5 ms·
> you could say that you are a male/female or whatever and X years old and if someone ask you for proof, you would be able to provide it Identifying as male or
by smoldesu 5y ago
> you could say that you are a male/female or whatever and X years old and if someone ask you for proof, you would be able to provide it
Identifying as male or female is pretty much an arbitrary social structure in today's society. Your age is not.
- authed 5y ago> Identifying as male or female is pretty much an arbitrary social structure Are you sure that everyone's cells age at the same rate?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 5y agoHow is age not an arbitrary social structure? There is a lot of social structures and expectations tied to age that are just as arbitrary. People view you differently and there are laws which govern who you can and can not marry.
- quenix 5y agoAge is not an arbitrary social structure—it is a number directly proportional to the number of seconds that have passed since you exited your mother's womb. Gender expression is a social structure, however. Note that I am using the word 'gender expression' here rather than 'biological sex', which is not an arbitrary social structure. See the difference?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThen we should separate the concepts of temporal age from expressed age. For most purposes and matters, we should defer to the individual's expressed age of preference. I can think of few instances where someone's temporal age is more relevant than the expressed age.
- smoldesu 5y ago> For most purposes and matters, we should defer to the individual's expressed age of preference. Pray tell, what are some relevant "purposes and matters" where an expressed age would be more practical than a... legally binding one? My understanding was that age isn't just counted for the hell of it, since we have socially decided that younger people shouldn't be allowed to partake in certain "purposes and matters", as opposed to how we socially settled on the idea that men and women are equals.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>Pray tell, what are some relevant "purposes and matters" where an expressed age would be more practical than a... legally binding one? The premise of this case is that an individual wants to change their legal age to what they feel is their expressed age. This would enable them to take advantage of the legal and social practicalities of the younger age. Examples of why some purposes why someone might want to be treated as the age they identify with might be: To receive legal benefits corresponding to the age they identify as. Be protected against discrimination for representing their identified age. Compete in sporting events for their identified age. We have socially settled on the idea that mend and women are equals, and that people can identify as either men or women as they choose. Assuming someone is an adult, they are are considered equal. Why not allow the right to be treated as the age they identify with.
- smoldesu 5y ago> Assuming someone is an adult, they are are considered equal. Why not allow the right to be treated as the age they identify with. Not all adults are created equal. Again, society decided that there are hard limits on this for a number of reasons. I get that you're canvassing for some larger queer argument to be made, but it's not a like comparison. I can't identify as 45 years old and run for president just like how I can't identify as 65 years old and claim AARP benefits. You can assume the identity of those ages, but you won't collect any of the benefits that you've listed above.
- sascha_sl 5y ago>'biological sex', which is not an arbitrary social structure. it's still a potentially dangerous shorthand for typical normative and often simply assumed development that deviates more often than assumed, especially because we only really detect and diagnose it if it causes severe issues as "intersex". Also, gender and gender expression are not the same. The gender expression of a stone butch is pretty masculine, but their gender is not male. > age is not an arbitrary social structure That's not the reason age and gender are different. Both are relevant for how we treat people, but gender, at least with our current social assumptions, is an exclusive or, while old people have already been young.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>Both are relevant for how we treat people, but gender, at least with our current social assumptions, is an exclusive or, while old people have already been young. How do you reconcile this with fluid genders and non-binary genders?
- sascha_sl 5y agoI did. >at least with our current social assumptions Recognition of gender outside the binary is the exception rather than the rule, and people all around you make assumptions all the time that you can't correct. It's just descriptive of material circumstances that nonbinary people will face ignorance. We've made some progress, but it's slow. As a non-binary trans woman, it is absolutely common to have a "fallback binary gender" you'd rather be associated with facing this. You know, for casual encounters, when you don't feel like explaining yourself in detail. Or when accessing trans healthcare, which is often very binary and gatekeepy of everything else (for instance, in Germany you often get denied HRT with F64.8 "Other gender identity disorders", only F64.0 "Transsexualism" is eligible) Funnily enough, TERFs often want trans people to simply pretend like these conditions do not exist, and that it is their personal responsibility as non-cis people to further gender abolitionism (while they still suggest sex is an immutable super important thing).
- dragonwriter 5y ago> 'biological sex', which is not an arbitrary social structure ‘Biological sex’, the two-valued function of the multidimensional space of observed physical characteristics, is an arbitrary social structure, and one which has evolved over time.
- quenix 5y agoHrm, technically speaking that is true. Sex is not even binary—it is bimodal. I was trying to give a simple explanation
- pyuser583 5y agoCouldn’t you argue that “age expression” is a social construct, and should be represented on official documentation? Instead of “biological age?”
- kelseyfrog 5y ago> exited your mother's womb The problem with this is that it is arbitrary. Why this and not date of conception, or date from first heartbeat, or date from first word, or date from walking? Any response will attempt to reify the construct, but that doesn't actually do to constructivists what non-constructivists think it does.
- Dylan16807 5y agoThose all give you basically the same progression. I don't understand your objection. (Though using walking would have absolutely ridiculous and insulting edge cases.)