6 ms·
The solution: paid overtime. Time and a half after 8 hours, time and a half after 5 days, and those multiply. This is why film scheduling is a serious discipli
by Animats 5y ago
The solution: paid overtime. Time and a half after 8 hours, time and a half after 5 days, and those multiply.
This is why film scheduling is a serious discipline and software scheduling is a joke.
- nexuist 5y agoThis is a brilliant idea and I'm curious if anyone has any opinions on why it wouldn't work. Paid overtime shifts financial responsibility to the PM who ordered overtime, because arguably a more competent PM would either push back against unrealistic deadlines or manage the team more efficiently to avoid overtime crunch. It sets the stage for competent management to prevail while incompetent managers are forced out of the org. I think this is great incentive structuring.
- makeitdouble 5y agoDevil's advocate: As paid overtime becomes more common, people start factoring it in production costs, and standard hour salaries are adjusted accordingly. When people negociate they get told "don't worry, with X hours of overtime you'll get a pretty good pay" and we're back to square one. For a real world examole of that, Japanese companies have had these kind of deals for a few decades.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoAt least those devs get something back for their crunch time then..
- eru 5y agoThe comment you replied to explained that the rates would be the same as now after some adjustment. (Of course, you can disagree with that.)
- hamstergene 5y agoThere are many countries where not paying for overtime >=2x is illegal, and nothing like that is happening
- meheleventyone 5y agoIt can really depend. For example in the UK there is the Working Time Directive which limits employers to a 48 hour maximum working week. Except the employee can opt out of it voluntarily and the power relationship means this is almost never actually voluntary. No doubt some places have strong laws but many have so much wiggle room the laws on the books look nothing like reality.
- makeitdouble 5y agoMost of these countries also have special statuses for skilled workers where the pay isn’t related to worked hours. In France it often was a separated contract you had to sign, but most people above “junior” level were pushed into it. It works pretty well in some companies, and heavily abused in others.
- Uehreka 5y agoIf that does happen then there was never going to be a way to fix this but no one is worse off. If that doesn't happen then the problem is at least somewhat fixed. Sounds like a good argument to give it a shot. I'm generally all for Devil's Advocate, but when it comes to giving workers reasons to _not_ demand more, I need to see some really compelling evidence of serious harm before I'm willing to tell people to reconsider.
- onion2k 5y agoI'm generally all for Devil's Advocate, but when it comes to giving workers reasons to _not_ demand more, I need to see some really compelling evidence of serious harm before I'm willing to tell people to reconsider. makeitdouble isn't saying workers shouldn't demand more; they're saying that paid overtime doesn't solve the problem of crunch time. It makes crunch time acceptable, and (potentially) gets factored into renumeration packages in the long term. If you want to solve the problem of crunch you need a solution that removes it, not one that pays people to continue doing it.
- Uehreka 5y agoIf crunch time continues but workers are making money commensurate with the fact that they're working outside reasonable hours, then I view that as progress. If base pay is depressed to make up for this change and workers make functionally the same amount, that's a bummer. But either way: I don't necessarily view crunch time as a thing that can or will be solved. I just want the game to be more fair than it is now.
- onion2k 5y agoCrunch doesn't really exist in large areas of the software industry. There's no reason why it can't be solved for gaming, especially at large, well-funded studios like CDPR.
- makeitdouble 5y agoTo add to onion2k’s point, a better “let’s give it a shot” alternative is to raise the base remuneration to account for the potential overtime. That way if you’re overflown with overtime it’s in your compensation, if you manage to not do any overtime you’ll benefit from it. It’s arguably harder to negotiate, but I think it would be the best way forward. Now, if the choice is between nothing and paid overtime, yes it’s worth it getting paid overtime.
- linspace 5y agoInsightful comment. And I will add that we constantly complain about how there are just a few hours daily of truly useful work. Adding more money will not change anything. Paid overtime also can give people the wrong incentives. Edit: what I mean is that we should not plan for overtime. Of course it should always be paid.
- smokey_circles 5y agoJust claiming an opposing stance isn't enough to validate it. This is just a silly opinion for the sake of argument. I live in a country with a 40-45 hour max work week. After that, you pay 1.5x rates. Saturdays are 1.5x rates for salaried workers and Sundays and public holidays are 2x. There are very serious legal consequences for trying to skirt the system. As paid overtime becomes the norm, it becomes another metric to track. Project managers that routinely run into overtime are punished. The same as any other expense caused by analysis failures. You seem to think paid overtime suddenly incentivises a company to just up the price of their product. Like it was equivalent equivalent the rising price of materials. It just doesn't work that way. Not everyone is a piss poor planner who can't react to changes in environments. Plenty of projects I've worked for have been pretty close to budget. When overtime is required, we talk to the customer. Their money, their decision ultimately. If your costs unexpectedly skyrocket, you're not keeping customers. I'm getting a little bored of these "qualification by differnce of opinion" reasoning. You've gotta actually qualify your opinion
- freewilly1040 5y agoYour comment is overly dismissive and provides no better evidence than the comment you are responding to. Not everyone is a poor planner, but deadlines become firm when large marketing spends are deployed, as they are in the gaming industry.
- ryandrake 5y agoHow do other kinds of software companies with large marketing spend deal with it? Hint: Often not with death march crunch time.
- meheleventyone 5y agoSome very badly run (although not unsuccessful) games companies scheduled in crunch as part of their project plan. Disturbingly some still might.
- meheleventyone 5y agoWe had paid overtime working on APB at Realtime Worlds across the whole salaried team. I do think it curbed the crunch a bit but did nothing for the project management side of things. There were so many things wrong with that project though it’s probably not a great case study. The other side of it is that people would work extra hours even if they didn’t need to which you might think is great but actually leads to lots of downstream effects because there is more to test that’s been written by people past their best. My personal take is that the overall discipline of managing software projects is so woolly and ill-understood to begin with that the incentives aren’t really there beyond the obvious fairness of actually paying people for the work they do. You don’t need a cost to competently push back against unrealistic processes.
- PeterisP 5y agoWell, CDPR had paid overtime (just as any other company is required by law in Poland and nearby European countries - the USA notion of programmers as exempt from overtime rules is, well, mostly USA-specific) and this apparently didn't work - the argument that "there should be paid overtime" does not seem to be relevant for this article at all.
- rebuilder 5y agoIt’s not that it wouldn’t work, it’s that in order for management to put this kind of restriction on their own power in place, they’d have to first admit they need it. People usually don’t like to tie their own hands. Now, if the employees unionised like in the film industry, it might happen.
- bogwog 5y ago> The solution: paid overtime The first step to getting there is a union.
- eru 5y agoWhat makes you think so? Mainstream economics would suggest that high productivity and plenty of competition between employers gets you benefits. That's what worked for programmers rather well. Thanks also to low barriers to entry for new companies. (Especially if you compare programmers to people in other industries, also in other countries and in other historical eras. That would make the impact of unions vs the factors I outlined above more apparent.) In any case, feel free to form or join a union, if you want to try it.
- myownpetard 5y agoPaid OT is not something an individual can negotiate for when it is unprecedented in the industry. It also wouldn't surprise me if major game studios have a handshake agreement to never offer paid OT. It would probably be easier to avoid a class action lawsuit for that than salary fixing a la Google and Apple et al.
- eru 5y agoYou don't have to negotiate explicitly. As a customer in retail you seldom negotiate explicitly with Burger or Walmart or Amazon directly, you just vote with your feet (and wallet). Investigate your potential employers before you take a job. If you like none of them, at least pick the lesser evil, or move into an adjacent industry. (Eg lots of game programmers are more than welcome in Internet or in finance etc.)
- myownpetard 5y agoIf you want to compel an industry to fundamentally change its compensation structure, history indicates that you do need to organize and negotiate collectively and explicitly. See the 8 hour workday and the 5 day workweek as examples.
- tedunangst 5y agoBecause films aren't delayed or go over budget?
- eru 5y agoI think it's less common. Especially for the shooting part. But I suspect it has more to do with most big films being made in relatively similar ways. It would be interesting to compare different film industries in different countries and different times. Eg classic Hollywood studio system, modern Hollywood, Bollywood, etc.
- kevinmchugh 5y agoI haven't seen the pay schedule detailed but i have read that CDPR paid for the overtime. At least for the Polish employees (who are guaranteed that pay by law)
- mackman 5y agoThere is paid overtime for some employees. Including engineers. Instead of a project completion bonus for other employees. It’s a bit of a wash.
- eru 5y ago> This is why film scheduling is a serious discipline and software scheduling is a joke. How would you test / falsify this?
- Animats 5y agoLook into how film completion bonds work. I wrote that up a few months back.[1] Film Finances has been doing completion bonds for video games since 2007, but I'm not finding much info about that. I wonder how the details work. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27687265 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27687265
- eru 5y agoThanks. Tangentially related: https://socialgoals.com/ https://socialgoals.com/
- krsdcbl 5y agoIsn't that common in Europe, even required by law in most of it's countries? I'm not sure about Poland though
- ivolimmen 5y ago> Isn't that common in Europe, even required by law in most of it's countries? I'm not sure about Poland though Yes. I live in the Netherlands and we have this. I am a software engineer and working in a free sector (meaning I don't have a union or common branch contract) but it's normal that overtime pays extra. It's also the reason I rarely work overtime. Plus it's fairly common to be compensated in time. So if I work on a Saturday I get 1,5 off on my paid vacation sheet. Sunday pays out 2.
- ithinkso 5y agoSo it's a bit better than in Poland then, we have 1.5x / 2x pay for overtime but it doesn't translate to number of vacation days i.e if you work on sunday you may either receive 2x pay or one extra vacation day.
- zorked 5y agoThis solution is the law in probably 99% of the countries?
- ithinkso 5y agoThis is exactly how it is in Poland, by law. 150% salary for weekdays+saturdays overtime (200% if at night) and 200% sundays and bank holidays. ~400 overtime hours a year hard limit.
- krzyk 5y agoSmall correction: Saturdays are also 200% (for the first 8hrs, the remaining ones are 150% - yeah, strange but I was bitten by it once).
- hailwren 5y agoGiven that CDPR are in Poland, I guess we can say it didn't work?
- ithinkso 5y agoIn the sense that it didn't pay off for CDPR. The developers were paid regardless.
- burntoutfire 5y agoIn general, in Poland most senior people work as (pretend) "contractors", because the taxes are drastically lower for them than for full-time employment (it's essentially a massive country-wide tax evasion scheme which is, at least for now, tolerated by the tax authorities). None of the labor protection laws (high overtime pay etc.) apply to them. I don't know if CDPR also hires a ton of "contractors", but I would be very surprised if they didn't - they'd be saying no to a ton of experienced people who just won't work as full time employees.
- krzyk 5y agoIt depends on companies, some corps do it, some don't. I worked in both types, usually contractors are treated as second class citizens, e.g. some perks don't apply to them. I have yet to see a company where contractors are majority.
- 5y ago
- danjac 5y agoAnd yet the movie industry - which has over half a century's head start over gaming - still has its fair share of studio excess, cost overruns and expensive flops.
- rasz 5y agoAll overtime at CD Project was paid in full accordance with EU policies. This isnt Japan/Korea where you cant leave your desk before supervisor even if it means sitting up to 23:00 doing nothing and not being paid for it.
- kingcharles 5y agoI quit the video game biz over crunch. When I was made to work three nights without sleep for some imaginary deadline, and staff came in on the fourth morning and they had to pry the gold CD out of my hand as I was asleep on the floor under my desk - that was the end for me. https://www.amazon.com/Abomination-PC/dp/B00001ZT3Z https://www.amazon.com/Abomination-PC/dp/B00001ZT3Z I left and became the World's #1 seller of Beanie Babies. (True story)