7 ms·
It does raise questions about how industrial disputes may unfold online. If picketing IRL factories is allowed, what would the law be on DDOS of an online busi
by HPsquared 5y ago
It does raise questions about how industrial disputes may unfold online.
If picketing IRL factories is allowed, what would the law be on DDOS of an online business by union members?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- josephcsible 5y agoThis isn't equivalent to picketing. It's more like sabotage.
- kesselvon 5y agoFlooding your public website form isn't a crime in the same way prank calling a customer service line isn't a crime.
- gruez 5y agoActually it is a crime (even though prank calling isn't a crime) because of the CFAA.
- Miner49er 5y agoPretty much anything done on a computer could be a crime because of the CFAA. It is extremely broad.
- nulbyte 5y agoA recent case at the Supreme Court has limited this, and it seems applicable here, on the face of it. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2021/06/supreme-court-overturns-overbroad-interpretation-cfaa-protecting-security https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2021/06/supreme-court-overturn... > the Court adopted a “gates-up-or-down” approach: either you are entitled to access the information or you are not. To me, it sounds like you are entitled to submit a job application or you are not. I don't see how a charge under the CFAA for submitting an application would stick, when they are inviting the public to submit applications.
- colejohnson66 5y agoSubmitting a single application would probably be OK, but the coordinated flood might not be
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoNonsense. Using a public form, which is clearly intended to be a public form, is not using a computer without authorization or in excess of authorization. You can't make someone using your computer a crime just by retroactively deciding that you don't like they way someone used it.
- josephcsible 5y agoTo be clear, are you saying you believe DDoS attacks are legal?
- oauea 5y agoFilling in a form a few times is not a DDoS attack, even if it's automated.
- bhhaskin 5y agoIntent matters, and the intent is clearly to deny services.
- coldacid 5y agoThat and denial of service doesn't even need to be something that "clogs up" technical systems. Just making it impossible for the HR people to work by overwhelming them is still a DOS attack.
- jdauriemma 5y agoThis isn't the case, though, the intent is to disrupt their ability to hire non-union workers by submitting bad data, not by taking down their ability to ingest data in general.
- Robotbeat 5y agoIsn’t ability to hire people a “service” in this context?
- aloisdg 5y agoNot OP, but I believe they should be legal in the case of a protest/strike lead by union members.
- ohCh6zos 5y agoThe constant underhanded tactics are the exact reason joining a union is immoral.
- gruez 5y ago>If picketing IRL factories is allowed, what would the law be on DDOS of an online business by union members? I'm pretty sure union/striking isn't a valid excuse to violate laws, and that "picketing IRL factories" doesn't violate any laws (ie. they do in on the sidewalk/public roads).
- g_sch 5y agoPerhaps surprisingly, whether picket lines are lawful is often a matter of legal contention when there's a strike. Company owners argue that they are obstructive (which is at least partially the point), and courts often grant injunctions or restraining orders placing limits on the size, location, or even existence of picket lines. A coal company in Alabama recently won a restraining order that fully prohibited a picket line at their mine: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/judge-issues-restraining-order-against-umwa-in-strike-on-warrior-met-coal/ar-AAQ4hIt https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/judge-issues-restraining-o...
- pc86 5y agoHave any of these restrictions been on people operating entirely on public property? The only ones I've ever seen typically entail trying to block access entirely, something that by definition almost requires access to private property unless you have a ton of people, which most picket lines don't.
- ziddoap 5y agoSubmitting a job application with false information does not violate any law that I am aware of (perhaps if it's a government position there is? I'm not sure). Manually submitting 50 job applications with false information also does not violate any laws that I am aware of. The focus then becomes on automation. But if I automate the job application process at 1 application/day, that's not illegal. So it becomes a balancing act between how fast I am automating, and how shoddily designed the application system is. I don't think it's as cut and dry as "this is illegal" or not.
- lordlimecat 5y ago
- jamil7 5y agoI can't remember the details exactly but there was a case in Germany in which a coordinated online and offline protest against Lufthansa was carried out, the online component being a denial of service attack on the airline's website. Lufthansa attempted to charge those response and the court dropped all charges - seeing it as a legitimate form of protest.
- spsful 5y agoRegardless, I can't see how anyone could fathom prosecuting thousands (if not millions?) of participants in a DDOS attack and actually being successful.
- ohCh6zos 5y agoYou probably don’t need to prosecute each and every one of them, just the biggest offenders.
- skeeter2020 5y agoIt would be much more effective to go after the facilitator who made it possible, in this case the developer. Both efficient and punative messaging-wise
- coldacid 5y agoThe German (and generally, almost all European) legal system is a very different beast to the American one. What might be dropped by the court there may very well be seen as legitimate and prosecutable on the other side of the Atlantic, and vice versa. For something happening in the USA, you'd be best served by precedents from the USA itself, then from other common law countries, before considering anywhere in mainland Europe.
- GordonS 5y agoI'm not an American, but from what I know of the US judicial system and the power corporations have, I would think the courts would come down very heavily on anyone doing this - they'd rot in jail.
- moolcool 5y agoThis isn't technically a DDOS though, is it? My understanding is that they're overwhelming humans' capacity to process the applications, rather than machines' capacity to process them.
- vageli 5y agoI don't see how the thing being overwhelmed matters for determining if a DDOS took place. For instance, I think many people would characterize the Church of Scientology's attack on the IRS [0] as a denial of service of sorts. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Snow_White https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Snow_White
- bee_rider 5y agoI don't think they'd characterize it that way in court. The Church of Scientology's dudes appear to have done a bunch of other illegal stuff in setting up for the requests. OTOH, if we're going to consider "sharing too much information to an individual for them to process it" to be a DDOS, there are a whole bunch of Terms of Service that will need to be rewritten. So maybe this is a good idea...
- newsclues 5y agoLow orbit ion canon was a n activist tool to ddos something by basically refreshing webpages
- interblag 5y agoWas just thinking this - and I also think quite a few people have been arrested for using it over the years, including some jail terms. While I'm not on Kellogg's side on this, I'm nervous for a lot of US residents who might be jumping on this bandwagon for lolz without understanding the potential consequences... (edit ... link: https://www.wired.com/2010/01/guilty-plea-in-scientology-ddos-attack/ https://www.wired.com/2010/01/guilty-plea-in-scientology-ddo...)
- advisedwang 5y agoHistorically, law enforcement, courts and at time even military force have been used to put down labour action when it goes outside the box the NRLA drew. So I have no doubt they would throw the book at this kind of action if they can get away with it. Even regular picketing sometimes gets sanctioned by the police. Just this October John Deere picketers were sanctioned for blocking a gate. [1] [1] https://nptelegraph.com/business/deere-wins-injunction-against-davenport-picketers-deere-official-says-it-was-needed-to-provide-safe/article_97dd6ff2-4031-57fd-a606-8bd3253b91d8.html https://nptelegraph.com/business/deere-wins-injunction-again...
- gruez 5y ago>Historically, law enforcement, courts and at time even military force have been used to put down labour action when it goes outside the box the NRLA drew. >Even regular picketing sometimes gets sanctioned by the police. Just this October John Deere picketers were sanctioned for blocking a gate. [1] Did those actions get put down because it was labor action, or was it because those actions were not acceptable? ie. if I said [unpopular thing] online, and a bunch of protesters showed up to my house and blocked my driveway, preventing me from going to work, would it be reasonable for the police to disperse those protesters? would it be reasonable for me to get an injunction against those protesters to prevent them from doing it again?
- beepbooptheory 5y agoAll "labor actions" have only become "acceptable" through sacrifices of people fighting for it. Its a hard thing to get companies to agree to make less profit, as making profit is how they justify their existence, and profit tends to fall, so they are incentived to fight even the smallest demands from workers. "Acceptability" is a dynamic thing, decided by those who write laws. Not sure how to respond to your example because its a different situation? Do you think workers are just angry in the same way the mob outside of your house is? Or do you maybe think they are just trying to survive in this world?
- gruez 5y ago
- skeeter2020 5y agopicketing explicitly CAN NOT prevent people from crossing the line. Though in practice it does just that, they have plausible deniability. A DOS attack is harder to use this defense, plus typically you attest that the information is correct so unless you're actually automating this will real information you could potentially be opening up that concern as well.
- lordlimecat 5y agoThere is a difference between picketing-- which is refusing to work-- and actually sabotaging company systems. The DDOS would fall under (among, I'm sure, other laws) the CFAA and could be a felony if someone wanted to pursue it.