5 ms·
For the sake of discussion, which age would you want to pause at? 16, 24 for insurance reasons?
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
For the sake of discussion, which age would you want to pause at? 16, 24 for insurance reasons?
- kyriakos 5y ago16 is too young and you won't be able to do a lot of things unless you walk around with paperwork all the time. 24 sounds good but I'd pick 30 cause looking 30 people take you a bit more seriously. You will be able to relate more with people in their 30swhen you are 50 but look 30 than with people in their 20s. Of course in this hypothetical scenario if everyone is not aging then it all cahnges.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoYeah, maybe a separate question would be what the age would be if everyone in society was forced to pause at that age. I wonder what immortal oligarchs would even do…
- clairity 5y agothey’d find other ways to kill each other. that’s not facetious—our egos depend on getting an edge, however microscopic, over others, and when that doesn’t happen, we get angry (that is, desperate and irrational) and do things we shouldn’t. it’s a tale as old as time. that ‘modern’, ‘developed’ civilizations haven’t devolved this way yet isn’t because we’re all so cultivated now, but because we’ve lived in an unusual period of extended growth and excessive abundance which keeps destructive competition at bay. but infighting (i.e., tribalism) has been rising over the past 50+ years and is threatening to overthrow that period of prosperity and civility.
- eska 5y agoI bet that assessment would cease to be the case once we have gotten used to 100 year olds that look 16
- kyriakos 5y agoThis assumes that treatment will be available to everyone and not just to select few.
- abracadaniel 5y agoPresumably the birth rate would plummet, so the number of 100 year olds choosing to look 16 would probably vastly outnumber the actual 16 year olds.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 5y agoThis doesn't work like that
- kyriakos 5y agoit works cause its just a philosophical discussion at this point.
- booleandilemma 5y ago16 is way too young. Assuming brain development is paused at that age, society would descend into some kind of Lord of the Flies hellscape.
- priansh 5y agoI would argue society is already a Lord of the Flies hellscape.
- silverpepsi 5y agoSpeak for your own brain, I didn't make particularly impulsive decisions at that age nor at 40 do I have a problem with the logic behind the conclusions my 16 yo self made (I obviously had less data to draw from which wouldn't be an issue at year 50 of being 16). Just sayin'
- pharke 5y agoLord of the Flies is such a tired example to hold forth. It's purely fictional and not generally representative of human behaviour. There is even a recorded incident of school boys being stranded on an island and living perfectly peacefully for more than a year https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/09/the-real-lord-of-the-flies-what-happened-when-six-boys-were-shipwrecked-for-15-months https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/09/the-real-lord-... Yes, humans can be violent but we are obviously more predisposed to be cooperative otherwise we would have never made it this far as a species. You can't put 10,000 unrelated members of any other species in one place and not expect chaos, with humans it's no problem as long as everyone involved has food in their bellies and the promise of going home after a few hours. That's our real defining trait, getting along with each other, our intelligence wouldn't do a lick of good if we didn't have that.
- toomuchtodo 5y ago35. Perfect balance between maturity and youth.
- ogwh 5y agoTell that to my hair follicles.
- InvaderFizz 5y agoI started supplementing testosterone for reasons unrelated to hair loss. It has completely stopped and even reversed my thinning on top after just a few months.
- germinalphrase 5y agoPresumably under the direction of a doctor?
- myfavoritedog 5y agoIf I could choose an age for my physical body that would last indefinitely? I'd choose 29.
- gremloni 5y agoProbably around 28 so I’m done growing to my final height.
- clairity 5y agoobserving professional sports, you find that despite physical fitness/attributes having already plateaued in the early-mid twenties, people reach peak athletic performance in our late twenties when our mental facilities have fully matured and we have some modicum of experience. 27-29 is probably exactly the maximizing range, for this reason.
- InvaderFizz 5y agoI'm not sure allowing the beginning of deterioration that occurs after around 25 is a good thing in this scenario. The mental maturity is most likely largely a result of experience. I'm sure it has some hormonal impact, but that doesn't automatically mean late 20s is superior if we can maintain the healing capacity of a 18 year old while increasing our experience and therefore ability to process the whole picture. I guess it comes down to: is the capacity of strategy developed as a result of age, or as a result of experience?
- clairity 5y agophysical deterioration doesn’t really become evident until after/around 30 (the end of the plateau). neural development happens well into our 20s, with a long plateau into our 30s and a gradual decline after that (only becoming substantial around retirement age). growth from experience seems to be substantial into the teens, where it hits an inflection point and starts to decelerate but still climbs, albeit more slowly over time, well into our 40s at least but possibly our whole lifetimes. we’d still get the most bang for buck if our age was ‘frozen’ in the late 20s because experience would still accumulate regardless, but we’d have maximized the combo of physical and mental growth. it’s only obvious in retrospect how immature we are at 18, both physically and mentally, or even at 25. that’s why sports is such a neat test bed, because it taxes both facilities enough to tease out these otherwise unnoticeable dynamics.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mikotodomo 5y agoAt 35. It's well known that human brain development does not end until past 30. Even before scientifically proven, intellectuals and teachers have observed anecdotes such as that singing only can begun to be mastered around the age 35. From Lilli Lehmann's How to Sing, page 108 (originally authored in the late 1800s): "No woman of less than twenty-four years should sing soubrette parts, none of less than twenty-eight years second parts, and none of less than thirty-five years dramatic parts; that is early enough."
- johnisgood 5y ago35 does sound like a great age to pause at.
- fallingfrog 5y ago26 was when I felt physically strongest and mentally sharpest, so I'd push the pause button there.