9 ms·
Again, it's highly problematic defining mobility as "moving from bottom quintile to top quintile". - Moving from bottom quintile to 2nd highest is significant
by refurb 5y ago
Again, it's highly problematic defining mobility as "moving from bottom quintile to top quintile".
- Moving from bottom quintile to 2nd highest is significant mobility and completely ignored in this analysis.
- The analysis ignores the fact that the highest quintile in the US is higher in absolute terms than other countries. So moving from bottom to 4th may give more income than bottom to 5th in other countries.
- This analysis also ignores the changes of income within quintiles. The 3rd quintile in 1980 isn't the same income in 2020. 3rd quintile could see significant income improvements.
- This analysis also ignores government transfers.
- Countries that have a lower income spread, but overall less income would do better.
- jeffbee 5y ago" - [blah blah ignorance] ignored in this analysis" Q1-Q4 mobility is not ignored, it's right there in Table 2 of the paper. For your information the U.S. is also worst among the five studied nations for Q1-Q4 mobility. Furthermore the U.S. is also worst for Q1-Q3. HTH.
- dataflow 5y agoThe paper isn't linked in the article (I think the parent was referring to the article). I think you're referring to the paper here: https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/stantcheva/files/alesina_stantcheva_teso_mobility.pdf#page=12 https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/stantcheva/files/alesina_s... Looking at it myself now, it doesn't seem like the US is all that different from the other countries examined, e.g. US 12.7% Q1->Q4 vs. 12.9% for UK vs. 12.8% for France. For Q1->Q3 it's somewhat higher (18.7% vs. 19.9% for UK for example) but for Q1->Q2 the US is also higher than the others (e.g., 27.7% US vs. 25.1% UK).
- twoodfin 5y agoIndeed. Some quick digging came up with UK figures from 2019[1]: Average in Q1: £13,300 Average in Q4: £35,700 For US stats, Googling only got 2018 figures[2]: Average in Q1: $13,775 Average in Q4: $101,570 So there’s a big absolute distinction hiding behind those similar relative %’s. [1] https://www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/work-pay-and-benefits/pay-and-income/income-distribution/latest https://www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/work-pay-... [2] https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/household-income-quintiles https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/household-income-...
- Railsify 5y agoThank you. The article is using statistics to lie.
- syki 5y agoRead the actual study. The people who did the study are knowledgeable about the topic. If a non expert can think of a problem with the paper after a few moments of thinking about it then it is highly likely that person’s objections are not valid and are accounted for in the study. A person should not read the study or the article and think, “The reason this is nonsense is X.” Rather the thought should be, “I wonder how the study accounts for X.”
- savant_penguin 5y agoThis is possible, but it's also possible that they are just lying too Some studies use household income over years to """prove""" that incomes have either fallen or stagnated. They just outright ignore that the size of the household went from 6+ to about 4. In this scenario a constant household income meant about 50% increase in per Capita income
- missedthecue 5y agoPlenty of knowledgeable people have very motivated reasoning
- syki 5y ago
- thomasahle 5y agoThe story is not so much about the US's (low) social mobility, but about how Americans perceive it. The effect of "Americans are much more optimistic about social mobility" seems to be the same if you look at other measures, like "Probability of remaining in the bottom quintile". (Except Q2 -> Q1 mobility, which Americans seem more pessimistic about for some reason.)
- ryandrake 5y agoThere was a survey[1] a while ago where 19% of Americans said they were in the top 1%, and 20% more believed they would later become the 1%. That adds up to 39% of Americans who are either irrationally optimistic or who failed statistics. It's kind of like how everyone thinks they are an above-average driver and are a top performer at work. 1: https://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-hope-over-self-interest.html https://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-ho...
- forgotmyoldname 5y agoI mean... that doesn't detract from the problem at all. That just says there's a massive wealth divide and that moving up to the mere top 20% (the group 1 out of 5 people belong to) should be considered a ridiculous proposition unless you're born into it. Why should 1 out of 5 people belong to a group so wealthy that saying mobility is difficult should be considered problematic?
- csallen 5y ago> Why should 1 out of 5 people belong to a group so wealthy that saying mobility is difficult should be considered problematic? Why is it a bad thing that so many people are so wealthy? The more people who belong to the so-wealthy-it's-hard-to-achieve group, the better.
- inetknght 5y ago> Why is it a bad thing that so many people are that wealthy? In the USA's case: for every one person who is that wealthy there are dozens of people struggling to put food on the table.
- csallen 5y ago12% of Americans struggle from food insecurity. By definition, 20% of Americans are in the top quintile. I'm with you, I want that first number to be as close to 0% as possible. But it's mathematically untrue that there are dozens of Americans starving for every American in the top 20%. In fact, there are barely half as many.
- inetknght 5y agoI count myself to be lucky in the top 20% of earners in America and have friends who also fit in the range. I've met a lot of people who struggle to put food on the table whose income is in the middle 50%. A lot of them have the same complaint: they don't qualify for help because they make too much. But they also struggle to pay their bills because they don't make enough. I don't know where you think 12% of Americans "struggle from food insecurity". But I don't trust your numbers because my anecdata says different.
- pentae 5y agoThe economist has been pushing a certain political agenda for a while now, I cancelled my subscription a while ago because of this reason
- rsynnott 5y agoI think you're possibly thinking about this the wrong way. The story here isn't "noted communist magazine the Economist is trailblazing by writing about social mobility problems", it's "social mobility has become such a problem that even _the Economist_ is now covering it". This isn't a new concern, by any means, and at this point I would think that _most_ serious media has covered it; the Economist is just grudgingly catching up. Note that they couldn't resist trying to find a bright side (the numbers are still quite _bad_, just not as bad as people think they are): > But in Europe, climbing the ladder is easier than most people believe
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoYou didn't consider that this quite old publication, renowned for its conservative market-friendly op-eds and neutral-as-can-be reporting, may have realized that wealth inequality and lack of social mobility is a bit more important than they used to think?
- niels_olson 5y agoYou should probably read the actual analysis (free, 40+ page paper), they accounted for all sorts of things. https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/aer.20162015 https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/aer.20162015
- alex_young 5y agoThe other side of the coin would be data about how overwhelmingly likely it is to retain one's membership in the top quintile by mere dint of being born into it. It seems grotesque that many are born and stay very wealthy while so many others have little to no chance of ever experiencing even modest prosperity. Another observation: No other quintile has actually grown its percentage of household wealth since the 1970s. The wealthy really have taken all of the gains. Perhaps it would be healthy for us to share some with the people who do all of the physical labor. https://www.statista.com/statistics/203247/shares-of-household-income-of-quintiles-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/203247/shares-of-househo...
- seventytwo 5y agoHow is it problematic and not just an arbitrary metric? You also presuppose that everything should be relative to absolute terms. What evidence do you have that social mobility should be relative to absolute terms rather than relative to the quintiles defined by the society a given person lives in? Why would we expect mobility in absolute terms for a society that ranges from 1-100 in wealth, compared to a society than ranges from 40-50? We should expect mobility to be with respect to the society’s wealth range.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI read about another study relatively recently (maybe it was HN? Not sure.) that talked about some of the fundamental flaws when looking at these types of economic mobility studies (i.e. change of moving from bottom quintile to top quintile, etc.) because they usually only look at income and ignore social class. That is, suppose Bob is a rich banker. His kid Frank goes to private school and on to an Ivy League college, but seeing how distant and money-focused his dad was growing up, Frank decides to become a writer. Frank is certainly not poor, but he definitely lives on a very modest income and that is what his son John experiences growing up. John, not wanting to have to be in as modest circumstances as his Dad, decides to follow in his grandfather's footsteps and become a banker. His grandfather is even able to introduce him to some colleagues and get him some interviews at top investment banks. Point being, if you just look at income, it will look like a dynamic economy with lots of economic mobility, with each generation moving from the top to the bottom of the economic latter, and vice versa. In reality, though, nothing really changed at all about their social class and the opportunities that were open to them. Unlike most people in the bottom half of the economic spectrum, Frank was basically there by choice. Again, you may think this is an extreme example, but in my experience I have seen some version of that multiple times.
- derangedHorse 5y agoI don't think the amount of "rich" people (and their descendants) are a significant enough proportion of the population to render the results completely inert.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Swizec 5y agoIt’s easy to choose the artist life if your parents can bail you out when shit happens. A little harder if you’re expected to be the bail out for your parents.
- Jensson 5y agoLots of poor people live with their parents, you see that all over the world. Also lots of rich people disown their kids. That has more to do with the mentality of your parents than anything else.
- wahern 5y ago> This analysis also ignores government transfers. AFAIU, by dollar amount government transfers in the U.S. are roughly comparable to those in most European countries. However, a disproportionate amount of those transfers are spent on medical care, a consequence of the high cost of medical care in the U.S. Moreover, a disproportionate amount of government medical spending goes toward the elderly and small, high risk groups. IOW, even at comparable dollar amounts, government transfers in the U.S. simply don't provide the same sort of secure economic footing that people can use to get ahead in some other countries.
- refurb 5y agoDisagree. The biggest transfer is cash through the EITC. If you're eligible for EITC, you're likely eligible for Medicaid which has near-zero out of pocket costs for medical care. I keep hearing how the US has a "non-existant safety net" yet can help but notice safety net programs are more than half the federal budget.
- wahern 5y ago> The biggest transfer is cash through the EITC. Per Wikipedia, "At a cost of $56 billion in 2013, the EITC is the third-largest social welfare program in the United States after Medicaid ($275 billion federal and $127 billion state expenditures) and food stamps ($78 billion)".[1] That looks to me like Medicaid spending is nearly 8x that of EITC. And that's just Medicaid. Medicare spending is greater still, though I don't know the breakdown of Medicare spending by revenue source--FICA vs straight government subsidy. The subsidized component may be less than Medicaid, or may already be accounted for by Medicaid. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit Wikipedia's source is http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2013/08/federal-spending-by-the-numbers-2013 http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2013/08/federal-spe...
- 8note 5y agoIs it a fact that the highest quintile is higher in the states? I imagine that Putin and MBS are extraordinarily wealthy What evidence shows that to be a fact? Do these Americans have proven wealth, or is it all on paper?
- pipodeclown 5y agoI don't think moving to the top 20% is such a strange metric to look at. Isn't that the 'american dream'? This is especially so if you use it as a comparative metric. The study isn't solely looking at this metric to determine whether social mobility in the US is a thing, it is using it as a metric to compare social mobility with other countries, in that sense I think it is valuable.