3 ms·
> You could be you in a tabletop game and bring all the stuff that you wanted to bring into it,” he said. “A tabletop game is limitless. A video game, by its ve
by ekianjo 5y ago
> You could be you in a tabletop game and bring all the stuff that you wanted to bring into it,” he said. “A tabletop game is limitless. A video game, by its very nature of how it’s designed, has some limits.”
Thats it? Such a uber long article to reach such a feeble insight? Not impressed, New Yorker
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoWhat a weird thing to say. Board games and video games are two very different media with different capabilities and limitations.
- needle0 5y agoI'd imagine one would have a tendency to consider what you're personally working on as superior in some way to something you're not.
- eru 5y agoA tabletop game is limited to (essentially) what you can make with cardboard and flavour text. You can add flavour text to a video game as well. FTL is a great example of that making the game feel much bigger.
- ekianjo 5y agoRPGs are not regular tabletop games. Nobody was talking about Monopoly in that article. The whole point was about pen and paper RPG vs video games.
- GuestHNUser 5y ago>A tabletop game is limited to (essentially) what you can make with cardboard and flavour text. Maybe for board games. But for tabletop rpgs, I think it's different. Games like Dungeons & Dragons are limited more by what you can describe with language and reasonably bookkeep without slowing down the pace of play.
- e12e 5y agoTabletop rpgs doesn't require any props. People do use rules, character sheets, dice - and anything from sketched maps to grids and miniatures - but essentially tabletop rpgs are less limited than say an author writing fiction.