig economy workers
- ghgr 5y agoIt reminds me of the short story "Manna – Two Views of Humanity’s Future" [1], which describes the steady establishment of AI process optimizers as the managers of human employees, who increasingly became a replaceable commodity. Fascinating read. [1] https://marshallbrain.com/manna1 https://marshallbrain.com/manna1
- AussieWog93 5y agoFunny you mention that. I've felt the same thing when going on Uber Eats runs with my mate who drives for them. At the moment, the technology is in the "chapter 1" stage where things are pretty smooth and chill. It's genuinely low-stress, well-paced work. Once self-driving tech hits the market, though, it's clear that the human employees will be replaced without a care or thought for their well-being.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoNot if they unionize, and it's hard to offshore delivery drivers. I guess autonomous driving cars will be an option?
- retube 5y agoSo? Ever since the industrial revolution new technology has obsoleted jobs. 98% of us used to be farmers. Excel put gazillions of book-keepers out of work. But we're still at basically full employment: there's thousands of jobs now no one could have conceived of 50 years ago, or even 20 years ago. Self-driving cars (if indeed they actually materialise) will be hugely transformative for society, and create whole new businesses and industries, i.e. new jobs to replace the old. Progress fundamentally relies on this "creative destruction", without it we'd still be in caves scavenging for nuts and berries. Edit: it's kind of bonkers that pointing out the basic mechanics of technological progress is getting downvoted on a site like HN, where I imagine most of us are gainfully employed trying to do just this.
- credittw2021 5y agoOtoh the last few decades have led to automation replacing well paying jobs with mcJobs.
- retube 5y agoMaybe in some localised areas. Globally tho absolutely not; in recent years huge numbers of people have been pulled into the middle classes, probably a 1bn+ in India and China, and Africa is now the fastest growing economy, with the world bank expecting most countries to reach "middle income" status by 2025.
- JoachimS 5y agoAnd replacing entry level academic jobs with machines - adding a barrier of entry for freshly baked lawyers.
- derekjdanserl 5y ago>So? So much for humanity benefitting from technology. Instead of our workdays becoming fewer and shorter, a tiny number of people who don’t work at all will become richer while our lives become more alienated from our labor. This is the opposite of what we tell each other technology is supposed to accomplish. If it’s not a problem, why do we keep lying about?
- FDSGSG 5y agoYou are describing some speculative future that doesn't really correlate with historical progress. Same could've been said about the industrial revolution, but somehow it did end up dramatically benefitting all of humanity.
- nopenopenopeno 5y agoAgain, that is the story we well, but it’s a very reckless claim. Generations in early industrialization who still remembered life as a peasant almost universally preferred life as a peasant. Industrialization’s need for labor forced other peasants from their land to build competing modern nation states. Very few people asked for this and only a small wealthy few would tell you that dragging these people into brutal toiling factory labor improved everybody’s lives, but those are the people who funded the history books.
- JoachimS 5y agoGood pointer, and a good short story.
- mikro2nd 5y agoWhen I first read Dune, 'lo those many years ago, I always thought of the Butlerian Jihad as being somewhere in our far future. Now, I'm not so sure...
- pessimizer 5y agoWhen I first read it, I realized was probably a Butlerian jihadist. "Computers" are unfortunately named after the least important thing that they do (accounting.) What's important about them is that they are allow us to generalize and add infinite complexity to autonomous control systems, like valves that open when a certain pressure is reached, or switches that toggle at a certain light level. The ultimate computer network would keep the king that implemented it in power for eternity, even after his death, by keeping his will alive. If you automated his corpse, you wouldn't even need to know that the king could die. edit: "Ordenador" (from Spain) is probably better, i.e the thing/person that gives orders, or puts things in order. Maybe "mandónador"...
- monkeybutton 5y agoI've been seeing more and more references to this story over the last few years which is a sign.. Of something. It would be really interesting to see the Http referrer logs his website gets for it. Probably a great collection of threads about everywhere this kind of automation is happening.
- streamofdigits 5y agoHow can it be that the most predatory elements of society have been given so much leeway? This is not an intrinsic pattern of our species / societies or we would have devoured ourselves literally or figuratively long time ago. Obviously restoring forces that would push this evil genie back in its bottle exist but are somehow dormant, neutralized or otherwise missing-in-action. This fight and push-back should not be a thing for "activists". It affects every single person. We are all "gig workers".
- caddybox 5y agoThis is my personal opinion. We have been devouring each other for ages now. Entire cultures have vanished, destroyed by more powerful members of the same species. The entire history of our species has been on violent conflict where a stronger group removes a weaker group, only to be removed later by another group that emerges stronger. Previously it was racial, clan-based violence. Now it's economic servitude where a perpetually unfortunate lower class keeps on greasing the wheels of industry with sweat and blood. The rich stay rich, the poor stay poor. We are not benevolent or kind creatures. We are programmed to survive. As long as the poor live, they will rarely question the rationality behind the inequality that keeps them poor.
- Applejinx 5y agoNo, you overlook the mutual aid factor. We are non-benevolent AND benevolent, unkind AND kind creatures. Hence the inability ever to settle on one explanation. Either direction you go, you're in error unless you account for both. It becomes an existential crisis when humanity designs bots and AI and then behaves like humanity must COMPETE with the AI in order to survive, when we absolutely can't. We can't lift better than a forklift, run faster than a Veyron, we can't think better than Big Data. For the time being we're still able to dream better. For now. Android dreams won't speak to us. But there's no reason we can't pass on our capacity for mutual aid to the AI, as well as the competitiveness. And there's no reason the AI can't have heart and soul. When it fails it's because WE try to construct it in a false image of what we think we are.
- streamofdigits 5y ago
- i_like_waiting 5y agoTo be honest, I just realized I am culpable in this area. So far its small things for small company: e.g. automated alerts when checklist is not filled for selected day, information in 1 system is not matching with info in second system. By themselves those things look innocent, and just automate my headache of writing emails to correct the info. What will it be 2-3 years for now? For sure automated penalization system in case you don't do those things correctly. Do I have enough morality to not do those alerts/ "small productivity hacks" for me and do it manually for greater good instead? Tbh I need to think about it.
- simion314 5y agoI would say that first thing you should do is to make sure the emails/notifications you send contain all information needed that the affected person knows what he did wrong and also contain a way to dispute. We need to push against broken system that abuse us, like in my case I got an email from Sony that I violated a super generic rule and my account is suspended for 2 months, with no way to dispute this and sure enough no refunds or compensation for my currently paid and active yearly subscription. (this can happen to any of us is not only Google/Apple/PayPal/Amazon that can screw you with their automation and shit customer support , the list is much larger and probably growing)
- spaetzleesser 5y ago“I would say that first thing you should do is to make sure the emails/notifications you send contain all information needed that the affected person knows what he did wrong and also contain a way to dispute.” This should become law. Otherwise we end up in Kafka’s “The Trial” world.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> This should become law I'd like to see that too, but I think it's... unlikely. In the case of OP, he lost access to his Sony account (I assume that's an online gaming platform) and there were monetary damages included, but imagine a generic "you can't be suspended from an online account without a way to dispute with an actual human person" law applied to, say, Facebook or Twitter or Reddit?
- stevenjgarner 5y agoThere is an avalanche of gig economy employee management and monitoring software (Teramind, ActivTrak, Ekran System, BrowseReporter, workpuls, Cerebral, monday.com, DeskTime, Time Doctor, etc). Many of these systems contain algorithms that surveil and manage workers. These tools eliminate much of the risk of outsourcing work to remote workers that cannot be directly supervised. They enable the remote workers by making them eligible for employment, and engineering a higher degree of trust into the relationship.
- afandian 5y agoI would dearly like to see legislation that means that non-human supervision constitutes an elevated a risk to the employer. e.g. UK Data Protection Act 2018 A controller may not take a significant decision based solely on automated processing unless that decision is required or authorised by law. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2018/12/part/3/chapter/3/crossheading/automated-individual-decisionmaking/enacted https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2018/12/part/3/chapter/...
- stevenjgarner 5y ago... and to the employee?
- Applejinx 5y agoFor the time being that's a given.
- willcipriano 5y agoI don't think it even needs to go that far, if you choose to delagate your descion making to a machine you should be as responsible for whatever results from that, it is your role to ensure the machine is making the right choices.
- afandian 5y agoI think it's a harmful act of technological hubris to suggest that it's possible. Employment is a human relationship. I don't see much evidence that humans are able to construct a system that can respond to all of the human interaction that goes into a human relationship. Look at the state of the art of HR software, let alone spyware. Let the robot managers for manage robots.
- ape4 5y agoA small example: I had a Uber driver who was afraid to deviate from the app-selected route even though he could see an obstruction.
- Bayart 5y agoThat page had me download over 11000 elements and 80MB.
- agustif 5y agohttps://marshallbrain.com/manna1 https://marshallbrain.com/manna1 https://marshallbrain.com/manna2 https://marshallbrain.com/manna2 https://marshallbrain.com/manna3 https://marshallbrain.com/manna3
- monkeydust 5y agoRecommend reading this paper which introduces the concept of 'pre-automation' https://sociologica.unibo.it/article/view/11657 https://sociologica.unibo.it/article/view/11657 Helps understand (for me at least) what's going on here
- Havoc 5y agoHappened to be reading a photo essay about delivery drivers [0] today and was struck by how intensely vulnerable the workers are. e.g. Saying he knows 5 people that died and non that have filed insurance claims. i.e. They're not even bothering with the shiny "support" processes the companies put in place. Sure that is in a dangerous country, but still says a lot about the people that are (by necessity) attracted to these jobs. It's not just the algo angle...the entire system isn't fit for purpose. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/13/ghost-riders-the-invisible-lives-of-johannesburg-food-couriers-photo-essay https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/13/ghost-riders-t...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ammonammonammon 5y agoOne step closer to Elysium ...
- Animats 5y agoMachines should think. People should work. That's the new reality. How far away is an AI system that supervises web developers?
- fxtentacle 5y agoThat video at the end is interesting both for its content and for its delivery technology. And I do agree with him: If whether you get work or not decides on a black box AI and your only support channel is another black box AI, that is pretty much a Kafka-esque nightmare. I'd guess we here on HN are the people best equipped to prevent the worst. So the next time you help someone automate their customer support, ask yourself: How would I feel if my well-being depended on this? Because for some poor soul, it might. Is there a clear fall-back in case the AI fails horrible? Because, you know, they always do. I once had my own support automation problem with Amazon, but luckily I had no stakes in it. They accidentally sent me someone else's parcel. So I filed a support request to inform them. They very politely apologized within a minute and informed me that they are sorry about my lost parcel and they'll send another one. So I got the same wrong parcel again. After waiting a while, I opened up the two parcels, each roughly 10x5x5 inches (25x10x10 cm) large. It was two single pencil erasers. But boy would I have been furious if I had received the same support quality for a lost high-value parcel... Also, I did ponder if it is OK for Amazon to waste my time if I'm not even their customer. I mean their support forms are difficult to reach, no matter why you need to contact them.
- konschubert 5y agoAny automated process always needs human fallback.
- syshum 5y agoGoogle, Amazon, and the rest clearly disagree
- konschubert 5y agoYes, and it's a kafkaesque nightmare. I try to avoid Google for this reason.
- Maf1 5y agoOr will we live in a world where the computer is always right.